Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

spindle chatter

Posts

spindle chatter

#1

spindle chatter

john lucas

>I was turning a long reasonably thin spindle today out of pine. It's a test piece for the legs I'm working on. I wanted to get a full size look at the shape but it would also give a chance to find out how much chatter I would get. THe spindle is 31" long and tapers from 1 1/2 to 1". Pine flex's and chatters bad so it was a good test of my skills.

I did some experimenting with my technique. I found the most important thing other than sharpness ( and it needs to be really really sharp) is an extremely light touch on the bevel. All the force should be forward into the cut, not down on the bevel. You can hear the difference. When you push down to hard it vibrates off the chatter and makes noise. When you get the cut just right there isn't any noise and no chatter. I do move the tool handle so that the bevel is cutting at a slightly different angle than the original cut that caused the chatter.

I use my front hand over the spindle to control the flex. The less force you put on the bevel the softer your touch will be and the less you burn your fingers. When you do it correctly there is so little pressure from your fingers that you don't get any burn.

Re: spindle chatter

#2

Re: spindle chatter

DAVID J CHURNEGA

>A light touch seems to be the answer for me too. Seems incongruous with the the amount of machinery involved.

Re: spindle chatter

#3

Re: spindle chatter

Peter Lamb in SC

>John,

Why no steady rest?

Peter

Re: spindle chatter

#4

good points

John K Jordan

>I agree about being light on the bevel. One book I read long ago (it might have been Darlow's) pointed out that riding the back of the bevel on the wood will just amplify any existing irregularities behind the cut.

Something I found which really helps is to consciously apply downward force on the tool shaft itself, pressing it tight into the tool rest but carefully staying light on the cutting edge. This seems to help more than anything. This is easy with a thin shaft since I can press down with the thumb on my guiding (left) hand.

Also, for problem pieces that seem prone to chatter or bounce, it sometimes helps to cut with just the point of the heel instead of further up on the edge. Often this will smooth out the surface enough so on the next pass the bevel of the skew has a better surface to follow with the bevel.

JKJ

Re: spindle chatter

#5

Re: good points

Jorge Casta�eda

>John,

That is what I was doing last night exactly, cutting with the heal gave the less vibration and resulting roping.

Somebody order 24 drop spindles. whorls of different size and weight but the spindles themselves taper from 7mm to 4mm in 8 1/2" on one side of the whorl, and try what I may, vibration was there, I suspected my skew was dull and touched with a finger tip, nope, I was bleeding instantly so I called it a night.

That is just the prototype, I would like to know if there is some kind of steady for spindles that small.

Thanks

Jorge

Re: spindle chatter

#6

Re: good points

Barry Irby

>I am certainly no expert here, so take this with a grain of salt.

You can make a steady rest out of High Density Polyethylene (HDPE?) or anything else that is really slick. For a few pieces you could probably use a piece of dense hardwood. I made one once that had a hole in it and the piece passed through the hole. Rig up some kind of bracket and clamp it to the ways. Can be as simple as two sticks tacked together or as sophisticated as you want.

Re: spindle chatter

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: good points

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Jorge, You can make one with roller blade wheels...works well. I've found that just letting the tool feed at its own rate rather than pushing with force, makes a big difference.

Re: spindle chatter

#8

Re: good points

Jorge Casta�eda

>Thanks Barry, food for thought, I think I have some scraps of high molecular stuff.

Hi Keith, I have a steady with the roller blade wheels, but this is smaller than the smaller I can get with that, it needs to be less than 1/4" at the mid point. I was thinking of rigging something with strings like the french guys do with their "trembleurs"

Re: spindle chatter

#9

Re: good points

fgvanatta

>String steadies work fine for small spindles and are very easy to make.

Re: spindle chatter

#10

Re: good points

Barry Irby

>I turned a dowel 9' long on a two foot lathe as a sort of joke. I ripped a long thin square that would pass through the headstock and tail stock and use a four jaw chuck to drive it. The problem was that the ends would whip all over the place and then would have broken and turned into arrows. I made a series of steadies out of screw eyes and fastened them to anything that I could get into a straight line with the lathe. The short version of this is that screw eyes might work for you.

Re: spindle chatter

#11

Don't need it.

john lucas

Re: spindle chatter

#12

Re: good points

john lucas

>Yea I should have mentioned that cutting with the heel works well when you you really have a place that wants to vibrate. I think this is because the heel is very close to where the tool is supported on the rest so there is less twisting motion to the skew. As you move the cut up the tool the wood tries to pull the skew down and I think that can lead to vibration or chatter.

Re: spindle chatter

#13

Re: good points

john lucas

>Jorge A V notch cut in UHMW works great as a steady. In fact before I learned to be really light on the bevel I would push too hard which made me push too hard with my fingers. This burned my fingers to so tried just holding the UHMW against the wood. That worked pretty well. Then I built one of the steady rests that Ernie Conover showed in his book. His rest is a V notch and sits in a tapered cradle so as the size of the spindle gets smaller it slips down in the cradle which compensates for the smaller diameter. Quiet ingenious and it works. It would probably work with wheels as well as the V notch. I'll try to find a photo a post it.

Re: spindle chatter

#14

Re: good points

Jorge Casta�eda

>Thanks John,

A v notch sounds very easy and should work, I'll try it tonight.

