Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

Posts

My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#1

My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

Mike Jones in Redding, Ca

I have recently taken on two students. One pays in scraps of wood or flea market "treasures". the other in cash. Four hours in a session with either one and I feel like I have been run-over by the proverbial truck...been beaten by the Ugly stick, wrung through the knot hole (backwards)...etc. and etc.

Not a drinking man, myself, but was sorely tempted to pick up a bottle this afternoon. Haven't smoked a cigartte in years, and I did not today either, but must admit the idea was downright appealing.

With only one in the shop at a time, you'd think it would be a walk in the park, but it' snot.

Truly, my kudos to those among us that demo and instruct. Tell me, were your first few students a struggle? When do you get over it?

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#2

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

bowlman

If you are very lucky, you never get over it. What you are most probably feeling is the aftermath of putting everything you have into your mentoring/teaching and that is a very good thing. Especially good for the students since they sense when the instructor is simply going through the paces.

After I have a mentoring/teaching session, I make sure the shop is cleaned up, then perhaps a 30 minute power nap. Usually works for me. In the event that my brain just won't calm down, I'll go to the 'puter and write down specific items to go over next time with the emphasis on those areas where the student seemed to struggle ... like using the skew and keeping the bevel rubbing and the tool in contact with the rest (ABC, Anchor, Bevel, Cut).

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#3

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

John Lucas

I always go through that the first day of a workshop. It seems everyone is having problems. By the end of the second day I'm always amazed at how they are doing the work they turn out.

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#4

Are you kidding?

John K Jordan

Where did you find these students, on a work release program? (just kidding!!!)

Maybe I've been lucky but every time I've worked with turners, both new and experienced, I've been left refreshed and looking forward to the next time. I usually start a brand new turner rounding a 1" turning square with a roughing gouge, then introduce planing and v-grooves with the skew, then some curves with the spindle gouge. I will NOT jump right into making a bowl, even if that is a goal - I think that would be a mistake.

Recently a good friend wanted to make some birthday presents so we decided on pens - this was her first time at the lathe. After some tool practice, the picture shows her first try, a cigar pen turned from cocobolo. She did the entire process from cutting the blanks to assembly. The second pen came out great too although it was a little trickier - a thinline from spalted beech.


Sessions with turners with experience have been great fun - I do a little demonstrating and a bunch of watching and advising as needed. Turning a thin magic wand with a skew is a great skill-building exercise, especially for those who have never really used a skew. And everyone goes away with wood! When I get more shop space I hope to do more of this - two people can barely move in my current space without getting personal.

JKJ

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#5

Steven Antonucci

Managing expectations goes both ways

Steven Antonucci

Most new turners think they are one tool/technique/thing away from getting it and if they get that, they will be David Ellsworth.

Most new instructors fail to recognize that there are 27 things they do automatically without even thinking, and that the one thing you are trying to teach relies on all 27, so we cannot figure out why the students don't pick it up with our marvelous teaching skills!

The balance is in recognizing that WE didn't get it all in one four hour session either and dissecting the dependencies. When I get a new turner, I'm happy if I can get them to recognize when they need to sharpen, riding the bevel and keeping the tool against their body in a few sessions. Even though I say it 400 times an hour, it takes time to sink in WHY it is important (as it did when David Ellsworth said it to me...)

Deep breathing helps...

Steve

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#6

Rob Wallace

Beautiful, John.....

Rob Wallace

....the pen's nice too! ;)

Rob

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#7

Brad Vietje

Re: Managing expectations goes both ways

Brad Vietje

Good points, Steve. Expectations are key. I don't do much teaching as I'd like (has to wait for a shop with heat), but lots of demonstrating.

I think it's easier to start a newbie off on the right track than to help a slightly more experienced turner break bad habits. Its also important to take those 27 things, and break them down and show how to stand and move at the lathe, hold the tools, and present the tool to the wood.

Like Jamie says, you just can't jump into bowls without at least reviewing the crucial foundations of turning mechanics. I prefer to go one step further, and not start with square stock. While turning square to round (or rough turning in general) is often the first turning done on a project, it may not be the first thing to learn. I start with a piece I've already rounded, and get them to get comfortable with initiating the cut, bevel angles and all that. After they can cut with the roughing gouge, spindle gouge and simple cuts with a skew, I'll get 'em to round up a square piece.

