Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Attaching pedestals

Posts

Attaching pedestals

#1

Attaching pedestals

Paul Zerjay

>I looking for a different way of attaching a pedestal to a hollow form from the way I have been doing it. What I do is form a tenon on the bottom of the vessel, and cut an appropriate size hole to receive it in the pedestal "trumpet". This way you can keep a relatively thin wall thickness throughout the vessel. But this limits the depth of the cove you can cut in the trumpet. I can't tell you how many times I have ruined a piece by taking it one step too far. So I'm wondering what would be wrong if you cut the tenon on the pedestal instead and the accompanying hole in the hollow form. This would leave plenty of wood available for a nice looking cove in the trumpet portion of the pedestal. But the downside would be you would have to leave more wood at the bottom of the hollow form in order to not go through the bottom when cutting the hole for the tenon on the pedestal.

Clear as mud? What I'm trying to describe is the exact same thing as a removable finial, except the entry hole would not go through.

Take a look at this finial. If I had a tenon on the hollow form, I would have to have a hole on the inside of the finial where the cove is, and there would be no room for such a deep cove.

So what I guess I'm saying is does the extra thick bottom of the hollow form matter? Or is there a better way of doing this that I'm not aware of?


Re: Attaching pedestals

#2

JL

Re: Attaching pedestals

JL

>I am approaching this from a furniture maker's perspective - so forgive me.

I usually have the tenons on the smaller stock. It doesn't matter if they are tapered, shouldered or straight. I usually put the tenons on the smaller stock. The mortises usually go on the larger piece. It doesn't matter if it is only 100% larger in diameter or greater - the mortises go on the larger piece.

The greatest "stress" is in creating a thin - walled mortise. They don't have the "beef" to resist wood movement and are usually more difficult to make.


If you wished to "pin" your finial into your piece, that could be done with a tenon on your pedestal (finial).

Re: Attaching pedestals

#3

Re: Attaching pedestals

jack

>I concur with JL...this as I see it is a finial, not a pedestal. A pedestal would also have to be big enough to hold the weight of the form and resist tipping.

Re: Attaching pedestals

#4

Re: Attaching pedestals

fgvanatta

>The hole can be very shallow - say ~1/8" - if the corresponding tenon is short. This is only used as a "locating" tenon to get the parts aligned properly; the holding power is dependent on how much other gluing surface contact there is between the two pieces.

Re: Attaching pedestals

#5

Re: Attaching pedestals

Pete in Holland, MI

>Might not want to use a hole & tennon. Makes for a great joint on furniture, but is also so good that if your piece falls over, it may break wood rather than the easily repairable glue joint.

My 3 cents.

Re: Attaching pedestals

#6

Re: Attaching pedestals

john lucas

>Paul The length of the tenon should not matter because the glue strength will come from the total glue area. make the hole very short in the vessel. The glue strength will come from the long flat area at the bottom of the tenon. I would recess just a hair deeper in the middle to allow the glue squeeze out somewhere to go.

Then make the tenon on the pedestal short as well. The total thickness of the wood at the bottom of the vessel shouldn't matter because the wood in the pedestal will fill in that space and strengthen it. That way you will still have a thin bowl bottom and can cut the pedestal cove as steep as you want.

Re: Attaching pedestals

#7

Re: Attaching pedestals

Paul Zerjay

>John I agree with you 100%. But my wall thickness is usually 1/8th inch or less. I sure don't want to see a black dot down there in the bottom of the vessel when you take off the finial. I guess I'll just have to have a thicker bottom, unless somebody knows a better way.

Re: Attaching pedestals

#8

Re: Attaching pedestals

Stuart Johnson

>Turn a small finial on the end of the pedestal that goes into the vessel. Instead of a black dot there is a small surprise.

Re: Attaching pedestals

#9

Re: Attaching pedestals

Barry Irby

>I kind of like Stuart's idea of the little surprise.

I was thinking that you could make the hole in the pedestal quite small, perhaps a 1/4" and turn a small dowel on the bottom of the vessel. The problem I visualize with this is the wood of the bottom is quite thin and if you applied torque tot he pedestal it might pull a plug out of the bottom of the vessel, since that is end grain. Gluing the surface of the bottom foot vessel to the surface of the "cup" in the pedestal might help, but I don't have much faith in the glue joint. It would be end grain to end grain.

Re: Attaching pedestals

#10

Re: Attaching pedestals

john lucas

>Paul There's really no reason to make the bottom that thin unless you plan to pierce it. Only turners look for thin and even they can't tell how thick the bottom is as long as it doesn't feel clunky. The weight of the finial will change the balance of the piece anyway.

I've added more than a few "decorative surprises" to the bottom of pieces that were so thin you could see light through them. Nothing wrong with that. If you do it often enough it becomes a sort of signature rather than looking like you filled a mistake. Again, only turners know or care. Customers find it a unique surprise.

Re: Attaching pedestals

#11

Brad Vietje

Re: Attaching pedestals

Brad Vietje

>Paul,

I make a lot of thin hollow forms and have played around with setting them on pedestals or "feet" which are glued on/in. Couple of thoughts:

1. The balance of the piece will probably be a little better if the base is just a little thicker than the rest of the vessel. This is based on vessels with a rather narrow base, so wide forms might not be the same. When I close my eyes and rotate a piece in my hands, it just feels better that way. I also want a little more weight in the base so its less likely to fall over, having lost a few in galleries that way. Once the foot is applied, it will weigh more at the base anyway, so you won't be making matters much different with an extra 1/16 or so at the base.

2. The tenon on the base part can be really, really short -- like 1/32 or 1/64" or something crazy like that -- just a sharp-edged dent or depression that's enough to index the placement and keep things centered, so you don't need to make things any thicker if you don't want to.

3. I often break all the rules and urn HF's right on the pith, and occasionally get away with it by keeping things quite thin at the base (and turning to completion when green). These are one-piece vessels with no glue joint at the foot. More often I drill all the way through to remove the pith, which allows the piece to shrink without cracking. Then I can apply a foot as you are doing. If the tenon on the base is a contrasting wood, and has a turned point or finial that extends into the piece, that can look nice, too, as long as it looks intentional.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT