Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

Posts

New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#1

Brad Vietje

New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

Brad Vietje

>Seems like I'm handling a lot of firewood these days. We heat exclusively with wood in the "house" (my future shop!), and we're keeping the new straw bale house warm enough to allow the earthen plasters to dry with a second wood stove...

Turns out, I've seen some pretty nice-lookin' firewood lately! Here's some Yellow Birch with real nice curly figure:


So, how about some design or turning challenge to create something turned from firewood? This might not be fair to those down South, but they've been feezin' their butts off this winter, so maybe they should be burning wood :) We'd have to come up with a rule or two, but the deadline is real easy -- March 20, the vernal equinox and the first day of Spring!

Whatcha think?

Safe spinning,

Bad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#2

It's all Firewood...

mjonesrdg

>Yesterday I turned a small lidded box (something like a Stafford box) of desert ironwood that I had brought back from Baja. It just might be the most beautiful wood I've ever turned. The chatoyance from the light colored grain is absolutly golden and contrasts with the darker streaks. It's a little like cocobolo but prettier.

In BAJA, the locals go out into the desert with beater-truck and chain...they yank it up roots and all, (few own a chain saw) and drag it home. A stem 6" diameter takes two days to burn through. To them, it's just firewood.

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#3

Steven Antonucci

I'd have to pull that piece for handles

Steven Antonucci

>roliing pins, and other future considerations! I have a rule about "wood that's too good to burn must be saved to turn!"

Steve

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#4

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

John K Jordan

>I posted this picture before, splitting white oak firewood one day when I ran into some figure I couldn't resist taking inside. I thought about this again just a while ago while bringing in wood to load up the stove for the night - several had some amazing crotch figure destined to go up the chimney.


Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#5

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

>This was also picked from the firewood pile.

Dave

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#6

Ellis Walentine

Great idea, Brad

Ellis Walentine

>In fact, I wouldn't mind making an official WoodCentral turning contest out of it. But March 20 is too soon if we make it official. I'd like to get a sponsor and advertise the contest a bit. What would you think of having the deadline be on the summer solstice instead of the vernal equinox?

Thinking out loud here, one of the rules of the contest might be to include at least one picture of the firewood log before you start cutting it up and turning it. Also, what is firewood anyway? Should it be a split piece? If not, what makes it different from any other log section that you might turn something from?

And should there be a limitation on what you can turn from it? It's hard to judge a contest when one piece is a goblet and the next is a bowl or a hollow form. How about plates?

Sorry for all the qualifications and questions. I'll be happy to help host the contest, but I'll need a little time to put the pages together and line up a sponsor, judges, etc. Let's keep talking about it.

Ellis

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#7

ebd

Re: It's all Firewood...

ebd

>This was from a black walnut tree that was cut down and split up for firewood. They should have been shot. The butt of the tree was about 4 feet diameter.

It's 8" in diameter, 3" high, walls are 1/8th and it's light as a feather. Probably the best unsegmented piece I've ever done.



Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#8

goblet!

John K Jordan

>My thoughts on the object to be turned: since firewood is often handled in split pieces 3"-6" in diameter, it may be difficult for some to find a useful piece for a plate or even a reasonable-sized bowl. The bowl I pictured was only around 4" in diameter. And as you mention, what's the difference between a turner's log section and firewood other than the intention?

I like the idea of a spindle-oriented turning such as a goblet.

About the summer, some people tend to turn more in the fall/winter. If the contest happened to be in cold weather or in the fall with impending cold weather, a functional goblet could also be used to toast the fireplace and the blessing of a warm, cozy place (and make a nice Christmas present)!

JKJ

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#9

Le�a

Jorge Casta�eda

>This is one of my saves: ,

So let's hear the rules...

Thanks

Jorge

Le�a means firewood

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#10

Re: Great idea, Brad

John Lucas

>I'm not sure that would be any different than turning something from 2 square feet or a 4 piece of 2x4. It really leaves the work open to imagination. It does make it hard to judge so you may have to include originality,and ingenuity in the rules for the judges.

I'm not sure how you would regulate what is and isn't considered firewood.