Another important thing is to avid making a project at first. Keep the stakes and expectations low and make shavings and make the tools cut -- then make a project for them to take home.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#8

Re: Teaching can be rewarding...and hard (Long)

Donna Banfield

Some days are great, and then there are other days...

I had a bowl class this past Sunday, 6 students, and only two of them had any experience with turning tools. One came in with a bag full of very old spindle turning tools -- every single one had a tang entering the handle that made it look like they were simply reshaped and sharpened files. He was disappointed when I told him I wouldn't let him use those to turn a bowl -- disappointed because he now had to buy a bowl gouge. Apparently not a tool junkie.

One student had a medical issue which required the student to sit down often; couldn't stand for more than about 5 minutes at a time. Despite being told not to, the student kept trying to turn while sitting on the stool. This put the student VERY far away from the lathe, and put the tool angle about 2-3 inches above center. The bowl spent more time flying through the air than on the lathe. (This is why the next lathe in my shop will be the Oneway 1236 SD. Needing to sit down is something we all will need to do as we get older).

Another student had a crack develop in his while he was turning it, and when we couldn't 'save it' with CA glue -- crack was more than an 1/8" wide on the rim -- he did not want to give it up. This even after I told him that continuing to turn this piece would put his and all his classmates' safety at risk. (Keep in mind that all of you might be able to save this bowl, but this is not something a beginner should attempt). I got the feeling that this student didn't hear the word 'NO' very often.

Another student kept 'tucking' the handle of the bowl gouge into her body under her arm/shoulder to secure it. Obviously, this angle of the tool put her entry point straight in, and every time she jabbed the tool into the spinning wood, you can guess what happened.

I start every class with the safety instructions, how to use the lathe and grinder, and then demonstrate what they're going to do, so they see the process, all while stopping and explaining each step, like Anchor Bevel Cut, 'dancing with the lathe, or the woodturner's waltz, etc. Apparently not everyone was paying attention.

At the end of the 6 hour class, they all walked away with a completed bowl, grinning from ear to ear. Over the 6 hour class I felt like I started with loose fit boxers, graduated to tightie whiteys and finished with a thong! They never saw me sweat, though, and patience and calm confidence in their ability was always reinforced. I remind them that everyone started out as a beginner, and eventually it will start to become second nature -- you just need to practice.

This was an unusual class. My best students are ones who've never picked up a turning tool because they're a fresh slate with no bad habits. I love them! And I let those newbies know that, too. Last Sunday was unusual for some reason. At the end of any class, I'm either exhiliarated or exhausted. Last Sunday I was both!

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#9

Don Pencil

Are you an instructor???

Don Pencil

It should be fairly obvious from these posts that teaching is very complicated. Not everyone has what it takes to do it, even with training. Each of us has our own gifts. If you are not gifted as an instructor and well trained in communication and teaching skills, it is going to be very difficult for one to try. One may be very skilled turner, an excellent artist, and may even have a deep desire to show these things to others, but if you are not trained and gifted as an instructor the students and mentor will be very frustrated at the end of the day.

How many times have we all witnessed a demonstration or day of instruction that was boring, fairly uninformative, or confusing? I have been in several "adult education" or "college classes" where the vocational instructor had many years experience but could not communicate that experience to others. Remember, a lot of public school teachers get years of training and still can't get it done.

It may be that the new instructor just needs a little time to get over the "opening night" jitters. But if that person has not received some training in teaching, "good luck".

Mentors and instructors who do not seek proper training before beginning this journey are doing harm to the students and woodturning as a whole. One may be discouraging a turner who would otherwise make it with proper instruction. If the student isn't getting it, it may not be the student, in most cases it is the instructor.

I hope we all look inward a little. Even though for me, this is an area of great strength, I certainly have many area of my life that are not. I will get training in those or stay out if possible.

Be Well,

Don

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#10

Steven Antonucci

Been there, done that (trying to avoid

Steven Antonucci

doing it again)

I understand that it is an economic thing to put 6 beginners in a class, but it is impossible to fix 6 bad turners at one time. When I work one on one with people, I will often grab the tool or the turner and physically correct the "wrong" things- many, many times over. I also will turn off the lathe and make them correct themselves ("Why did I turn the lathe off?"..."What were you doing wrong?") If we have to go backwards to go forwards, so be it.

