Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Students n Teachers

Posts

Students n Teachers

#1

Students n Teachers

Guy Bratt

What started as an attempt to classify students has morfed into whos a better turner via sanding preferances. As a three year old er 57 year old turner with 3 years experiance. I would like to know where I stand with my skills. I think the AAW could help estabilish some criteria. I believe sanding requirements alone are not enough. A published standardized set of skills would help students position themselves in classes they'd like to take.

As for teaching skills... I would think it more important to know when and why to use a particular method over another. Diversity of skills is also important. Bowl making isn't the pinnical of the craft/art. Tery Scott for example, expert at large and odd shaped turning. Can he turn a 36" trembular? Probably. Expert? Only he knows.

Re: Students n Teachers

#2

Re: Students n Teachers

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Guy, there is only one criterion for those who are not trying to earn a living at turning.

Are you having fun?

Everything after that is optional. It's a hobby for crying out loud. It is supposed to be fun. If it were my hobby, and I wasn't having fun, I would change it.

I earn my living at this stuff, so I have a different hobby. My hobby is shooting guns. I love shooting. I am not very good at it on some days. Some days I am a crack shot. But you know what? Most of the time I don't care. I spend most of my shooting time killing tin cans and plastic bottles, because that is what is fun for me. Some of my friends get the most fun out of sitting at a bench and trying to put holes in paper as close to one another as possible from 100 yds away. Still others like to shoot at things flying through the air. I mainly shoot holes in the air. But I have fun.

Turning is supposed to be fun. The only competition should be with yourself, at least at the beginning stages. Years ago there was a huge argument on this very forum about hollowing tools. Two camps quickly developed - those who thought that captured hollowing rigs were the devil's own creation, and those who thought they were the greatest thing since the invention of the wheel. But I can promise you that a person picking up a hollow form knows nothing about what tool might have been used, just as they most likely know nothing about what sandpaper was used to finish the surface. Now, in some cases one can see at what grit a person stopped sanding, but on a well finished piece, no one knows, and most people don't care where someone started. It is the finished product that counts. Did you have fun making it? Did the person who received it appreciate it? This is what counts, not what sandpaper you started with, or what tool you used to get to the end.

And even though this is my profession, it has to be fun. I hate doing stuff when I am not having fun. Life is too short to be dreary. So go have fun, and don't worry about what grit you are using, or what tool makes the cut, unless you aim is to have more fun doing it.

Re: Students n Teachers

#3

Spot on!

Jeff Willaford

Well stated, Bill !

For me - It's a hobby... and loaded with enjoyment. As for competition... I feel good when someone else appreciates my turnings but I feel great when I manage to improve in an area or when I accomplish something I never thought I could do even if it's only a 'draft' version. Plenty of folks have more experience, skill and/or creativity than I do and some have less but I bet very few have more fun.

I say keep the fun coming my way.

Re: Students n Teachers

#4

Steven Antonucci

"Classify" is not a negative word

Steven Antonucci

When we were in school, there were advanced classes, average classes, and remedial classes for all academic subjects. We were tested to be placed into the right groups, since it wouldn't make a lot of sense to put a remedial math student in Calculus coursework.

We graduate the "free" system and go to college, where we can take whatever we want (and pay for it). Still, we are tested to make sure we aren't getting into Harvard with a D+ potential.

I will continue to contend that short of watching someone turn, you can pretty well guess what they are doing at the lathe by looking at their work. I am not sugegsting that the AAW stamps this classification on your membership card, but as someone who instructs frequently, I spent a lot of time gathering requirements.

I completely agree with Bill that this should be fun. Among the turners I have spent time instructing, there is a common thread. They enjoy turning, but are frustrated that they aren't getting better.

"the dreaded skew..."

"I still get lots of catches..."

"how do I get rid of tool marks?"

"I afraid of.."

There is a technique in industry called Six Sigma, which is aimed at reducing error rates. The goal is not to fix problems when they occur, but to eliminate problems at the source before they get created. Competent tools skills are the source of 95% of all problems.

Having these skills is a little bit of work, but creates the opportunity to have fun in a stress free environment. The one club that I belong to has seen the quality of the work vastly improve because a bunch of us have worked at the basics. It is an additive process too. Once we all have tools skills, we can move to the next topic and the whole group benefits. You know you are doing it right when the students are now working with new turners...

I am glad that lots of folks have taken the time to contribute to this discussion, too. Lots of good conversation.

