Answers to your questions:
Steven Antonucci
1. "When we were in school, there were advanced classes, average classes, and remedial classes for all academic subjects. We were tested to be placed into the right groups, since it wouldn't make a lot of sense to put a remedial math student in Calculus coursework."
Am I to understand that you test all of you potential students before allowing them to sign up for a class? That is exactly what your comment states must be done. I for one would be very interested knowing how you do that. Perhaps if we all understood how this is done for all of the private instructors, private schools, commercial classes, adult schools then we could all get our heads around the testing and classifying of all students before the session begins.
No, I test them before I begin the session. I want to know who I have to watch for dangerous habits, and I want to group people who have the same needs together. If I have a mix of skills, I try to put a more experienced student with them, or notify the workshop assistant that some folks might need some additional help. The goal is that everyone becomes better, but not necessarily all at the same things.
If there was a way to assess prior to sign-up, I'd be all for it. I try to speak to as many of the people as I can before to get an idea of who is where, and then begin with stepping up to the lathe. If they can't mount work safely or stand in the line of fire, i spend more time with them up front and slow down the rest of their program until I see that they got it.
2. "I will continue to contend that short of watching someone turn, you can pretty well guess what they are doing at the lathe by looking at their work."
Personally I have reviewed turnings that were flawlessly finished, uniform thickness, well disigned works that I watched being produced with the most crude turning tools and techniques I have ever seen and were fit for any gallery iin the world. And there have been others that were equally as well done (but certainly no better) that were done in my presents with the finest of tools and techniques. When finished they appear to be of equal quality.
In general, beginner work is pretty obvious. Can someone produce a masterpiece without good technique? Sure, but if it looks like a duck, and walks like a duck- it's probably a duck. Shape is a good indicator, as are uniformity, and cleanness of the cuts. If you've every tried to sand out a big catch, you know how hard it is to get down past the dig. Most new turners simply don't remove those marks, and if you got a dig, it's a tool skill issue.
I also look for cracked wood- new turners will SAVE everything. Why? Because they probably have invested a significant amount of time in getting that far. If I crack a piece, I burn it.
None of these are cast in stone. We have a club member in one of my clubs who produces the type of work you describe: Excellent, flawless but with very average tools skills. Do you know what he says to me? "I need to get better with my tools so I can stop beating myself up and work as efficiently as you do." He gets it. It is not about me being a better turner than him, but about him being a better turner than he currently is- and I can help him get there.
Please explain how you can tell by looking at these works what the turner was doing at the lathe. As I know of no professional or other who can do this it would be informative and helpful to us all if you could enlighten us.
I'm not sure if that helps you- but I think I did the best I could. If you paid for an intermediate class with me to learn hollowing, wouldn't you be upset if a brand new turner required all of my attention to teach them how to turn? If you were an instructor, how would you handle it? Would you spend the time to catch them up (because they overestimated their abilities) or would you "drop them" and focus on the material you intended to present?
Teaching turning is a lot harder than turning. When I started demonstrating, I found out that I could be in mid-process, and 1/2 the crowd was lost. If you get that in a classroom, it's a long day.
Definitely taking notes for September. I promise that at least 1/2 of my class will be able to cut the inside of a bowl one handed at the end of the weekend, and everyone will move up two grits...
Steve