electric chainsaws
Carol Reed
Anyone using small electric chainsaws in their shop to prepare blanks?
Suggestions?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
electric chainsaws
Carol Reed
Anyone using small electric chainsaws in their shop to prepare blanks?
Suggestions?
Cheap Sears
Ray - Middletown, IN
I bought one years ago to grub out some roots of shrubbery that I was removing. I just stuck in down in the dirt and mud and didn't worry about the chain or blade. Figured it was cheaper to ruin a cheap saw than paying someone. Stupid saw still runs like a top, some 15-18 years later. I just touch the chain with a file stick it where I don't want to use my good saw. Same chain, still cuts good. Can't even justify getting a new one.
Ray
BTW - Think 9-11-10
Re: electric chainsaws
Terry Quiram
I have a Remington I bought about 10 years ago. If I were to do it over I would get a Sthil. The Remington leaks oil when not in use.
Re: Cheap Sears
Carol Reed
Thanks, Ray.
Unfortunately good things from Sears from years ago may not enjoy the same endurance today, but I will look. As for the other I have made the appropriate notation. YeeHaw!
Re: I have a Makita electric which I can
JamieDonaldson
....recommend right up there with my Stihl, and a bit less money.
Same here
Scott Crumpton
I also had a cheep Sears one, 14" or 16", that I used to remove pine stumps. Several chains, bars and sprockets later it was still cutting up big oaks. I eventually killed it and bought another. The second was not as well built, they used some plastic gears. It held up well, but did not see as much use. I sold it to a friend when I got my first gas saw an Echo CS-3400 and recently added a CS-520. The CS-520 with a 20" bar is sweet for making blanks. I still have a $40 Remington electric that I use for cutting in the dirt, it's a real piece of junk.
Best I can say is to make sure what you're looking at appears solidly built, doesn't have plastic where it shouldn't, and has a bar with a sprocket at the tip. Electrics have a poor power to weight ratio compared to gas saws and turn the chain slower. So, you should probably buy bigger than you think you need.
re: a Makita electric - discontinued
Carol Reed
Re: electric chainsaws
Carol Reed
Over $300! Yikes! I do have the Stihl gas for away from the electron source though. I know that is a good saw, but gees!
Re: electric chainsaws
Barry Irby
I had two Remington's I bought at Lowes. Actually, I bought the first one and it failed and Lowes replaced it. The second one lasted just long enough to get past the warranty.
Went to Sears and bought what appeared to be another one made by Remington for Sears. (about $100). Bought the Extended warranty for about $12. Truly expected them to replace it about twice under the warranty, but it has lasted for about five years. Use is very sporadic. Sits for months then used like a maniac for a day or two.
It has a 16" bar and more power than I expected. It does leak bar oil. Actually, it just leaks bar oil. That's how it appears to work, it leaks onto the chain. I don't think it has a pump, it just drools. So, if you leave it alone, it drools everywhere. I have not put bar oil in it for years. I rely on the water in the wood for lubrication.
My understanding is the Makita saw is $400=/- and the Stihl is $500 or $600. I would love to have either, but the money is not there. The saw I have is one thing I have bought from Sears that has exceeded my (admittedly low) expectations. It is much better than the ones I bought from Lowes and I would buy it again. If you need it I will get you the model number.
Re: electric chainsaws
Texian
Had a cheapo Remington some years ago, mostly plastic. It cut an amazing amount of stuff during several year lifetime. Loaned it to my FIL and it came back in a basket. The oiler with flexible plastic top that pumps the oil via your thumb is poor/useless. As mentioned, the oil leaks out. I used a pressurized oil can to squirt the chain with used motor oil before every cut. Assume that the high dollar electrics (Stihl, etc.?) have proper oil pumps and should give excellent service. Fifty dollars vs. two or three hundred.
Re: electric chainsaws
marvin ewing
I have a Husqvarna with a 16" bar love it paid about 250.00 for it new
Re: electric chainsaws
keith zimmerman, Normal, IL
I have a cheap Remington 16" and they are still available...and cheap enough to replace easily.
keithz
Re: electric chainsaws
Carole Valentine
I have a McCulloch 14" and it sucks. Was a waste of money...thank goodness it was cheap to begin with.
Re: electric chainsaws - Did Remington
Carol Reed
and McCulloch merge? Anybody know? The Sears site shows both brand names on one saw.
Re: electric chainsaws - so far
Carol Reed
For now the goal is stay under $100.