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#11

How about requiring a "before" photo??

Russ Fairfield

>It will add interest and keep everyone honest.

There can be some nicely figured wood in the firewood bundles at the grocery stores and Home Depot.

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#12

Re: How about requiring a "before" photo??

Carole Valentine

>Any piece of wood in my shop...including already turned or rough turned stuff, is potential firewood!

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#13

Re: How about requiring a "before" photo??

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Carole, you mean that the lovely little briarwood HF in my collection was once on your firewood pile?

Wally

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#14

Re: How about requiring a "before" photo??

Carole Valentine

>Uh, no, that one wasn't Wally...but it could have easily become firewood after I put a gouge to it! Has happened before. LOL

Hope you are feeling better.

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#15

And a standard firewood length

Jorge Casta�eda

>Around here fitted firewood is always 16" and most of the time is split.

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#16

How about you have to buy the firewood......

Barry Irby

>from Irby Firewood, Inc. No, not that, you have to buy it from the borg or super market. Submit the receipt, showing the sale amount and complete with the drawing of the project on the receipt.

Or maybe leave some part of the original surface showing in the work?

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#17

Re:Buy firewood? You mean to actually .....

JamieDonaldson

>...pay some stranger to deliver wood, and I would have to make some form of payment to them? What a strange practice! My firewood grows and falls in the woods all around me, and my chainsaws recycle those trees into free BTU supply material for my Buck stove.!!

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#18

Does stuff from the past qualify?

Mike Brazeau

>Two of my favorite bowls came from my BIL's firewood pile. I think it was in 2002.

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#19

Re: How about you have to buy the firewood......

John K Jordan

>With over 50 trees down on my property from storms there is no WAY I'm going to buy a stick of firewood. Hmm, unless perhaps I can find some kingwood firewood, or some big leaf maple burl firewood, or some cuban mahogany firewood...

JKJ

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#20

Prob not if the rules require a "before" photo

John K Jordan

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#21

Ellis Walentine

I think we'll have to keep this one informal

Ellis Walentine

>The more we talk about this concept, the more I think you might want to go with your initial instinct rather than making this a regulation WoodCentral contest. I'm concerned that the rules are going to be way too squishy to properly judge entries. I have another contest brewing that will be more specific.

Anyhow, nothing wrong with having a contest that just lives here on the messageboard. I don't know if or how you should reward the winners, or if there even need to be any winners. Everyone wins.

Could be fun. Thanks for the suggestion and for all the discussion about firewood as a contest parameter. I wish it were easier.

Ellis

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#22

Brad Vietje

Here's a new twist...

Brad Vietje

>When I started thinking of what the rules might be, I realized this wasn't going to be all that easy. Plus, it's hard to involve our Southern friends in something that involves firewood.

I think I agree that a Firewood theme might be an informal design challenge here on the board, and not an official contest, per se. The idea of having to go to the big box borg and buy firewood, though, excites me about as much as it does Jamie. I have 15 acres of land, 10 is dense forest, and 4 logging operations within a mile of my house, so I am literally "out in the woods" (which gives me an idea for yet another thematic design challenge...).

SO, how's about a new twist on the theme? Maybe we should stick with the fire theme, and think about turnings "Touched By Fire"... That could include firewood, wood scorched by fire, pyrography or friction burned lines, or even wood salvaged from a forest fire or a burned out building. I would suggest that the influence of fire be visible in the finished piece. Touched by Fire in my mind means charred, burned, or scorched in some way, not "Inspired by Fire" (another possible theme), which would be influenced by fire, like flame shapes and flame finials, kinetic sculptures, etc..., but would not need to be actually burned in any way. We could save that idea for another day.

What does everyone (or Ellis, who out-votes everyone) think of the Touched by Fire idea?

Safe spinning (and fire prevention),

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: New Contest/Design Challenge Idea???

#23

Bill Blasic

Re: Here's a new twist...

Bill Blasic

>Brad,

I think that you should just stick to your original premise and take a picture of your wood/firewood and then a picture of what you did with it. just my two cents.

Bill