Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

McNaughton Bowl Saver Question

Posts

McNaughton Bowl Saver Question

#1

McNaughton Bowl Saver Question

Ed Larson

>I'm still in the learning phase with my McNaughton Bowl Saver. Should the knife be on the left or right side of the T-bar?? I've seen pictures of it used both ways. It there any reason to use one side or the other??

I just learned that you extend the knife all the way to the handle to determine the correct height of the knife to be cutteing just at center. This is spelled out in one of the two sets of McNaughton instructions that I have but not the other. I have the standard set of knifes and just discovered that the knife goes in the middle slot not the left slot that I have been using. Again this is not spelled out explicitly in the operating instructions.

I'm interested in any methods that people use determine the knife depth to prevent making a funnel or a very thick bowl bottom.

Re: McNaughton Bowl Saver Question

#2

Re: McNaughton Bowl Saver Question

robo hippy

>Yes, the instructions are rather lacking, and this is not a tool that you can learn all by yourself. You really need some one to help you, or there are 2 DVD's about using the tool.

It doesn't really make any difference which side of the T bar you go on. The newest version of the McNaughton has a square opening that the bar goes through, which I actually like better, but if you get it, the newer one has narrower blades for the large set, and the older ones won't fit in the new tool rest.

For aiming, I select a blade, then hold it up against the outside of the bowl you are getting ready to core. If the curve of the blade is shallower than the curve of the bowl, you want to aim more towards the center. If the blade is more curved than the outside of the bowl, then you want to aim more down the side of the bowl. I also hold the blade up over the top of the bowl, and over the gate in the exact position that I want it to end up in for a perfect core, then aim a bit shallower. The blades always seem to drift to the outside of the planned cut. McNaughton does make a laser pointer for the system, which is a big help, and so does Randy Privet of Monster tools. If you don't have a laser pointer, stop a few times during the core and look into the cut to see where it is going. For a long time, it seemed like I was always 1 inch too deep or 1 inch too shallow.

I have all 3 coring systems, and prefer this one. It is faster, and more efficient than the other systems, but there is a learning curve.

robo hippy

Re: McNaughton Bowl Saver Question

#3

Brad Vietje

Re: McNaughton Bowl Saver Question

Brad Vietje

>I'll add one little tidbit for Ed...

The different cutters ("knives") are not all the same width (thickness), nor are they the same height. Therefore, the medium knives will be loose and sloppy when used in the slot that's properly sized for the larger set of knives. Due to the height difference, they would also move too much vertically. If the knives twist in the slot, they can and will bind, which an bend them rather badly (I'm told).

Make sure the knives are in the correct slot, and hold the handle up against the T-bar when cutting. You don't resist the cutting force by holding the tool down -- let the machine do it by keeping the handle UP.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: McNaughton Bowl Saver Question

#4

Re: McNaughton Bowl Saver Question

D. Hansen

>As others have said there is a learning curve. Always start with the blade perpendicular to the face of the blank. I made a cheeep locater of aluminum to see where the blade is when working. Take a 14" flat piece of aluminum or similar stock..Make a 90 degree bend so that the length of the first leg is the same length as the blade. If you hold the other leg against the handle face you see that the first leg is now directly over the tip of the tool. The blades are curved but end up so that the tip is straight out from the center of the handle. Works and is very inexpensive.

Re: McNaughton Bowl Saver Question

#5

Any chance for a picture???

adrien

Re: McNaughton Bowl Saver Question

#6

Re: McNaughton Bowl Saver Question

Barbara R Dill

>I, too, was frustrated at first. I have made a jig that has helped me immensely in knowing where the end of the tool is. I drew two axes that intersect at 90 degrees. I put that on my lathe, having one axis represent the axis of the lathe (and the depth of the bowl). The other represents the radius of the bowl. I draw with chalk the depth and radius. I take the McNaughton blade and lay it on the depth and radius I want to end up with and use a marker to mark the blade at that depth. I also note the angle. I pull the blade out to the half way point and again mark the blade and note the angle. I lay the tool at the starting place and note the angle. Now I have reference points that will tell me where I am as I cut the cone from the wood. This has helped me a lot!

Re: McNaughton Bowl Saver Question

#7

Re: Any chance for a picture???

D. Hansen

>Gee Adrien I'm not up to pictures right now. Just envision a 1/8 inch thick piece of flat stock bent at the middle forming two legs. One leg is the length from the handle face to the end of the blade. The other leg is the height of your lathe swing. When you hold that leg to the face of the handle where the blade goes in the tip of the other leg will be at the point of the tool. Makes it easy to see where the balde is when you are coring.