Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Black Walnut - Dangerous?

Posts

Black Walnut - Dangerous?

#1

Black Walnut - Dangerous?

Bob S

>I am curious if turning black walnut is hazardous or not. I seem to recall hearing certain wood species were unhealthy to inhale. So far, as i am a newbie, i am getting very high from the whole experience of woodturning.

Bob

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

#2

Re:Some people are sensitive and .......

JamieDonaldson

>...most are not, and it can be a beautiful wood for turning. The usual problem is breathing the sanding dust, so try it and find out, without inhaling significant amounts of dust.

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

#3

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

Carole Valentine

>I turned a lot of black walnut when I first started turning with no ill effects. Then after a couple of years, I started getting a sinus reaction to the dust. I don't turn it much any more, but when I do I wear a respirator. I think it's one of those woods that once you are sensitized to it, the reaction only gets worse. Fortunately I don't have a dermatological reaction to it...yet.

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

#4

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

john lucas

>Doesn't bother me but my Dad is allergic to it. I try to keep the dust collector nearby when I turn it just in case.

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

#5

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

Barry Irby

>I am mildly allergic to it. I found out by letting dust accumulate under my watch in the summer. It stuck in the perspiration. When I wiped it off, the skin came with it.

I also have the sinus reaction to it and it gives me a cough. So, when I work with it I wear a tyvek suit and a respirator. As soon as I leave the shop I take a shower. I vac off and blow off the dust before leaving the shop. I also run dust collection while working with it.

Takes most of the fun out of walnut.

My understanding is that David Ellsworth is severely allergic to it and won't turn it anymore.

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

#6

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

John K Jordan

>>I seem to recall hearing certain wood

>species were unhealthy to inhale.

Bob,

ALL wood species are unhealthy to inhale! Wood in the form of very fine dust can cause severe respiratory problems. There are credible stories of people who worked unaffected by certain species for years then developed allergic reactions - as if lengthy exposure sensitized them. Reactions can be to the skin as well. It is my understanding that nearly any species of wood can cause problems in the long run.

Personally, I am affected by fine dust from several species: cocobolo and eastern red cedar on the skin; walnut by respiration. If I do not wear breathing protection while even casually sanding walnut I will definitely feel it, so I don't let that happen. If I work in a room where walnut is being machined my sinuses are affected unless I use breathing protection, even though the quantity of fine dust is nothing like that from sanding.

Cocobolo has a reputation for being a problem. If I leave cocobolo dust on my skin, I will get a rash. Eastern red cedar on my skin causes a rash IF it remains for some time and especially if moistened, such as by sweat under a watch. I manage this problem by wearing long sleeves when sanding. (And ALWAYS wearing a respirator while sanding.)

My favorite lung protection is a dual-filter industrial respirator - lightweight, comfortable, and very effective. I also have one with a full face shield I use at times, but it can get warm in the summer. For the summer, I use a powered faceshield that uses a fan to pull air in through a filter. This is pretty comfortable in the summer but the filters are not as good as the industrial respirator. You have to keep batteries charged as well.

I also use a Jet ceiling-mounted air filter system. If positioned correctly, this will circulate air in the shop and remove much of the fine dust, giving the respirator less to do. Some people use a dust collector at the lathe itself but I don't have that yet.

There is an easy way to test a wood species to see if you are sensitive: create a bit of fine dust and trap it under a piece of tape or bandaid to some sensitive area of skin, such as the inside of the forearm. If that species is a problem, it will itch and the skin will turn red after a some time.

BTW, black walnut shavings are toxic to some animals, especially horses.

JKJ

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

#7

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

Pete in Holland, MI

>Oh, and, when you can't get that dark staining off your hands at the end of the day...........lemon juice.

Pete

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

#8

Rob Wallace

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

Rob Wallace

>"Better things, for better living, through chemistry!"

1. Tannin + Fe+++/Fe++ [black]

2. drop pH (ascorbic acid & citric acid )

3. Tannin [colorless] + ferric or ferrous citrate/ascorbate [colorless]

:D

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

#9

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>The dust makes me sneeze, but I still turn it and wear a mask when sanding.

keithz

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

#10

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

robo hippy

>There is a reason why things have trouble growing under walnut trees. I turn green wood, so dust isn't a problem. If I am turning black walnut, a few pieces isn't a problem, but if I am turning it for a good part of the day, I notice it is irritating, so I will wear a dust mask. Smaller chunks up the nose will sneeze/blow out, but the mask is better than my beard. As far as people reacting to walnut bowls, I haven't heard of any one having problems with the dried and finished wood. I do tell people that the wood is strongly scented, and can 'flavor' whatever you are eating out of the bowl. I think it would add to salads, but take away from soup or ice cream.

robo hippy

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

#11

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

Don at Central Illinois

>Haven't you ever had black walnut ice cream?

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

#12

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

Bernie Weishapl

>Some people are allergic and some are sensitive to walnut or other woods. It doesn't bother me unless I breath the sanding dust. Of course this is true with any wood when I am sanding. When the doctor told me after I developed a respiratory infection from breathing sanding dust while using a paper mask that it could possibly lead to emphysema I took notice. You only get one set of lungs so I got a respirator. It goes on as soon as I start turning as it is my face mask to.

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

#13

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Bob, I would say any wood dust is unhealthy to inhale. Some will give almost allergic reactions to certain people. If I don't wear a respirator type head gear while turning any kind of walnut I get big time headaches the next morning. I call it my walnut hangover.

Jennifer

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

#14

Dust & shavings

Jack Savona

>JKJ is right in reminding all of us that all dust, especially the finer dust from finer grits of sanding, can be hazardous to inhale (although probably not as bad as the dust of sand and glass from dressing the grinding wheel).

But back to the walnut. As a tangent to your question, I've read a lot about shavings from walnut being toxic to horses (and possibly other animals) as well as toxic to growing plants. So...don't give shavings with walnut to horse owners or put them in your garden. I'm even careful about not giving walnut shavings to the local animal shelter.

So, whatever walnut has in it, if its toxicity affects plants and animals....

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

#15

Re:The problem with walnut and horses....

JamieDonaldson

>....is when the walnut shavings are in bedding, contributing to founder, an often fatal foot deformation.

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

#16

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

Bob S

>WOW - What a response. Thank you all. I have enjoyed reading everyones feed back as I get them in my email. The one from Jennifer hit the nail on the head, finally. I had a very bad headache Sunday morning for no apparent reason. Sure felt like a hangover, now i know 'walnut hangover'. I wasn't even thinking about that when i wrote the question, i was just wondering......

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

#17

Re: Black Walnut - Dangerous?

jim miles  - Charlote NC

>Be careful about putting it around plants for mulch - killed some azealeas that way