MAGLEV Movement Idea
charlie belden
Any ideas come to mind that use this MagLev thing?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
MAGLEV Movement Idea
charlie belden
Any ideas come to mind that use this MagLev thing?
I like the way you think Charlie !
Don Orr
May have to try this one. I already have some magnets.
Re: MAGLEV Movement Idea
Bob Macgregor
It sounds interesting, Charlie.
If you had a flat, steel ring covering all the magnet heads in both the up and down parts of the structure, wouldn't that spread out/eliminate the rocking you described? Also, I think the rocking motion would be dependent on the rate of spin of the top, where certain rates would create harmonic/reinforcing wobble that would make repeated contact with the sides interfere with the spin a lot.
If you built in electromagnets instead of fixed ones and developed an appropriate controller for the electromagnets, you could make this into a motor, ie, drive its rotation just like the maglev trains move forward, by sequentially switching the magnets on and off.
BOB
Michael Faraday Belden,
Jorge Casta�eda
Charlie,
you are just about to discover the electric motor spinning in one direction or a generator spinning in the other.
Have you ever read James Clerk Maxwell?, he did further the electromagnetic field theory started by Faraday. Dig in there and maybe you come out with something.
I like the way your mind keeps popping things... Levitation was one of my teen age dreams. Alas, never master it.
Re: Michael Faraday Belden,
Jorge Casta�eda
Charlie,
I just remembered, that is the principle the high speed trains use, the monorail is one pole, the tran is the other.
Re: Michael Faraday Belden,
Steve Kubien
Jorge, levitation is easy. Just throw yourself at the ground...and miss. Oh wait, that's the art of flying. Sorry.
Steve
-really needs to read his Adams again
Re: MAGLEV Movement Idea
Steve Kubien
I have had a few similar ideas rumbling around inside my cranial vault for a while. Unfortunately, I've never made time to play with them because something always gets in the way. However, you may have spurred me on with this post. Thanks.
Steve
Re: MAGLEV Movement Idea
Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)
Years ago the owner of a science store challenged me to come up with a top that would hover over a base while spinning. I made a couple of them with magnets encased in a two piece spinning top, which looked identical to many of the ones turners typically turn. While the theory was sound, the practice needed more R&D than I had time or interest. The top would indeed hover, but it also spun off at a tangent almost immediately. Putting it in a container would allow it to hover longer, until it stopped spinning, but even that was short lived, as the friction generated by bumping into the container slowed it quickly. It did pulse up and down as the strength of the magnetic poles came into alignment on each rotation. Once it came to a stop, the poles would align to their attraction and it would stick to the base.
I suspect that the variable density of wood is part of the culprit. Something that is more uniform would be needed. But then, I am not an engineer, I am just a backward redneck turner who does stuff like this by the seat of my pants. 
Re: MAGLEV Movement Idea
John K Jordan
Bill,
I know a magnetics expert who has created many magnetic levitation devices over the years, some for huge rotating machinery. He used to little permanent-magnet motors that he could spin at such high speeds (in a vacuum) they would come apart and smear the pieces on the inside of the container!
I told him about an idea I had for something static or spinning levitated by permanent magnets and he said that without some physical constraint, such as a rod or the lip on charlie's bowl base, that stable levitation was not possible without active feedback and control (i.e., sensors and electronics). I'd still like to try the idea I had then because I think it would work, but I've been wrong before.
JKJ
Re: MAGLEV Movement Idea
charlie belden
The Electricity and Magnetism physics class, along with the Circuit Analysis class I took in college turned me on to Faraday and gave me the basics of the theories of electric motors and electro magnets. This one doesn't require understanding WHY, but merely the use of the directly observable WHAT - like magnetic poles repel each other - and using that observable fact to add actual movement to a turning.
As an aside, when I place one magnet with it's "north pole" down onto a thin steel disk - it sticks to the disk. But when I put another magnet, with its "north pole" directly under the first magnet - but on the bottom of the thin steel disk the first magnet is stuck to - rather than being repelled, it stick to the underside of the disk - regardless of which of the second magnet's pole is towards the underside of the disk. Have to think about why.
As noted, one of the challenges of using this maglev idea for the example turning is keeping any part of the "plate" from contacting the "base". I'm thinking an additional pair of magnets, one in the bottom center of the plate and one in the center of the base - with opposite poles facing each other might work, another solution would be to place a small diameter polished rod in the center of the underside of the platter and have its other end sit in a hole in the center of the base.
I'm not after a perpetual motion machine. I just want a piece that you can move and have it do something other than just sit there and look pretty - an interactive dynamic/kinetic piece. If the balance issue can be overcome, theoretically just blowing on the plate could cause it to move. Incorporate some "fins" and it might act like a Pin Wheel, but bob up and down as it rotates.
Just throwing out ideas for adding movement.
Re: MAGLEV Movement Idea
John K Jordan
>...rather than being repelled, it stick to the underside of the disk - regardless
>of which of the second magnet's pole is towards the underside of the disk.
>Have to think about why.
