Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

Posts

Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

#1

Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

bowlman

>OK, so earlier this year I took a flier and spent $90 on a Kodak C182 12 megapixel camera with 3X optical zoom. As Jamie D. can testify, shots taken with this camera yielded images that were NOT sharply focused. Now, my other digital camera, Kodak 4 megapixel, 10x zoom, has a Schneider Kreuznach Variogram Lens. Schneider lenses (especially Schneider Symar lenses) have been some of the best for decades and decades. At Brooks Institute of Photography, back in the '60's, I preferred Schneider lenses (I couldn't afford Nikons).

Anyway, this new camera ... when purchased there was no user manual. You had to download it from the Kodak website. No big deal, but wait, there are 2 manuals? One is very very cursoy, the other is called an "Extended" User Guide.

Ok, I'm now studying the extended user guide specifically looking for key words like focus, depth of field, aperture settings, and sharpness. Guess what?

This camera has a "sharpness" setting with 3 levels ... soft, normal and sharp. And, it comes from the factory pre-set to "soft" ... what the hell*(&#^!#756. When viewed on screen with no zooming in, the pictures look fine. But zoom in a couple of factors, say 4x or 6x, and they are oh so soft soft soft! No wonder my images have all the zip of a close up of a stay puff marsmallow! My eyes have, over the years, adopted their own soft focus, thank you, and I don't really need any help from Kodak or Canon or Nikon or anyone else to further soften the images.

So now, I spent some time going through all the modes and all the settings making sure that everything I can do to ensure sharpness has been done. I nearly always use a tripod, except when using the electronic flash, but that is going to change as well. Back in the day, electronic flashes were fast enough (1/2000 of a sec) to stop nearly anything from blurring, so no need for "blur reduction" technology. Guess these new digi cam flashes are not nearly as fast, because my wife can hand hold the camera, using the flash, and still get a blurred picture.

So, if you have one of these cameras, or one like it, you may want to check the user manual, in detail, to make sure the "sharpness" settings are all set for the best/highest settings. Why anyone would want soft focus is beyond me ... and nobody at Kodak has been able to explain the difference between the "Normal" sharpness setting and the "Sharp" sharpness setting, although I think it really has to do with the aperture setting. BTW my camera has an effective aperture range of f2.9 to f5.2.

If I had known this all before buying, I would have declined and searched for a camera with an effective aperture that went at least to f8 ... or even better to f16. Guess I'll have to save my pennies to upgrade to a good DSLR where I can have manual override over everything.

Sigh, sometimes I really do miss the film days! As soon as I can I will psot a test pciture showing the differences among "soft","normal", and "sharp".

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

#2

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

Texian

>My Nikon DSLR has a "sharpen" feature in the software used to download (upload?) photos to the computer. The maximum "sharpen" seems to be best on nearly every photo. Have not taken time to learn whatthehell is "unsharp mask", but am sure that others here understand it.

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

#3

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Dick I'll be curious to see your picture tests. I bought Weston one of these a year or so ago and he's now complaining that it won't focus properly. It's still under warranty but now I'm wondering if he's goofed with one of these settings? By the way, can't stand that Kodak Easy Share software that comes with these cameras. It over rides all the other photo software on the computer. Arrgh.

Jen

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

#4

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

john lucas

>Dick Personally I don't think digital is anywhere near what film was. I've had this argument with my boss but I cannot get a print anywhere near what I used to get in the darkroom. I had a long time photo friend visit last weekend and he brought up the fact that he didn't this digital was anything like film. He's been shooting weddings for 20 years with film and then digital. I have a full frame 12 meg Nikon D700 camera at work and it just doesn't look sharp to me. The same was true with the D2 that I used to use. Even when you sharpen stuff in photo shop the prints just look soft to me when enlarged anything beyone 8x10. I used to print really nice 11x14's from fuji 50 35mm back in the film days.

As far as flash goes. They've built in all this smart crap that you can't override. It often lengthens the shutter speed to help fill in the back ground behind the flash. So you get the flash image and if you move the camera any at all you get the ghost image from the longer exposure. My old CAnon Rebel was really bad about this. I ruined a bunch of photos with that camera and though I had set the shutter to 125 sec using shutter priority. It apparently overides what I want. I now use my Nikon D80 in manual mode when I want to use flash. I simply have more control and know what my equipment is doing. I'm smart enough to make my own choices.

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

#5

Re:It's hard to critically compare digital ....

JamieDonaldson

>......to analog(film!) for sharpness and several other imaging factors. The "sharpness" of print workflow output must also take into consideration digital printer characteristics of resolution(dpi), contrast, and color saturation. Even when comparing Nikon FX (full frame equivalent to 35mm) D700 digital format, lens quality, test procedures (tripod or hand held) and several other factors can skew individual results. Digital chip pixels are generally larges than Tri-X film developed in Microdol X, but not D-76!(That's for you old darkroom guys!) Software can make up some of the differences, like the Photoshop unsharp mask, which is really a sharpening operation which should be used judiciously. For those of us who worked in formats larges than 35mm (including myself) and often did our own lab work the unequal comparison is more apparent.

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

#6

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

bowlman

>I only use the Kodak software to get the images into the computer. After that, I move them to a new folder under "My Documents". Close Kodak, open something like Photoshop or ACDC Pro 2.5, open the new folder and have at it!. By the way, when I come to visit, I'd be happy to show you and Weston where to find the "Soft focus" features.

