Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Close Quarters Drill

Posts

Close Quarters Drill

#1

Bob Moffett

Close Quarters Drill

Bob Moffett

>Does anybody know how the Close quarters drill at Vince's Woodenwonders compares with a Milwaukee close quarters drill as far as quality and durability?

Re: Close Quarters Drill

#3

Re: Close Quarters Drill

Terry Fox

>I started with a Harbor Freight drill - piece of junk. It lasted 6 -9 months before the bearings were shot. I then got one from Vince. it has worked like a charm for two or three years, although it has just started squeaking a little when it gets hot - might be time to buy another.

Terry

Re: Close Quarters Drill

#4

Re Harbor Freight Close Quarters Drill

Jerry Hall

>I agree that HF is of uncertain quality. I had one that spit sparks, but was exchanged by mail with no hassle. The replacement has lasted 3 years and is going strong. I believe that the air intake on the HF being low down on a longer handle cuts down on the dust reaching the bearings. My Sioux went out much earlier than that. At $40 or less on sale I am going to keep with the cheapo from Harbor Freight, and just have a backup on hand. The HF drill is heavier and a bit more awkward however, but ok for me. My local repair shop replaced the bearings on my Sioux for $40, so that is a long term option also. I am reluctant to spend much more than that on a drill that is being misused for a sander.

Re: Close Quarters Drill

#5

Re: Close Quarters Drill

D. Hansen

>I'll bet if you asked him he would answer your questions. since Vince does not sell junk I would be they are rather decent drills. FYI I just picked up a cheepy on ebay for $35.00 incl shipping.

Re: Close Quarters Drill

#6

Re: Close Quarters Drill

Carole Valentine

>I have what looks like the same drill. I got mine from the Sanding Glove (he's local to me) but it is a keyless chuck for the same price as Vince's which, from the picture, appears to be a keyed chuck. If you want a keyed chuck, that one is $59 at the Sanding Glove. I have had it for around a year and it seems to be doing fine.

Re: Close Quarters Drill

#7

George Balock

Re: Close Quarters Drill

George Balock

>Bob,

I have had Milwaukee (life about 1.5 years), Grip (life about a year) and now the HF close quarters drill. The drill to me is a disposable item, and price doesn't seem to affect life, so the$40 Harbor Freight may just suit the job for me. It is a bit heavier than the Milwaukee and Grip drills, but as someone else pointed out, the air intakes are lower, so maybe so much dust won't get in. Good luck with whichever one you pick.

George

Re: Close Quarters Drill

#8

Re: Close Quarters Drill

Scott Crumpton

>If you search Amazon for "close quarters drill" you'll find some Sioux/Milwaukee clones by Neiko in the $35 range. I just got two today. Haven't had a chance to put them to wood yet, but they both spin and sound nice. Much cleaner sound and quieter than the HF which I also have.

Re: Close Quarters Drill

#9

Re: Close Quarters Drill

Vince Welch

>Hey gang,

I am in the process of acquiring quality replacement bearing for angle drills and offering replacement bearing service at a minimum fee. Should be coming together in the next two weeks.

Vince

Re: Close Quarters Drill

#10

The problem is we are using a

Jerry Hall

>drill as a sander. Never intended for that. There must be a similar tool that is actually designed for sanding, and to seal out and exhaust the dust instead of depositing it all around the drive mechanism. A close quarters drill doesn't do well as a hammer either. The closest thing to a real solution is an air sander, but they can run too fast I guess.

Re: Close Quarters Drill

#11

Re: Close Quarters Drill

robo hippy

>I have 4 of the Sioux/Milwaukee drills. I get about 450 bowls (3 to 18 inch) out of one before the bearings are shot. This is after I slowed it down to about half speed by placing a 1/4 inch piece of cork under the handle. Before that, it was in the 300 to 350 range. I have had the plastic casings replaced on all of them at least once as they wear out also. I got one of the cheap clones, and it lasted for about 50 bowls before the casing wore out. I need to get another one and do a demolition test, as well as one of Vince's. Vince does carry good stuff.

robo hippy

Re: Close Quarters Drill

#12

Re: The problem is we are using a

John K Jordan

>what about gluing a layer of thin filter material (cut from a vacuum cleaner bag?) to the inside of the ventilation slots, then keep them clean with compressed air?

JKJ

Re: Close Quarters Drill

#13

Design Flaw...

John Kaner

>My Daughters got me a Milwaukee Close Quarter Drill for Christmas. I noticed right away it pulls air from the top and exhausts through the bottom. Dumb design! Dusty air is forced into the enclosure and gets stuck to the nice lubricated bearings and motor...

My other drills from Skill, Sears, Porter Cable, etc all exhaust air at the chuck end. I've used this "exhaust" to clear sawdust after drilling.

I'm keeping it because it comes with a 5 year warranty. Don't know what that means when it comes to repair time.

Re: Close Quarters Drill

#14

Re: The problem is we are using a

Vince Welch

>HI Jerry,

A agree these drill were not oringinally designed for sanding as woodturners use them. However, because of there design, weight and familiarity they do seem to be the go to tool regarding "Power Sanding". With that said, I beleive one of the best things one can do is use compressed air to blow out the unit often. I firmly beleive in sanding slower is much better and as you mentioned air sanders tend to operate at a fast speed for what I need it for. Some folks may disagree. Pneumatic sanders are great but I find they work best with very fine sanding at 220-280 grit and higher. I've had the same knock off sander I offer on my site for three years with no issues what so ever and I have never even replaced the bearings to date! Now with having said that the bearing will go out tomorrow....lol Vince

Re: Close Quarters Drill

#15

Bob Moffett

Re: Close Quarters Drill

Bob Moffett

>Please let me know when you get the bearings and how much they are.

Re: Close Quarters Drill

#16

Bob Moffett

Re: Close Quarters Drill

Bob Moffett

>Thanks for the input everyone. Vince's drill sounds like a good one.

Re: Close Quarters Drill

#17

Re: Design Flaw...

Jerry Hall

>John, I understand the the two big makers of quality drills specifically define sanding as a misuse and will not honor the warrantee. They were replacing too many I guess. Jerry

Re: Close Quarters Drill

#18

Re: Design Flaw...

Bill Neddow

>The five-year warranty means nothing on the Milwaukee if they have even a hint of suspicion that you might have been using it for sanding. My Milwaukkee died after 10 months and the Milwaukee repair depot refused to honor the warranty because I was honest and told them I used it for sanding.

Re: Close Quarters Drill

#19

Re: Design Flaw...

John Kaner

>Thanks Jerry and Bill. Time to return it and see about the ones Vince sells.