Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Cutting Up Burls

Posts

Cutting Up Burls

#1

Brad Vietje

Cutting Up Burls

Brad Vietje

>This relates to Brent Smth's question from a few days ago, and Jorge's post of a few burls to cut up... There's no "right" way, and it depends on what you want to get out of it at the end.

Here's a large-ish (~200#) hunk of Black Cherry Burl I decided to cut into yesterday:


...and here's the other side:


Due to numerous extensive bark in-foldings, multiple shallow lobes, and a fairly flat shape, there's maybe one medium natural-edge bowl in here, and a bunch of smaller pieces. There's also some sapwood degradation and bug holes on the flatter face shown in the second photo. I decided to hack out chunks for small bowls and cut the rest into boxes, stoppers, etc..., and save the bigger part for a warmer day, as it was about 24 degrees (F) and falling pretty quickly when I coated these.

Here's the carcass with Anchorseal on the cut faces, at the bottom, plus a few other chunks I decided to coat:


I'm sure there are other opinions about cutting this up, but since every burl is different, its pretty hard to know until you make a few cuts, and then you're committed!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Cutting Up Burls

#2

Steven Antonucci

Kudos to you

Steven Antonucci

>A lot of folks would have been tempted to try and make one enormous something out of that burl with semi satisfactory results. It takes a fair amount of courage to hack it to pieces for best figure...

I need to go burl hunting again...

s

Re: Cutting Up Burls

#3

Does this qualify as Firewood?

A. Kapocius

Re: Cutting Up Burls

#4

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Kudos to you

Katherine Kowalski

>After taking Cindy Drozda's 5-day workshop on lidded vessels and discovering how to use burl to best advantage -- getting the best piece from a given bit of wood, instead of using ALL the wood to make a single piece -- it gave me the needed courage to cut into some expensive burls to get the figure I wanted on the finished piece.

Now I'm a confirmed burl girl, and I have no fear of cutting in! I think that's the thing I love most about burl -- there are so many ways to cut it, so many patterns of grain to reveal -- they're endlessly exciting! :-)

Re: Cutting Up Burls

#5

Steve Kubien

I have minimal experience...

Steve Kubien

>...cutting up burls like this. What could one expect to find if the straights ends were cut off and the whole thing was mounted in the orientation you have it shown, pith to pith? Would you expect rather bland grain near the centre or would the figure likely run throughout? If throughout, I would be tempted to make one large hollowform. As I said, I've never been in this situation, but hope to be someday!

I would appreciate your thoughts on this.

Re: Cutting Up Burls

#6

Katherine Kowalski

Re: I have minimal experience...

Katherine Kowalski

>Burl tends to grow on the outside of the main branch/trunk. If you turned the piece with the pith at either end, you would have a standard ring pattern at the top and bottom of the form, and part way up the sides. The wider parts of the side of the vessel would have burl eyes coming from every angle, (since the burl eyes tend to grow outward).

(Alternatively, if the burl was cut "sideways" it would produce chatoyant lines indicating the paths of the burl eyes.)

Katherine

Re: Cutting Up Burls

#7

The bison treatment...

Jorge Casta�eda

>Steve,

Making a hollow form with the pith as axis makes a fine vessel, sometimes ornated by a window or two that lets you peek inside, but at a high price, as most of the burl will be rendered as shavings.

Where I am burls are far from common, and cost many a pretty penny, I don't know what causes them, but I have been in places both in Vermont and in Quebec where seems like every tree has them, makes me think of a viral thing.

As they are not common, to me burls are to be utilized to the max, just like the native americans did with the bison. Waste litle.

In my limited experience with burls, the general public is not fascinated as much with the grain, they are by the intricate shapes under the bark, so I try to make some live edge things too.

Jorge

Re: Cutting Up Burls

#8

Brad Vietje

Re: I have minimal experience...

Brad Vietje

>Um -- well, it depends on how early in the tree's life the burl got started.

Burls tend to grow outward in a conical shape to form "heads", but if there are more than one point of origin, these individual growths will bump into each other, forming lobes -- usually with bark inclusions between them that persist. I do go for the largest single piece that can be turned from the largest lobe or burl head, which can also be cored to create more than one piece if its bowls you are making.

I have some pieces turned on the pith with burl figure all the way around, and just a little "regular" wood at either end, surrounding the pith, but this is a rare condition, as most of these big, "segmented" or multi-lobe burls would not result in solid wood all around the pith. Rather, they would have a bigger chunk here, a dead and decaying chunk there, and a lobe growing over the dead parts as a sort of burl scab. That's why a neat, plump, round burl head is so valuable, especially if it lacks lobes, "butt cheeks", or bark inclusions. These are the thing that become Mahoney nested sets, and are not very common.

Here's a roughly 10" tall hollow form rough turned right on the pith (I driled out a 1/2' hole through the bottom, coated with a little Tried & True for seasoning


You can see a little straight grain near the foot, and up around the opening. I'm still experimenting with some sort of base for this one.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT