Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Laser Engraver + Jig + Turning = ? *LINK*

Posts

Laser Engraver + Jig + Turning = ? *LINK*

#1

Laser Engraver + Jig + Turning = ? *LINK*

charlie belden

>Having spent a lot of years as what is now being called a "futurist", formerly known as forecasting, I can't stop looking out at, and trying to see beyond, the horizon. One of the things that's out there is the laser engraver (think ink jet printer and substitute a focused laser beam for ink - with the piece staying fixed and the "print head" doing all the moving). Computer driven laser engravers are becoming more and more accessible - some Kinkos copying centers already have them you can rent time on and our local woodworking store has one available for a nominal fee.

Laser engravers open up plenty of opportunities for turners - once you find a way to get around one small problem - focal length/depth of field. Above and below a laser beams focal length, the beam is out of focus - the effect being "blurring" and loss of crispness. With a depth of field of only about 0.10", curved surfaces present THE problem. Throw in a stepper motor to move the indexing jig gear - synched up with the laser's driver software and the whole laser engraving process could be automated.

Fortunately, a member of Silicon Valley Woodturners has solved THAT problem - with an indexing jig he made - the tricky parts made with - what else? - a laser engraver.

The attached link has the details of the jig and its use.

Note that the laser can burn/vaporize stuff to 256 different depths by changing the beam's power level and how many "pulses" you tell it to apply at each point. Give it a gray scale image and it will NOT burn if the value is WHITE and will pierce if the value is BLACK. Lighter means shallower, darker means deeper - "carving contours" with up to 255 "steps".

Now imagine if Graeme Priddle, or Terry Scott or Molly Winton or . . . could work out their pyrographic/vaporizing designs on a computer, and have the computer and the laser do the time consuming grunt work. Imagine Bin Pho, or J. Paul Fennel (sp?), Andi Wolfe or Ron Fleming being able to have the laser do most of the piercing, and even some of the carving.

Of course there will be details to work out - but think of the possibilities.

Have YOU got an idea of two that could exploit this idea?


Laser Engraving Jig

Re: Laser Engraver + Jig + Turning = ? *LINK*

#2

Re: Laser Engraver + Jig + Turning = ?

Scott in Falcon

>Interesting idea; the possibilities are endless. However, one definite consequence when this becomes a commonplace tool is that wooden bowls / hollow forms with fabulously intricate detail will appear for $4.99 at your local WalMart!

Scott

Re: Laser Engraver + Jig + Turning = ? *LINK*

#3

Re: Laser Engraver + Jig + Turning = ?

Carole Valentine

>I would have absolutely no interest in a Graeme, a Terry or a Molly if it was done with a computerized laser. It's their imagination and skill of their HANDS to bring forth what they have imagined that I admire.

Re: Laser Engraver + Jig + Turning = ? *LINK*

#4

Re: Laser Engraver + Jig + Turning = ?

john lucas

>I'm actually looking at this for a project. The artwork will be mine of course. I thought about trying to burn it but I have enough trouble trying to draw what I want. I think I can draw and sketch and erase and redraw until I get it right. Then I'll have a friend with an engraver cut the image into a platter. It just seems like the best way for me to get it done. I still may try to burn it. I think the laser cuts look too machine made. Perhaps a combination of the two. Let him burn it really shallow and then I can go back and go over it by hand.

Re: Laser Engraver + Jig + Turning = ? *LINK*

#5

Re: Laser Engraver + Jig + Turning = ?

charlie belden

>Like any technology this has potential upsides and downsides.

In this case one of the concern is Knock Offs - CHEAP Knock Offs. Were pieces by the artists mentioned mass market items this might be a big concern. For what are now One Offs or limited editions, I don't think the Knock Off folks would be interested since the potential market is so small. Even the least expensive laser engraver runs around $10K - not exactly like duplicating audio cassettes, CDs or DVDs. You'd have to make - and sell - a LOT of knock offs just to recoup the cost of the equiptment and I doubt Kinkos would go for someone banging out a couple hundred wood bowls or whatever on their lasers - ignoring the rental cost.

But it does raise the supply and demand curve question - big demand, low supply = high price, low demand, high supply = low price. May be like when photography arrived on the scene. Once you've got the negative you can make as many prints as you want - and can sell. Then folks like Ansel Adams came along. Seen the prices of his prints lately?

I'm just looking at this idea as a means for artists to reduce grunt work time so there's more time for the stuff that NEED special skills or developing creative ideas - and perhaps do variations that probably wouldn't be tried otherwise - maybe different woods, different finishes, different dyes, different piercing patterns, different . . .