Steve

Re: Students n Teachers

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: Students n Teachers

Keith Tompkins

It's funny, after you have been teaching for a while, you priorities change. Some of my favorite students were not necessarily the best turners. It's important not to judge a person by their level of turning skill, but to simply recognize them as fellow human beings and treat them with respect. I've had students take me out to dinner after a class just to thank me for being patient with them after a bad experience elsewhere. I can usually tell how a class is going by the looks on a turner's face....someone who has been struggling suddenly has a big grin on their face...they GOT it! It's important to acknowledge those moments; and give them a bit of praise. Those students may never become world-class artists, but they are great people to be around, and I'm always thrilled when they sign up for a new class with me. When someone emails a pic of a piece they completed, and says "thanks"... that's a rewarding experience.

Re: Students n Teachers

#6

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Galen Vetterick

Re: Students n Teachers

#7

Re: Student or just having fun

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Very nice Galen! It looks like you even got the "grain" going right. :D So let me see, .357 mag, or possibly .38 Special with a semiwadcutter, .45 ACP, .45 Colt, .30-30, and .30-06, or possibly .300 Winchester mag. How close did I come?

I've got a job in the shop right now to turn "bullets" for two 3" shells. My neighbor's boy is going into the artillery, and he got these casings somewhere. I am turning the "projectiles" and then drilling the center out for a lamp.

Re: Students n Teachers

#8

Re: Student or just having fun

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

Hey Bill...shooting IS fun....you sort of missed on the '06 or 300 mag. Not a 300 Mag because it isn't belted. I was lucky enough to be in the business for about 30 years. Sold guns, ammo, and other related sporting goods. This gave me a good excuse to spend a lot of time on the rifle and pistol range. I belonged to a R&P club so did some competitive shooting. I even got to spend time with trap and skeet shooting.

At one point I had 46 firearms...lots of them just trading material. Now I'm down to 3 and I haven't fired any of them for a long time. I have a friend and neighbor who spends time on the pistol range. One of these days I'm going to accept his invitation to go along.

Wally

Re: Students n Teachers

#9

I'm going shooting.

john lucas

I'm going to take a couple hours off today and punch some holes in a target. I need to practice with my new carry gun. It's been too cold out but today will be fine and I need a break.

Re: Students n Teachers

#10

Your forgetting one thing

john lucas

The school where you teach has to fill the classes. At the Craft center where I teach they have a hard time filling classes listed as advanced. If you list a class as only a beginner class, same thing. They can list a class as beginner to intermediate and fill the classes. Depending on who the instructor is the students could be anywhere from beginning to advanced. It sort of depends on how the class is advertised.

The other problem is, suppose you are a really good spindle turner and take a class from Binh Pho on turning thin and piercing. Your skills in that area might be slightly above beginner.

In other words, it's awfully hard or impossible to classify a person's skill. The schools try to classify the skills needed for that class, which is also difficult, partly because the students are then trying to classify themselves and as someone said they tend to rate themselves higher.

It's kind of funny I think. The turners who have been turning for 2 or 3 years rate themselves higher and the turners who have been turning for a long time tend to rate themselves low. I think that's because the long time turners have been around some of the people with really great skills and we don't see ourselves there yet.

Re: Students n Teachers

#11

Re: I'm going shooting.

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

John....you're packing heat now? Are things in Tenn. that bad?

I live in the Wild Wild West where our state leg. just enacted a law that we CAN pack a firearm in a bar......Sheesh

Wally

Re: Students n Teachers

#12

Re: I'm going shooting.

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Wally, I've been packing since before I was turning. It's not how bad it is, it is what can happen anywhere. As I explained to one of my recent students, I get total strangers just walking into the shop on a regular basis. All of a sudden there is someone standing there. Sometimes it is idle curiosity, sometimes they want directions, and sometimes it is someone trying to sell me something. Some of my neighbors have had uninvited guests looking for things to steal, sometimes while they are home! We live two miles from a major drug corridor between two cities here in PA. I haven't had to shoot anyone yet, but who knows the real reason some of these characters just walk into a strange building with no signs indicating it is open to the public?

And this doesn't even address the critters that can come exploding out of the woodpile while I am out there working on blanks or cutting firewood. :O Most just want to go the other way, but some can be ornery, and smell real bad to boot.

Re: Students n Teachers

#13

Re: I'm going shooting.

john lucas

Wally Been packing since they passed the law in Tennessee about 8 year ago. I'm with Bill. I actually live in a pretty safe area and crime in general has been down in Tenn. ever since they passed the concealed carry permit. The problem is, you just can't predict when or where it might happen and I choose not to be a victim.

One of my neighbors came home from work and thought he saw something in the garage. He went out to investigate and someone stabbed him and ran off. He was OK and the police think it was a robbery. With all the drugs and people out of work you just never know when something will happen.

I know I pose no danger to anyone else while I carry my weapon and might be able to save someone's life. Besides, if it's on me instead of the house, they can't steal it. Consequently I choose carry it whenever I can.