What I am finding and hearing:
16" bar or longer
Automatic oiling & buy lots of oil! They "drool" - (Love it, Barry!)
No-tool chain adjustment - reviews indicate they come off often
As many amps as are available in that range - gotta watch the sneaks that tout horsepower.
Sprocket at the nose of the bar - here the ads are hazy and the pictures unclear.
As little plastic as possible - exactly what should NOT be plastic?
Outlets available to me locally (40 miles round trip) include Ace, Sears (small local contract store) and Home Depot.
I have a chiropractor appointment Wednesday morning. I will make the rounds. Taking your comments, suggestions, warnings, and recommendations until then. Thanks!
McCulloch 16" $79
charlie belden
Facing a $180 "tune up" of my gas powered Stihl, and with a bunch of loquat (japanese plum) logettes that need cutting to managable pieces I picked up a "3.2 HP" McCulloch with a 16" bar at my local ACE Haredware. Another $4 for a bottle of chain oil and with tax the total was less than $90.
Worked nicely, a lot quieter, no tugging on a rope to get it started and a LOT lighter than the Stihl. Easier to clean up afterwards too.
Re: electric chainsaws
robo hippy
Carol,
It would depend on how much you are going to use it. For occasional use, one of the cheaper saws will work fine, but if you plan on doing a lot of work with it, then you will probably want a Sthil or Husky. I do tend to buy industrial grade tools because that is how I use/abuse them. I would check the amp draw for the saws, usually listed on it some where. More amps means more power. Also, when cutting with one, let it cut by itself, rather than pushing it. That type of electric motor has 2 speeds, on or off. If you are loading it by pushing hard, like when the chain is dull, you can burn up the motor fairly easy.
Since I got my Laguna 16HD bandsaw, I never use the electric chain saw for anything other than small cross cuts. If you are prepping bowl blanks that you can get onto your bandsaw, it is usually more efficient. Of course, sharp blades are necessary.
robo hippy
Re: electric chainsaws
jim miles - Charlote NC
I use an electric frequently in the shop to trim up & balance big blanks while on the lathe ( not running of course )
Had a Sears for 30 years- could'nt get parts
Bought Remington ( cheapest ) @ Lowe's
They have some kind of engineering defect. Over 3 - 4 years I burned up 12 - 15 of them. Lowe's kept replacing them however. ( never had to sharpen )
They replaced Remington with an electric Poulan which I have had about a year and been very pleased with
Re: electric chainsaws
cliff
i also had the cheap remington from lowes, lasted longer than i expected, now have a 4hp elec poulan from lowes has held up so far, use mine to prepare blanks.
Re: electric chainsaws
Charles Watson------WebKitFormBoundary+ATeQdvhmFc4
I use a Makita which is one of the best purchases I have ever made.
no comparison
John K Jordan
Carol,
I've had inexpensive electric chain saws. I'm afraid I have to say this is one area where you get what you pay for. The cut was poor, chains were non-standard and cheap quality, power was never enough, and the bar oil delivery was manual and problematic (always leaked).
Last year I bought a Sthil electric. There is no comparison. So far I am very pleased - it has cut anything I've tried and as well as my other saws. I use it inside and outside - instant on (and off), no noise, cuts cleanly, lots of power, and it puts the oil on the chain instead of the floor. It is so nice to simply plug and go. Unfortunately, it was not inexpensive - I think I paid around $400 but I saw one just now on eBay for just over $100.
This review might help:
http://www.consumersearch.com/chainsaws/electric-chainsaws
JKJ
Re: electric chainsaws
-e-
husqvarna electric
http://www.consumersearch.com/chainsaws/husqvarna-316e
excellent quality for the price. very pleased with them and great for cutting on the lathe.
Stihl MSE 220 and other electrics are the top but very expensive.
Re: no comparison
Donna Parrillo
I'm with John, I have the Stihl MSE 180C and am very happy with it. -Donna P.
Re: electric chainsaws
Lee Buck
Carol; I burned up an Echo. I don't think it was the fault of the saw. When making rip cuts the long fibers jam between the cover and the chain and pulley very quickly. Whatever saw you get you should be sure that those fibers are being ejected when cutting with the grain. Pull them out when they are not flowing. I now have a Stihl.
Bailey's Still Lists Them
Tom Collins
Carol, I just got an email ad from Baileys yesterday and they still list the Makita electric. Kind of a steep price though. Go to Baileysonline.com to see their ad
TomC