Re: spindle chatter

#15

Re: spindle steady

john lucas

>ONe of these days I'm going to build one of these but I'm going to put some small wheel bearings on it. This looks like it would be less in the way than most others and would self adjust.

Re: spindle chatter

#16

Cool!

Jorge Casta�eda

>Sure is simple and worth a try,

Thanks for posting it John! :b

Re: spindle chatter

#17

A simplification (?)

Doc Green

>If I were building such a steady, I would get rid of the wedges.

First, I would use a clamping block to clamp the base to the ways of the lathe. That is, run a bolt through a block that fits against the underside of the ways and have this bolt extend through a slot in the base. Put the nut on top so it is easy to get to.

Second, I would thread the vertical part of the base with a 1/4 -20 hole. A bolt screwed into this hole would contact the tongue and force it against the spindle. The vertical part of the steady I envision would be truly vertical and not set at an angle to accommodate the wedge.

When installing the steady, you would position the base so that the tongue is close to the spindle. The slot in the base makes this possible. Then, apply the desired pressure with the 1/4-20 adjusting bolt and away you go!

I have two shop-made bowl steadies that use this method and they work like a charm.

Did you ever notice that it's so much easier to "improve" someone else's design rather than come up with one on your own?

~Doc

Re: spindle chatter

#18

steadying thin spindles

John K Jordan

>>...I would like to know if there is some kind of steady for spindles that small.

I think using the left hand as a steady rest (as John Lucas mentioned) is the best way to turn a thin spindle. (That is, unless it is very long in which case you might need more hands!) The hand moves with the tool keeping the work supported where needed without getting in the way. The left thumb helps control the tool near the tip; the end of the tool handle is supported under the forearm. This is the way I turn all of my magic wands where the shafts usually taper down to around 5mm or less.

I found an important thing for thin spindles is to hold one end securely in a chuck rather than turn between centers. If supported between the two points of centers, the piece pivot on each point to flex more easily and cause vibration or break. Supporting securely on the headstock end keeps that end from flexing, adding support to the whole length. For wands, instead of a 4-jaw chuck I just cut a short morse taper on the blank and press that into the headstock as a jam chuck. This gives more working room at that end.

JKJ

Re: spindle chatter

#19

Re: A simplification (?)

John Lucas

>The wedge is what makes it work so well. As you turn the spindle it gets smaller. The wedge then drops down and the contact is maintained on the spindle with out putting too much force on the spindle.

Re: spindle chatter

#20

Re: steadying thin spindles

Jorge Casta�eda

>Hi John,

Your method is what I have been trying to master, using long nose jaws in my chuck, the main difference has been that I was using my 1/2" skew with a 9" handle, so it is not long enough to put it under my arm. On the meantime I noticed that the hard maple I was using is not quite straight grained and that was some of the trouble, I just prepared some cherry that I did split to make sure it is straight. So I guess I will have to make a long handle for my little skew, or I could try using the 1 1/4" but I think is too massive for the job.

I'll get there,

Thank you

Jorge

ps are your wands Hogwarts approved? :o)

Re: spindle chatter

#21

Re: A simplification (?)

Jorge Casta�eda

>Doc,

Thanks for the suggestion, but I agree with John, no need to make it complicated when most likely is just right for this job, think turning chopsticks, that is about what I need to do.

I'll post a picture when I make the steady, thanks again John

Jorge

Re: spindle chatter

#22

short handle

John K Jordan

>Jorge,

I also use a 1/2" skew with a relatively short handle. I grip the tool with my right hand either high on the shaft or around the ferrule right where the tool enters the handle, then steady the bottom end of the handle by resting it against the under side of my wrist or forearm. This works with even a very short handle. The tool is held securely with one hand and becomes an extension of the arm.

I actually do not like long handles except for larger things like hollowing and manhandling bowls. For delicate spindle work I like short handles (7-8" is good). Frank Penta teaches this method.

Recently I began using even shorter handles - the new Unpatented JKJ NolHandle. I use the tool shaft itself with no handle. I started doing this with some small negative-rake scrapers I ground from Thompson tool stock and later found I could use the unhandled 1/2" skew (when planing) and Thompson's new St Leger small roughing gouge just as easily with no handle when doing small-diameter spindle turning. (I don't think this would work very well with a spindle or detail gouge.) The NoHandle emphasizes finesse and a delicate touch. It's also quite inexpensive. :)

JKJ

Re: spindle chatter

#23

Funny..

Jorge Casta�eda

>You should mention the no handle approach, I have been using a 3/8" bowl gauge like that for quite a while and recently the 1/4" detail spindle gouge.

The no handle thing for me started with a broken chisel that I did ground in a V shape and use it free hand as a finish scraper. Like you said, a very light touch.

I am going to try your method of holding the short handle with my left hand, as I have a broken rib in my right side and don't like anything near the sore spot, not even my arm.

Thank you John

Jorge

Re: spindle chatter

#24

Re: Funny..

John K Jordan

>Yikes, a broken rib was the most painful thing I've ever experienced.

Also, I watched myself turn some small diameters last night and noticed that when cutting cylinders and tapers I tended to hold the skew with my right hand right up near the cutting end and slide my right forefinger along the back of the toolrest - very easy to control.

JKJ