Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

sand paper grinding for sharpening

Posts

sand paper grinding for sharpening

#1

sand paper grinding for sharpening

Carol Reed

>Steve Kubien made this comment in another thread (that I didn't want to hijack): "The grinder scares me more than anything else in my shop, so much so that I only recently gave up my belt-sander as my preferred tool for sharpening."

Why? I am not questioning the caution in using the grinder, but asking about the reason to abandon the sand paper approach via the belt sander.

I haven't found the grinder of my choice yet. However, I have a 12 inch Shopsmith disk used for sharpening back in those days when I had a Shopsmith and all its doodads. I also have a 1725 rpm motor with a 5/8" shaft. I am considering using this for sharpening in the turning shack. No wheels to shatter and impale me. I also have a 6" high speed grinder - 60+ year old really heavy Craftsman built like a tank and coasts forever - for massive metal removal.

What's not to like?

Steve?

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

#2

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

John Lucas

>Personally I like a disc sander with one exception. It wears out to fast when sharpening steel. However I was using discs designed for wood, not metal. What I like about the disc sander is that you can change the surface speed by simply moving the tool toward the center. This will remove metal slower so you have more control. I started with the shopsmith and that's what got me going. I used to mount a disc on there and cut it with a razor so I could mount 3 different grits from outside to middle. That way I could use the course grit on the outside. The finer grits would overheat the tool so I put them on the inside. This way I could take a chisel from dull to really sharp very fast. Like I said though I had to change the grits constantly due to wear.

Now a belt sander with easy to change grits is a good way to go and I've looked very seriously at the 2 machines out there designed for sharpening. I have also used a belt sander upside down. burnt a hole in the dustcollector bag doing that so if you go that route, remove that sucker before you start.

I like having a concave surface on tools like the skew because I do my final sharpening using a diamond hone and it's easier to get the hone flat when you start with a concave surface. The hone is only resting on 2 points so sharpening just takes a few strokes. With a flat bevel you have to hone a micro bevel which I prefer not to use. I like the friable wheels on my grinder because they always cut clean so I never have to replace any sandpaper. About the only thing I don't like about he grinder is the danger. I tap each wheel before installing to make sure they aren't cracked and I run at the slow speed only, never 3450.

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

#3

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>The oldest power tool in my shop is my Delta floor stand model 1-inch x 42 belt sander. Bought it in 1949. I've used it for a lot years in tool grinding. It's especially good for reshaping tools because it removes metal a lot fast and cooler than my grinder does.

A tip...Use blue zircon sanding belts. Made for cutting metal. It'll outlast the al. oxide belt by at least 10 to 1, and it costs about the same. I use 60 grit.

Wally

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

#4

Steven Antonucci

Before Tormek

Steven Antonucci

>I used to take my Craftsman beltsander, and hold it upside down in my bench vise. I would use a 220 belt or better, and if I had made a jig, it would have probably stayed my main means of sharpening. If you can make the jigs, it works pretty well.

Steve

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

#5

Re: Before Tormek

Bill Neddow

>There is an excellent article in Woodturning Design (most recent edition -- Spring 2010, pgs. 16-17) by John D. Williams on using a belt sander for sharpening. He has built a simple jig for holding a portable belt sander on its back (or end) for this purpose and shows how to make the stand so you can use jigs for sharpening. It is all very simple and can be made of wood or metal.

I like the ease of sharpening with belt sanders. You can quickly change the belt and go from shaping tools to honing in a few seconds. You would need a battery of 6 or 8 inch grinders and a fortune in wheels to get the same ease-of-use. The only down side I see is if you do a lot of hand honing. Everything else is an up side. And blue zirconium belts seem to last forever.

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

#6

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

Carol Reed

>As it turns out, I also have a 1" Delta Belt sander. I just need to put a motor on it.

And order some zirconium belts.

Thanks!

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

#7

Steve Kubien

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

Steve Kubien

>Hey Carol,

The belt sander I was using was the 1" x 42" frame sold be Lee Valley (#68Z7501). The problem I had was that I couldn't sharpen a roughing gouge or a skew to save my life on the thing. I never took the time to make a better jig than my wanna-be Wolverine. Then, I was given a grinder for my birthday and I picked up an actual Wolverine (used) from a friend for next to nothing. I already had the Vari-Grind holder so I abandoned the belt sander for the grinder set-up.

I loved the finish I got from the belt sander. I was using a 120 grit blue zirconia belt (also from LV) and it was impossible to blue the steel (not a big deal with HSS tools but...). Oh, I almost forgot...the motor I had on the belt sander finally bought the farm so it was just one more reason to switch over when I did.

Nowadays, my gouges are sharp, my skews are sharp, I actually enjoy using my roughing gouge and my scrapers are a really treat to use. I am happy I made the switch to the grinder, but it still makes me a little nervous.

Warmest regards,

Steve

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

#8

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

John K Jordan

>I use the 1" belt sander to sharpen some tool, especially things like axes. I remove the little tool rest which gets in the way for this type of sharpening.

According to his books, Mike Darlow is a proponent of sharpening with a linisher. (A british term, as far as I can tell - I never hear it around here)

I see a combo linisher bench grinder on Amazon/UK.


JKJ

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

#9

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

john lucas

>John I was reading my latest issue of the home shop machinist and there is an article by a person from the UK. He mentions that a Linisher is a metal working version of a belt sander.

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

#10

Denis Putland

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

Denis Putland

>My sand paper sharpening assembly in a picture, a one inch belt sander with blue belts mounted on a small table and a metal strip with multiple holes drilled for the jigs to pivot in.

It should be self explanatory for the most part. I grind a small flat spot on my gouges just in front of the handle area. That is where the cap screw on my jigs makes contact for very accurate repeatability in mounting the gouge.

No need to measure just slide the gouge in until it butts against the handle and tighten down the cap screw...

The three none adjusting jigs with different angles will hold any sized gouge up to about 7/8 inches.

There is no secret formula to know what jig will get you what angle or how swept back the side will grind as the combination of length of the gouge and the angle of jig and the number of the pivot hole you use on the sander assembly will determine the final angle. You can control the swept back part by how far you swing the jig back and forth when sharpening.

Ounce I find the right combination to get the angle ect. I then mark the number of the jig and also the number of the pivot hole on the gouge handle for easy reference for resharpening.

As the gouge grinds down and gets shorter you just move the pivot point one or two holes closer to the belt sander to maintain the same angle.

It rarely takes me more then 30 seconds to mount my gouge and sharpen it with this method of mounting, (no measuring jigs or such to mess with)

In my opinion the amount of metal it removes with each sharpening is almost in the same range as honing. Because of the small amount of metal it removes and almost no time is lost to do it so I sharpen often.

I am a self taught turner and it works for me, perhaps it is because I do not know any better :) :)

Denis

Ps; Hope the picture up loads >(

Edit:: Since this picture was taken I have added wing type handles on the cap screws for tightening them down.


Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

#11

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

Carol Reed

>Thanks, Denis.

I have the Wolverine, so I will use that. What grits of blue zirconium belts do you use? Get'em from Lee Valley?

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

#12

Denis Putland

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

Denis Putland

>Carol I get the 80 and 120 from Lee valley

Denis

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

#13

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

Henry (Raleigh NC)

>I use my disk sander - free hand for most tools (scrapers, rought gouge), but with a shop made jig for the swept back wings on my bowl gouge. I used the Ellsworth book for basic idea for the jig.

It's all I have used, but i see no reason to buy a grinder.

Henry

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

#14

Re: sand paper grinding for sharpening

Carol Reed

>Thanks.

I'll have to get an order in.