I've had 5 people crammed into my shop that were beginners, and you only get 1/5 of my time at best. Usually, right after the turning has been ripped out of the chuck and flung across the room, and that's too late.

I will be teaching at the end of the summer, and I plan on developing exercises that teach techniques for the better part of the day. I expect that I will not have a bunch of clean slates, but rather some huge bad habits to overcome. I hope folks don't mind my "hand's on" approach, but it is very effective...

Steve

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#11

Ric Taylor

You're Not Fooling Me....

Ric Taylor

She is way too clean to have been turning wood.

Ric

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#12

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

robo hippy

I have had only one total rookie for a turning 'victim of circumstances' as my martial arts teacher used to call volunteers. Most of the time it is people who have turning experience, and are struggling to get past a certain point. It us much easier for me to see what they are doing wrong, and make a few small suggestions as to how to correct than it is to start out with "this is a lathe". It does feel really good to see that light of understanding come on.

robo hippy

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#13

Re: You're Not Fooling Me....

John K Jordan

>She is way too clean to have been turning wood.

Ok, this is from a little earlier, before the kerosene heater warmed the shop up a bit.


JKJ

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#14

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

I just finished up two days with a man who had never touched a lathe before. I do a lot of that. I get people who have some turning experience, no turning experience, and even some who have enough that they are attempting to earn a living at it. I love it, regardless of the experience of the student.

The key is flexibility. I constantly adapt to the progress of my student(s). I will change the way I present things or explain things. I will sometimes change the tool being used. A good teacher needs to be aware of things like physical limitations, experience, natural ability, etc. It does no good to tell an 84 year old man to shift his weight and twist if he can't do that. And yes, I have had a couple of students in their 80s. May I be that spry when my time comes.

I teach techniques, I do not teach "things". I want someone to walk out of my shop knowing how to make certain cuts, how to sharpen their tools, etc. I don't really care if they make a thing or not. I want them to be able to go home and make as many things as they want with the techniques they learned in my shop. But if a thing gets made in my shop, that is a bonus.

Regardless of the student, his or her abilities, or how well things went, it is still very relaxing to sit down at the end of the day with an adult beverage, and in warmer weather, a good stogie, and reminisce about how good it is to do something I love to do.

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#15

Don Pencil

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

Don Pencil

HELLO!!!!!

Is anybody listening to this guy???

I have never taken a class for Bill but I would like to.

I do not personally know how he is in the classroom but I'd bet dollars to doughnuts that he is a really good instructor. I will guarentee that if he is getting the message he preaches over to the student great things will happen in the life and work of the new or experienced turner that takes a class from him.

If you are, or want to be an instructor then print out what Bill has written here and memorize it. Then go out and learn how to do it.

In any field of instruction, there is a basic and common thread that runs in classes of the best teachers, Bill has it. If all woodturning demonstrators and/or instructors could put this into practice what a wonderful world this would be.

When those who have experience in "teaching the teachers" get them to a place where Bill is at it is a great day. It is not an easy thing to do. Being an "on your feet" instructor is tough. When you can handle 8-10 rookies in the room in a hands on teaching environment, and do it well, you have arrived. I'd bet Bill could do it. Certainly not ideal, but when you are capable of that you are doing it right.

If you are a "Bill" then keep it up. If you are not then do yourself, your students, woodturning, and all who will have to straighten out the mess later a great service and get there. I'm certain he is a fine example of what it is when it is right.

Don

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#16

Re: You're Not Fooling Me....

Bob Macgregor

Looking at that picture made me wonder if anybody had ever had their face jerked down into the toolrest (or maybe scalped?) after getting their hair caught in a turning piece?

BOB

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#17

Brad Vietje

Re: Teaching can be rewarding...and hard (Long)

Brad Vietje

WOW, Donna, that sounds like a challenge!

Was this a private class, or one of those Woodcraft deals? It sure would make your life easier if the absolute newbies were in a separate and smaller group from those with a little on the ball (or a little lathe time).

I'm hoping to teach at home by next winter, and all these lessons are useful -- I'm planning one one big lathe, and two smaller lathes for learning the basics, and only two at a time. I hope others will share their experiences, too.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#18

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Ed Moore in SW VA

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#19

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

Grant Wilkinson

I hope all you instructors/teachers don't mind a word from someone who is neither, but who has been a student.