Look at the (imaginary) lines of force around a magnet which always seek the path of least resistance. In air, they extend uniformly far from each end of a symmetrical bar magnet and curve around to meet the opposite pole. When you place a magnet on a ferromagnetic disk which is larger than the cross-section of the magnet, the lines are "short-circuited" by the disk. Very little if any force will make it through the disk.
This effect is more or less pronounced with different materials. Mu-metal is one of the best for stopping magnetic fields. I used to use small sheets of it to shield CRT monitors from the magnets in desktop speakers.
A physical constraint, such as the rod you mentioned, is one of the best and least sophisticated means of dealing with the lateral stability problem.
JKJ
Re: MAGLEV Movement Idea
Jorge Casta�eda
Charlie,
It is more than half a century since I was into magnetism, (and perpetual motion),
I did lots of experiments and found that the magnets seem to invert their polarity in certain conditions. One of my kind of "successful" experiments was with fix magnets in the moving part and miniature electromagnets in the fix part and a commutator, the shifting field induced the rotation.
Re: MAGLEV Movement Idea
charlie belden
Jorge:
Using electromagnets complicates things - external power source, controller of some sort, wires sticking out, an electricl outlet necessary. This idea is pretty simple and straight foreward and anyone can give it a try. And if they come up with soemthing fun and interesting - I hope they share what they�ve found. If I use it I�ll put it up on YouTube or figure out how to embed the video here. Maybe a large lidded box with a floating, rotating, bobbing lid.
Re: MAGLEV Movement Idea
Bob Macgregor
This is one of those times that I wish I were any good at illustration, since I'm not sure how clearly I can explain my thinking here.
I think a major problem is lateral instability...any spin will be dampened by hitting the sides (or whatever restrains the wobble). One possible way to the floating piece from actually contacting the sides is to make the levitation a vector with both horizontal and vertical components
in its exaggerated form, this would be a cone within a cone, but it could just as easily be in the lip of a lid or the inside curve of a bowl or platter base... angled up and in from the bottom piece and correspondingly out and down from the top piece (or in and down from the top and out and up from the bottom if the top overlaps/hangs over the bottom).
Any tendency for pulsing, wobble, or harmonic motion would still be there, but inverse square law makes it unlikely that this could ever force actual wood-to-wood contact; the closer it got to hitting the sides, the stronger the force pushing it back.
The very critical factor here (and one I do not have confidence that I could pull off!) is getting all the magnet heads perfectly aligned (same angle and insetting)...there's probably some clever jig that would do this, but its beyond me to visualize it, much less successfully create one!
BOB
Re: MAGLEV Movement Idea
Jorge Casta�eda
Charlie, yes it becomes complicated with wires.
Your idea may work in a basically the shape of a "drop spindle", a flyweel pierced by a thin shaft, the bottom of the shat in a hole and the top trough another hole in an inverted u shape connected to the base.
For whatever is worth, back when, I seldom used even numbers, seems that odd numbers worked better.
Bob: This Sort of Your Idea?
charlie belden
ps: I'd like, with your permission, to use this illustration on my site with acknowledgement to you as its source. Would that be OK with you?
Two More Magnet Ideas
charlie belden
Re: Two More Magnet Ideas
Bob Macgregor
I think the problem here is that the most stable position would be in the "attract" one. If you rotated it to "repel", it would automatically slide sideways until it was either resting wood-to-wood or was in "attract".
Carrying this further, unless magnets were spaced very closely, any of the maglev attempts would likely run into the same problem: the piece would rotate until it stabilized between magnets. In fact, it would resist moving off this stable (non-levitated) position.
This would be true even if configured with magnets angled in facing each other, as I suggested in an earlier post...again, unless you could nearly eliminate the gap between the magnets.
BOB
What is possible vs not possible
John K Jordan
Don't publish this until you try it. I am certainly not a magnetics expert but I do know one. He told me once that stable static levitation with permanent magnets is not possible, without, as I mentioned earlier, some physical constraint such as a rod or the sides of the object or some active control. If a STATIC levitation is not needed, you can use gyroscopic principles and create stable levitation by spinning the object. Or use a superconductor (remember the classic suspension of a magnet over a wafer of high-temperature superconducting material in a dish of liquid nitrogen?)
Note the comment about diamagnetic properties in the Wikipedia article on magnetic levitation:
Stability Earnshaw's theorem proved conclusively that it is not possible to levitate stably using only static, macroscopic, paramagnetic fields. The forces acting on any paramagnetic object in any combination of gravitational, electrostatic, and magnetostatic fields will make the object's position unstable along at least one axis, and can be unstable along all axes. However, several possibilities exist to make levitation viable, for example, the use of electronic stabilization or diamagnetic materials; it can be shown that diamagnetic materials are stable along at least one axis, and can be stable along all axes.
Static stability means that any small displacement away from a stable equilibrium causes a net force to push it back to the equilibrium point.
The details, as usual, are not trivial. The proof uses a bit of math:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earnshaw%27s_theorem
BTW, Earnshaw developed his theorem in 1842.
This article discusses how the theorm relates specifically to magnetism:
http://www.mathpages.com/home/kmath240/kmath240.htm
There is more on this interesting page
http://www.coolmagnetman.com/maglev.htm
including this reference to an article in Nature:
Nature 400, 323 - 324 (1999) � Macmillan Publishers Ltd.