Re: Students n Teachers

#14

Re: I'm going shooting.

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

I live in a retirement town of about 30,000 people. We're 30 miles south of Tucson and 40 miles north of Nogales, Mexico. Many thousands of illegals come through our area weekly. They don't stop and we seldom see them. The Border Patrol has a big presence here. They're headed for other areas where there might be work. Most are just good people looking for a better life, but a few are bad guys looking for trouble.

I-19, which runs from The border to I-10 in Tucson is a major route for drugs coming from Mexico to the US. Again, they don't stop here. A couple of years ago some idiot who has never been west of New Jersey wrote an article in a magazine listing the 10 best and 10 worst places to retire. Our town, Green Valley made the list of 10 worst. CNN picked up on that and it made national news. The author had read about the drugs heading for the big cities of the US and decided that of course Green Valley was a hotbed of drugs. The people here got a boot out of that. The chamber of Commerce and the real estate dealers did not.

I would defy the stupid author to find even one drug dealer selling drugs to the 70 and 80 year oldsters who live here.....Oh yeah, we're stickin' it up our noses or smokin' it. A constant party.

However, It is a good reason to have a firearm or 2 in the house, which I do.

Wally

Re: Students n Teachers

#15

Re: I'm going shooting.

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

I live in a nice middleclass subdivision and St. Cloud use to be known as Sleepy Old St. Cloud. I carry a firearm anywhere legal and even around the homestead. We do have some critters around but they don't worry me as much as the two legged, bloodsucking, dirtbags that have moved into a million new subdivisions in the area. The air is filled with Tribal drum music at 200 decibels, loud mufflers on small cars, and the smell of some of the God awfullest food known to mankind.

If I venture out in my truck I have my pretty .357 on the seat next to me, around the shop I have the 9mm on my hip, and in the bedroom is a 12ga. pumpaction shotgun with 00 buck loaded and ready.

It has been at least 50 years since I have shot at a living being but the urge is getting stronger as I get older.

It will probably wind up being my foot.

Re: Students n Teachers

#16

Steve Kubien

Re: I'm going shooting.

Steve Kubien

Perhaps arthritis meds?

Re: Students n Teachers

#17

Don Pencil

Re: "Classify" is not a negative word

Don Pencil

Steve,

Now we are getting somewhere. You are correct in saying "Classify" is not a negative word.

It is just of no value concerning the students capability level. An instructors desire to suggest a general class level for a given subject to taught is another thing.

Having said that would you please help me to better to understand two other of your comments made in this post.

1. "When we were in school, there were advanced classes, average classes, and remedial classes for all academic subjects. We were tested to be placed into the right groups, since it wouldn't make a lot of sense to put a remedial math student in Calculus coursework."

Am I to understand that you test all of you potential students before allowing them to sign up for a class? That is exactly what your comment states must be done. I for one would be very interested knowing how you do that. Perhaps if we all understood how this is done for all of the private instructors, private schools, commercial classes, adult schools then we could all get our heads around the testing and classifying of all students before the session begins.

2. "I will continue to contend that short of watching someone turn, you can pretty well guess what they are doing at the lathe by looking at their work."

Personally I have reviewed turnings that were flawlessly finished, uniform thickness, well disigned works that I watched being produced with the most crude turning tools and techniques I have ever seen and were fit for any gallery iin the world. And there have been others that were equally as well done (but certainly no better) that were done in my presents with the finest of tools and techniques. When finished they appear to be of equal quality.

Please explain how you can tell by looking at these works what the turner was doing at the lathe. As I know of no professional or other who can do this it would be informative and helpful to us all if you could enlighten us.

Thank you in advance,

Don

Re: Students n Teachers

#18

Re: I'm going shooting.

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

I should have read the other posts. I just assumed the thread had turned to serious shooting. Last gun I made was a potato cannon using PVC pipe. I did make rubber band guns in my youth that fired little linoleum squares. We even took them onto school grounds.

Re: Students n Teachers

#19

Re: smell real bad.

adrien

Bill, you shoot one of those black and white pussy cats, the smell will be around forever. :)

Re: Students n Teachers

#20

Steven Antonucci

Answers to your questions:

Steven Antonucci

1. "When we were in school, there were advanced classes, average classes, and remedial classes for all academic subjects. We were tested to be placed into the right groups, since it wouldn't make a lot of sense to put a remedial math student in Calculus coursework."

Am I to understand that you test all of you potential students before allowing them to sign up for a class? That is exactly what your comment states must be done. I for one would be very interested knowing how you do that. Perhaps if we all understood how this is done for all of the private instructors, private schools, commercial classes, adult schools then we could all get our heads around the testing and classifying of all students before the session begins.