It seems to me that, even though the student has put his/her money down to be taught, that does not give them the right or privilege to ignore safety instructions and warnings repeatedly. If I were told by the instructor not to continue on a piece because doing so could endanger me or other students, and if I ignored that advice, I should be prepared to be handed my money back and my coat at the same time.

I took a pen turning session at LV with 6 participants. While it was fun and the project was simple, I could feel for the instructor. He was great, but he could only watch so many hands and tools at one time. I guess for something as simple and reasonably safe as a pen, that number was ok.

For bowl turning, I chose to receive one on one training over two days. I'm lucky; I could afford the added expense of individual training. Having done it that way, I would never choose otherwise. I had the instructor's undivided attention. I could ask questions when they arose and he could point things immediately.

I appreciate that, for instructors to make a living, they may need to have class sizes that are not ideal, but, with respect, I would suggest that you at least consider smaller classes, and larger tuitions. You'll come away less exhausted, and the students will come away much better prepared to continue learning.

To Don: You're right. Bill is incredible! It was from Bill that I received my one on one training. Best two days of turning I've ever had - before or since.

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#20

Re: You're Not Fooling Me....

John K Jordan

>...hair caught in a turning piece?

Bob,

That's a good point - it would be painful at minimum! That particular turner had her hair tied back for the bigger wood but not for the pen. Most turners seem to be old men with no hair but I'll certainly keep that in mind and add it to the checklist for the future, along with the safety glasses, etc.

We tied this one's hair back with a wire tie!


JKJ

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#21

Steven Antonucci

The difference between explaining and doing

Steven Antonucci

Every turner that I have ever met THINKS they are already doing what they need to do. It's the subtle difference between what they are doing and the "right" way that is almost impossible to correct without touching them and/or their tools. There are many instructors who will repeat the same ineffective words over and over again, "ride the bevel", "anchor bevel cut" etc to a student AND NEVER IMPROVE their students ability.

My methods works. It is not done in an aggressive manner, so there is no confrontation between student and teacher. Often, if the student sees me coming, they start to self correct because they know they are out of position or I wouldn't be coming.

Too many teachers don't take the time to analyze what their students need to learn. They teach to the middle, or a subject that doesn't take into account the individual needs of the student. In the end, the student says "I took a class with so and so, and it was good" but they haven't learned ANYTHING or developed any new skills. They still have bad habits, or worse, are potentially dangerous to the other turners in the class.

I don't expect that my style would work with someone who was already an "expert" (I know that it doesn't). Yogi Berra said "you can't teach him something he doesn't already know"- and I would highly discourage that type of person from ever taking one of MY workshops. However, for folks that still get catches every time they turn on the lathe and use 60 grit sandpaper, I offer my time, energy and experience to fix them.

And I guarantee I will move you and your tool more than once...

Steve

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#22

Re: You're Not Fooling Me....

robo hippy

Any long hair should be tied back and under cover. There was a drama teacher with long hair, here in town who got too close to an open fan. It ended taking about half her face off. Long dangly things are dangerous around open spinny things.

robo hippy

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#23

Ellis Walentine

C'mon guys....

Ellis Walentine

I think this has been an informative thread, and I also think there's room for some disagreement regarding what methods work or don't work. There's also the opportunity to learn something from each other without insisting on being 100% right.

Ellis

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#24

Steven Antonucci

I'm not insisting that I am right

Steven Antonucci

merely explaining how and why I do what I do, and that I'm not going to change it :-)

I seem to recall dropping a tool handle on a rough out for you at Bill's picnic a few years ago, and you didn't smack me with it, right ;-)

Re: My hat is off to you, instructors and mentors

#25

Re: Sorry for not replying sooner....

Donna Banfield

But I had another class to teach on Thursday night ;^) When I got home lost power within a half hour from that nasty storm that came up the east coast, and backed in again. Many trees down over power lines, flooding and road closures. Fortunately, we learned back in '06 after an ice storm, no power for 4 days, and 10 burst pipes once it came back on. We bought a generator, so now have heat and light.

Brad, the students were not in my private studio. I've had private students, but never more than 1 or 2 at a time. I have no control over who signs up for those other classes, because it's not up to me. But I deal with whatever is thrown my way as a challenge. And I never use one single approach when teaching. I've been a teacher since 1996, so I have a background in education already, and know that the same method doesn't always work for everyone.