The "I want THE ONLY ONE" thing - well I don't understand that one - but then I don't see life in terms of a Zero Sum Game - always a loser and a winner. Others may see things completely differently.

Re: Laser Engraver + Jig + Turning = ? *LINK*

#6

Re: Laser Engraver + Jig + Turning = ?

charlie belden

>John:

If the original art work has a gray scale, which a penciled drawing usually does, and you use the gray scale to define the depth of "cut" the results can be very difficult to distinguish from hand pyrographed or pierced. The example of Scott's pieces are from Vector graphics done in Correl's vector mode (think CAD as opposed to charcoal on paper - or PhotoShop artwork. Hell, most CAD programs now have a "hand drawn look" option. I suspect someone will come up with a way to get around the "machine made" look.

If you do go with laser engraving - put your finish on the piece BEFORE engraving. That way if there's any soot (sp?) from the wood burning vaporizing, it can be wiped off and not stain the adjacent wood.

Re: Laser Engraver + Jig + Turning = ? *LINK*

#7

Re: Laser Engraver + Jig + Turning =Walmart

Barbara Gill

Re: Laser Engraver + Jig + Turning = ? *LINK*

#8

Does It Matter HOW A Piece Is Created

charlie belden

>Humans, by nature, tend to want to stick with what's familiar - and often see change, not as opportunities, but more as threats - to what they're comfortable with and thus value. And in the world we live in today, change is coming at us at what seems like and ever accelerating rate. Turning seems to be adapting pretty well and some turners are adapting new technology to their needs. Variable speed lathes, new tool materials and methods, new tools, unusual woods that weren't previously available, power sanders, high speed air driven turbine grinders, powered carving tools, air brushes, sand blasters, electricly heated burning/scortching tools - the list goes on and on.

And I'm betting there's been resistance to the use of these now familiar tools and techniques - initially. The introduction of coloring turnings was somewhat shocking. Turnings SHOULD BE (must be?) Brown and Round (and smooth and symetric - and LOOK LIKE a bowl or plate or platter or . . .) And this response is understandable. Early adopters of new ideas, new tools and machines and new techniques don't initially produce fully refined ideas executed perfectly. It takes time to get really good at using new "things", to become famiiar with using new "stuff", to learn to bring out nuances that might otherwise be inaccessible.

I'm sure the early use of sand blasting a turning didn't result in a delicate enhancement of the wood like the pieces now being done by Pascal Oudet for example. Early pyrographed pieces probably weren't all that great - soldering irons being used early wouldn't permit fine line details or subtle shading the "pens" available today make possible.

There's also a certain mystique about "hand work", "sweat of the brow", "laboring over the work", "John Henry vs The Machine" thing to be overcome. In the end, does it matter HOW the result comes into being? Is it the creative idea and its execution, by whatever means, that is what's valued - or is it the blood sweat and tears (and hand cramps and burned finger tips and squinting eyes, runny nose, festering splinters and . . .) that give something its value?

Did the skilled carver see pyrography as a piker's way of putting a patterns or texture on/in wood. Did the skilled carver see power driven reciprocating carving tools as a denigration of his/her craft? Did the fret sawyer consider the power scroll saw as the end of a noble profession?

New ways of doing things already being done some other way are inevitable. And new things will be made that couldn't be made with existing tools and techniques and materials as new tools, techniques and materials come along. A little patience is often involved when early uses get shown. In time, much better pieces will follow - some we can't imagine - NOW. Those pieces are coming - and I for one am anxious to see them, maybe being one of the makers.

Re: Laser Engraver + Jig + Turning = ? *LINK*

#9

Re: Laser Engraver + Jig + Turning = ?

Dick Coers

>Denatured alcohol will remove the resin and smoke from raw wood quite easily. I don't like burning through most film finishes on my laser. It can goo up the optics and I really don't like cleaning them any more than necessary. The lense is really expensive.

Re: Laser Engraver + Jig + Turning = ? *LINK*

#10

Re: Laser Engraver + Jig + Turning = ?

charlie belden

>More info from a laser user please.

Have you done any low relief "carving" using gray scale images?

What CFM does the exhaust system have?

Are there "challenges" when laser engraving, or piercing, resinous woods?

Do you find the glue in plys - like baltic birch - to be a potential problem in terms of gunking up the lense like a film finish CAN do - if thick enough.

If you use the laser on bare wood, how do you deal with getting soot out of end grain, or avoid soaking it off the surface INTO end grain?

A million questions - but this is a start.

More info from someone with experience - working with different woods.