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

#7

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

bowlman

>Here are 3 images of the same object. All shot with the same apertures, shutter speed, on a sturdy tripod, 10 second shutter release delay, no on camera flash. The only variable is the "sharpness setting", from soft to normal to sharp.

While all 3 appear, at first glance, to be acceptable, it is when you zoom in that the differences become apparent. For most of us this can me seen by looking in the lower left corner for a magnifying glass with the "100%" to the right. Just to the right of the 100% is a down arrow. Press that and you can change the zoom level to whatever setting you want.

Try it and see if you can see the differences.

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

#8

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

Cyril Griesbach

>Dick, if I could tell the difference I'd say so. I think the last one may be a bit sharper image than the others so I'll guess and say the order is soft, medium, and sharp. I think all the images are fine and other than some differences in the background they look the same to me and my old eyes.

Cyril

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

#9

Jamie, tell me if I'm wrong

Russ Fairfield

>Unless we are willing to spend a lot of money, we use digital cameras for their convenience, and not for their picture quality.

I have always looked at it as the difference in the size of the particles that make up the picture, and the size of the pixel in most digital photos is very large compared to the grain particle of the film. I remember a reading a comparison that a 36 mm x 24 mm frame of ISO 100-speed film is estimated to contain the equivalent of 20 million pixels. I don't know of any but the most expensive digital cameras that come even close to that resolution.

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

#10

Re: Jamie, tell me if I'm wrong

john lucas

I've read anywhere from 20 to 36mil is supposed to be a film equivalent. I base my assumptions on projected images and prints. I realize there are a lot of factors involved but to me it's just like woodworking. It's not how you get there it's the final results that count. Digital images either projected as prints just aren't there.

Furthermore, I can usually tell a digital print before I even get close to it. The contrast is not realistic and the images just have an unnatural look. I'm not saying all digital images are bad I'm just saying that people usually go too far with all the photoshop manipulation and you can see it in the way the print looks.

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

#11

Re: Russ-you're right on target. Now that.....

JamieDonaldson

...a few top line cameras are 20MP+ they are about equivalent to film image quality in ISO ranges of 100~400, and those are equivalent to the same ISO ratings in the digital cameras. Just as with film, when the speed ratings go above 400 then the resolution starts to degrade just as with film, but the ability to change film speed without changing film is a real asset to many working shooters such as photojournalists.

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

#12

Ric Taylor

Sharpness

Ric Taylor

The unfortunate fact is that almost all digital images will benefit from some sharpening after downloading to a computer. Most graphics programs call this the Unsharp Mask feature. It is not difficult to use, and you will be happy if you take a few minutes to figure out how to use it.

I will NEVER let Kodak Easy Share software anywhere near my computer (been there, done that). First of all, it can be difficult to use the features, some of which are not intuitive. But most of all, my experience (and the experience of many others) is it can really degrade the performance of the computer in many ways, some of which are not related to photo projects. It's not just my opinion, check out reviews and forums on the internet, and you will easily find many many instances of very unhappy users.

But the primary reason not to use the Kodak software is you don't need it. You don't need it to get the photos from your camera to the computer or for any other reason. For that matter, you don't need the software for ANY camera manufacturer cluttering up your computer.

You can transfer photos from your computer to any folder you want (or create) on your computer with a simple copy and paste using Windows Explorer, copying from the camera and pasting to the folder. It is much faster than using the camera's software. Then you can use any of the really great, simple, and free photo editing programs that you can download from the internet to do anything that the camera manufacturer's software will do. Or you can use some of the leading products like Photoshop if you want to spend the money.

Ric

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

#13

The first step

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

Dick,

The very first thing I have always done when I get a new digital camera is peruse the menu, find the sharpness setting if there is one, and set it to the sharpest setting.

Assuming one's technique is correct, and because of the algorithms the camera manufacturers use, even this isn't always enough to guarantee sharpness in the final image, but it's the usually the best that can be done in-camera. It takes using the "unsharp mask" in my photo editing software to get as close to sharp as possible.

I have replaced several point and shoot digital cameras because they weren't sharp enough.

keithz

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

#14

Re: The first step

bowlman

All,

Yes, I know how to use the unsharp mask. But, for the sake of this test I did NOT want to add image manipulation to the mix. What you see is the jpg straight from the computer, no exposure adjustment, no cropping, no brightness adjustments, nothing except for the resizing.

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

#15

Re: The first step

John K Jordan

Isn't the software in the camera itself applying the equivalent of the unsharp mask algorithm? If you let the camera do it, you give up control - OK for snapshots and small images but not for something larger. I've always turned off any image manipulation in the camera, preferring to do it my self in Photoshop if needed. Often just portions of the image need sharpening, easily done with masks.

I suspect the reason camera makers even include a sharping option is to compensate for the unavoidable compromises of extracting single color pixels from the array of tri-color elements in single-chip image sensors (a trick in itself) AND to try to make up for the sharpness limitations of cheap optics.

JKJ

Re: Digital Camera "Sharpness" (Long)

#16

Re:And those cheap optics are often.....

JamieDonaldson

...covered with fingerprints for further "soft focus" effects!