Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

New regulations on finishing safety

Posts

New regulations on finishing safety

#1

New regulations on finishing safety

Russ Fairfield

>I have received several inquiries about the new regulations on finishin safety and childrens toys; and how it might affect the things we make. In the broad definition, anything we make could be chewed on by a child. In the past, there has been little if any enforcement action. It remains to be seen what the Federal Bureaucrats do with this one. Personally, I think the law was written for the big toy importers, and there are bigger fish to fry than a woodturner who wants to make a salad bowl.

I may be wrong, but I think there is much ado about nothing. The reality is that we have been under the law since lead and cadmium were removed from finishes in 1978. All the new regulations say is, "Prove it."

I suspect that we will be getting more questions about food and child safety of what we make. But, that has happened every time there has been anything in the news about finishing safety in the last 30 years.

There has always been a provision that says we can be asked to prove that the finishes we use are in compliance, that they contain no Lead or Cadmium, and that we have used them in accordance with the manufacturers instructions. Any finishing product that contains neither cadmium nor lead is in compliance with the FDA regulation, but until now there has been no way to bring legal action agaiist violators. This new law corrects that.

What is missing from the news stories about the toy problem is that several of the domestic finishing and paint manufacturers have lobbied for these new regulations because it will allow them to put a "food safe" and "kid safe" label on the can, and use that as an excuse for raising the price without changing the product.

Re: New regulations on finishing safety

#2

Re: New regulations on finishing safety

fgvanatta

>Just use shellac. It's used for piano finish and to coat M & M's. So you can easily get a beautiful, edible finish.

Re: New regulations on finishing safety

#3

karl jr

My 2 cents FWIW

karl jr

>I've been reading up on this a bit lately, and here's what I've come up with.

Medicinal grade mineral oil and beeswax are explicitly exempted from CPSIA (Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act) lead content testing requirements. They are considered food products, not consumer products, and are therefore regulated by the FDA, not the CPSC (Consumer Product Safety Commision).

Shellac, although proposed as an exempted item, is NOT exempt from testing. The key to this is that it may have been "adulterated or modified" in its manufacture. And yes, I know that more shellac is used as candy- or pill-coating than is used in woodworking. Go figure.

Paint and other surface coatings are also no-no's and products on which they are used must be tested.

Adhesives appear to be ok, since they are not exposed.

Dyes are also ok. Pigments may not be because their manufacture is a sophisticated process that may or may not include the use of lead in the chemistry.

(See http://www.cpsc.gov/library/foia/foia09/brief/leadfinalrule.pdf)

Products intended primarily to be used by people over the age of 12 are not subject to the CPSIA lead testing requirements.

(See http://www.cpsc.gov/cpscpub/pubs/thrift/thrguid.pdf)

Here's another onerous twist to the story. Products primarily intended for use by children 12 or younger must have a "tracking label" whether they are made exclusively of exempted materials or not. These labels must contain "certain basic information, including the source of the product, the date of manufacture and more detailed information on the manufacturing process such as a batch or run number."

(See http://www.cpsc.gov/about/cpsia/sect103.html)

Sorry about all this, but I'm just I just live in MN. You can thank MN Senator Kloubuchar.

Re: New regulations on finishing safety

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: New regulations on finishing safety

Keith Tompkins

>This law pertains to much more than finishes on kid's toys...the motorcycle industry is in chaos, since motorbikes designed for kids contain traces of lead or other heavy metals and can no longer be sold. That's just one example I've read about.