No, I test them before I begin the session. I want to know who I have to watch for dangerous habits, and I want to group people who have the same needs together. If I have a mix of skills, I try to put a more experienced student with them, or notify the workshop assistant that some folks might need some additional help. The goal is that everyone becomes better, but not necessarily all at the same things.

If there was a way to assess prior to sign-up, I'd be all for it. I try to speak to as many of the people as I can before to get an idea of who is where, and then begin with stepping up to the lathe. If they can't mount work safely or stand in the line of fire, i spend more time with them up front and slow down the rest of their program until I see that they got it.

2. "I will continue to contend that short of watching someone turn, you can pretty well guess what they are doing at the lathe by looking at their work."

Personally I have reviewed turnings that were flawlessly finished, uniform thickness, well disigned works that I watched being produced with the most crude turning tools and techniques I have ever seen and were fit for any gallery iin the world. And there have been others that were equally as well done (but certainly no better) that were done in my presents with the finest of tools and techniques. When finished they appear to be of equal quality.

In general, beginner work is pretty obvious. Can someone produce a masterpiece without good technique? Sure, but if it looks like a duck, and walks like a duck- it's probably a duck. Shape is a good indicator, as are uniformity, and cleanness of the cuts. If you've every tried to sand out a big catch, you know how hard it is to get down past the dig. Most new turners simply don't remove those marks, and if you got a dig, it's a tool skill issue.

I also look for cracked wood- new turners will SAVE everything. Why? Because they probably have invested a significant amount of time in getting that far. If I crack a piece, I burn it.

None of these are cast in stone. We have a club member in one of my clubs who produces the type of work you describe: Excellent, flawless but with very average tools skills. Do you know what he says to me? "I need to get better with my tools so I can stop beating myself up and work as efficiently as you do." He gets it. It is not about me being a better turner than him, but about him being a better turner than he currently is- and I can help him get there.

Please explain how you can tell by looking at these works what the turner was doing at the lathe. As I know of no professional or other who can do this it would be informative and helpful to us all if you could enlighten us.

I'm not sure if that helps you- but I think I did the best I could. If you paid for an intermediate class with me to learn hollowing, wouldn't you be upset if a brand new turner required all of my attention to teach them how to turn? If you were an instructor, how would you handle it? Would you spend the time to catch them up (because they overestimated their abilities) or would you "drop them" and focus on the material you intended to present?

Teaching turning is a lot harder than turning. When I started demonstrating, I found out that I could be in mid-process, and 1/2 the crowd was lost. If you get that in a classroom, it's a long day.

Definitely taking notes for September. I promise that at least 1/2 of my class will be able to cut the inside of a bowl one handed at the end of the weekend, and everyone will move up two grits...

Steve

Re: Students n Teachers

#21

Don Pencil

Re: Answers to your questions:

Don Pencil

Steve,

At this time I am going to move on. Your insistance on defending these positions is amazing to me and I just do not have the time to continue what is becoming a pointless thread.

It was of value as it has brought to light the value, purpose, and need of correct woodturning instruction when it is at its best by several of our countries best instructors. The responces to the posts and the private e-mails I am getting indicate that most of the woodturning community gets it.

It is like what others have said, when a turner gets the message it is a great feeling for them and the for the instructor. I hope you too will someday get it concerning instruction. It is a very special feeling.

As you have stated, it is true that all of these students will come away a better turner if they master the proper techniques of woodturning.

You to will be a better instructor if you will listen to the advice given by master instructors and master the proper techniques of instruction

I wish you well in in your teaching.

Don

I know several professional woodturners make a lot of money selling "cracked" bowls. If you cannot turn a cracked bowl let me know and I will send a beginner over to show you how. You could make a lot of money.

Re: Students n Teachers

#22

Keith Tompkins

Re: Students n Teachers

Keith Tompkins

Something I do during my classes....When a student is having trouble, say torn end grain on a spindle turning, I show them the way I overcome the problem. Sometimes, it's not the way the student remembers it from a DVD they have watched and emulated, or how they were shown by a former teacher. I explain to them: You don't have to do this my way, but I would like you to at least try it. Then, decide for yourself if you prefer one method over another. I'll show you what works for me, if it works for you, fine. If not, that's ok too. By absorbing something from each instructor, and applying it, you will begin to develop your own turning style. For example, I had a student who was producing bottle stoppers and such for craft venues. Each stopper took 45 minutes to complete...mostly time spent sanding out deep endgrain tearout. Last time we spoke...3 minutes. I teach design concepts in ALL my classes, even the very beginner classes. I feel that if a turner begins with a balanced approach, and can develop an eye for good form, they will progress at a faster rate.