Nature magazine, July 22,1999, p323
Magnet levitation at your fingertips
A. K. GEIM, M. D. SIMON, M. I. BOAMFA & L. O. HEFLINGER
The stable levitation of magnets is forbidden by Earnshaw's theorem, which states
that no stationary object made of magnets in a fixed configuration can be held in
stable equilibrium by any combination of static magnetic or gravitational forces,.
Earnshaw's theorem can be viewed as a consequence of the Maxwell equations, which
do not allow the magnitude of a magnetic field in a free space to possess a maximum,
as required for stable equilibrium. Diamagnets (which respond to magnetic fields with
mild repulsion) are known to flout the theorem, as their negative susceptibility results
in the requirement of a minimum rather than a maximum in the field's magnitude,.
Nevertheless, levitation of a magnet without using superconductors is widely thought
to be impossible. We find that the stable levitation of a magnet can be achieved using
the feeble diamagnetism of materials that are normally perceived as being
non-magnetic, so that even human fingers can keep a magnet hovering in mid-air
without touching it.
If you want some fun, order your very own superconductor levitation kit:
http://matchrockets.com/ether/superconductor.html
http://www.users.qwest.net/~csconductor/Experiment_Kits/Demonstration%20Kits.htm
There is a great deal about this in the technical literature. Perhaps you would find some interesting things with the help of Mr. Google. Note that I'm not suggesting you don't even try - I hope you succeed and become famous.
JKJ
Re: MAGLEV Movement Idea *LINK*
Kevin Stanbary - McHenry, IL
I don't really have much to contribute to this conversation directly, but I stumbled across this page a while back and saved it because I thought it was cool. I have no affiliation to this company, but looks like they might have information relevant to this discussion...
http://www.kjmagnetics.com/proddetail.asp?prod=LEV2
Profiles
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
Kevin,
I'd have sent you an e-mail, but you chose not to list your e-mail. Your helpful message has waited since 1:30 (it's now 8:00 California time, but I think this forum runs on East Coast time, so it's really later), because you put a web reference in the message. I approved it a couple of minutes ago to post.
If you'll take a minute to establish a profile - go to the FAQs at the top of the page and look at Item #3 in "How do I Use These Messageboards?" - you'll be able to put links in the messages in a way that will load directly to the board. You'll also be able to show pictures of your work easily.
This is NOT required to participate here - it does give you more choices and works more smoothly.
Bill Houghton, a moderator
Re: Two More Magnet Ideas
Dave Belser
Fun ideas Charlie, but as John pointed out (with references) stable levitation is not possible without a constraint. I have a mag-lev spin toy that was given to me this past Christmas. It uses a point on one end that rests against a stop and spinning it makes it gyroscopicly stable. It always crashes when it spins down and is actually quite tricky to give it just the right spin.
I made a prototype piece with a top that pops off when the alignment is right it kind of works but needs more refinement. I have an improved one drawn up but haven't made it yet.
Maybe in time for Hartford.
Not After Perpetual Motion - just going for . . .
charlie belden
another way of allowing a turning to actually move - rotate a little, bob up and down a little and maybe a bit of Tilt-A-Whirl - when someone touches it - or maybe just blows on it. I'm after another way to allow a piece to behave in an unexpected way - and maybe get people to play with it. If that results in a little surprise and delight or a smile the piece would be a success.
Doesn't seem to be difficult to make the parts to try this idea - see

Re: Not After Perpetual Motion - just going for .
John K Jordan
For another type of movement (that doesn't involve magnets) you might try balancing one piece on a needlepoint extending upwards from a base or downwards from the upper part. The needle can bear against a dimple in a small piece of metal. This would swing and spin and wobble in different ways depending on where the balance point was relative to the center of gravity. For even more fun, embed a magnet in it horizontally and make the piece into a compass - if spun, it will eventually stop in the same position relative to the earth.
BTW, speaking of compasses, did you know the earth's magnetic field tends to magnetize any piece of iron or steel left in the same position for a sufficient length of time? The resultant magnetic field is very weak but detectable. You can show this with an ordinary compass - hold it near the bottom of a steel refrigerator or washing machine and one point of the needle will point to the object. Move the compass slowly up the side to the top and the compass will reverse. This also works on smaller items such as steel cans which have been left on the shelf for some time - the same pole is always on the bottom. This might not work so well at the magnetic equator.
As for your drawing, if you want a smoother rotation you can eliminate the poles from the two rings of individual magnets and use a pair of solid ring magnets mounted concentric to your pin.
JKJ
Prototype of Part One of MagLev Idea Done
charlie belden
Did a quick and dirty prototype. Took longer to glue on the 32 magnets that it did to turn the wood parts to attache them to. With 32 opportunities to super glue myself to the parts I managed to stick myself to only one : o
Now I just need to turn something to sit on top and see how THAT works out.
By using multiple rod magnets I can tune the lift by adding or removing magnets.

pic is slightly smaller than actual size - base is a tad under 3"