Diane Sawyer: What makes a great teacher?
Mike Jones in Redding, Ca
Not what you thought?
http://abcnews.go.com/WNT/video/secrets-americas-greatest-teachers-9961455
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Diane Sawyer: What makes a great teacher?
Mike Jones in Redding, Ca
Not what you thought?
http://abcnews.go.com/WNT/video/secrets-americas-greatest-teachers-9961455
Re: Diane Sawyer: What makes a great teacher?
Donna Banfield
Mike, thanks for posting that. The report demonstrates - for real :^)- that what we most think makes a great teacher isn't all that important -- the expert, the one with 25-30 years experience, or the one whose work appears in the most prestigious art collections and museums and sells for 5-6 figures.
In the previous thread, I pointed out that I had been working in education for almost 15 years. That is formally trained. In addition to that (not including teaching/demonstrating woodturning), I have been an athletic coach and mentor for many years in several sports.
I have modeled my teaching methods after those teachers from whom I learned the most. And they were the ones that made learning fun! Instead of lecturing me, or regurgitating what I already read in the textbook, they created stories, or used examples which demonstrated the skills that I read about, but didn't fully grasp until I 'saw' how they worked. Their teaching enhanced my learning, took me to another level, and I loved every step of the way. In woodturning, an ultimate goal in teaching is for the student to love woodturning as much as I. If I can accomplish that, the teaching thing gets easier for the student AND the teacher.
The student in the earlier thread, whose bowl kept launching because s/he kept trying to turn it while sitting down, was doing that because everyone else was getting so much further ahead. And that was simply because the student needed to rest often. When I convinced the student that this wasn't a race, with the winner being who finished a bowl first, the student relaxed, and was able to work on the bowl on his/her own pace. When the time came to sand, I pointed out that ALL the sanding could be done sitting down. And the student still had a finished bowl at the end of the class.
Like one of the teachers in the Diane Sawyer report said, if one method isn't working, admit it, and start over with another. Because THAT works.
Re: Diane Sawyer: What makes a great teacher?
Carol Reed
Like you, Donna, I began teaching in the 'mid nineties. I hated to administer (and grade) tests as much or more so than the students hated taking them. But academia requires certain things. I hated it until I learned that the results of the tests were not about how much the students learned, but how well I was doing as a teacher. That was not intimidating to me, but rather stimulating. We found fun ways to grasp and apply new information. That was reflected in the number of students signing up to take my class, especially when they had a choice of teachers for the same class.
:-)
Steven Antonucci
Set High goals
Try new things when old things don't work
Seek/confirm understanding
Hmmm, maybe I should try that :-)
S
A great teacher is a great motivator
john lucas
If you can make your students want to learn, then they will learn. Now how you do that is the hard part. When I look back the best teachers I had convinced you that you were better than you thought you were. They expected more from you and they somehow got you excited about the subject. If you can achieve those goals then the students will excel.
Can I do that? Don't know, but I try.
Re: Diane Sawyer: What makes a great teacher?
fgvanatta
A true teacher has the ability to see the subject from the student's point of view and can adapt their teaching style to make the learning process comfortable for each student.
Re: A great teacher is a great motivator
Steve Kubien
I like this. The best teachers I have ever had, in school, in the shop and in the dojo MAKE me want to get better.
Re: A great teacher is a great motivator
Cyril Griesbach
Excellent teachers are rare and worth far more than they get paid. Unfortunately adequate teachers abound and tenure assures only adequacy.
Now Carol Reed has pointed out something I've always believed and that it's the success of the student that's the measure of the success of the teacher.
Unfortunately, the problems with our students being behind those of other countries has been answered by lowering our standards.
Re: Diane Sawyer: What makes a great teacher?
Don Pencil
Mike,
Thank you for sharing that. I believe it certainly gives a face to what so many of us have been working for.
Training, experience, and ability are still a part of the equasion.
Setting High goals is the only way to go. Although what is a realistic goal for one is not student is not for another. In a one day or shorter woodturning setting with a turning project to focus on it would be impossible to set a skill level goal standard for all of the students. The instructor can only state, in advance, the tool skills the student is expected to have to the class to begin the project and what new skills will be addressed in the prodject. The high goal setting in my class is only for me. In the hours to come it is my responsibility to advance each of the students, to the best of their individual ability, in their personal comfort level, to a level of skill and knowlege that will best serve them in the days to come.
Seek/confirm understanding will be happening every second of the class and will take the full measure of all my years of traing. I will hear every noise in the shop even when talking or working with a student. I am listening carefully to very word they say. I will see most of the activity in the class at all times. I am watching for every tell tale expression on a students face that will help me help them.
Trying new things when old things don't work is what I will be doing constantly as needed because of all the information I have collected from the above. And just trying something else is not the answer. I need to draw upon my knowlege, training, and experience to know what correction is needed at that very moment. Right every time? Hardly. But those instructors who can perform the above thinking quickly on their feet and calmly under pressure will achieve the best results from every oppertunity.
Oh, one more thing, the student must believe in their heart that you are confident, in control, calm, and most of all that you believe in them, even when you may not. Expect know more of them than they are comfortably able to give.
Now, if you can do the above, go forth and instruct someone. You and they will have a great experience.
Don