>I had to do some tests this morning so I thought I would post a photo of our color checker chart. This has been downloaded on my calibrated monitor and the gray was set dead on using photo shop and the exposure is accurate. You should be able to see if your monitor is close. I just thought it would be interesting even for my home computer.
>Now, John, how is anyone going to be able to tell if these colors are right if their monitor is off?
I'm joking here, but if someone's monitor is off, they will see the colors off too. I am using two different LCD monitors here (one standalone HP monitor and a Dell laptop monitor), neither being calibrated (work systems), and the colors are different on each.
My monitor at home is calibrated and I'm sure it will be accurate, but there are a lot of people out there that don't have calibrated monitors so the colors they see will not be the colors you or I see.
>...monitor color is the white to black scale at the bottom. There should be no color cast in the white to black squares, and a good gamma check is to see all the squares from white to black as distinct and equally separate.The next row up are the primary colors of blue, green, red, yellow, magenta and cyan. They are the standards for both additive and subtractive colors that should appear accurate on monitors, and the remaining colors on the rows above are various blends of the primaries that are harder to compare without a chart being handy.Hey John,your Macbeth CC is in better shape than my old Kodak!
>Your right. I should have told them to check the bottom line. It should be white to gray to black. Any color shift will show up in the middle gray very noticeably.
OK -- I look at the bottom row... Now what? If I want to adjust anything, what do I do? I'm using a Toshiba laptop with Firefox running on Windows XP...
In my experience with optics and such, I probably can't tell if it's right unless I can adjust it back and forth to sense where the neutral position is. Just like the focus in a telescope or microscope -- since we all have different eyes, the focus has to be adjusted for each person, but most don't dare. I've learned when showing people something like the moon in a telescope to duck in-between each viewer and screw up the focus intentionally. That way, they have to make the adjustment to get the clearest view. Otherwise, they will assume either their eyesight is no good, or my telescope is no good, and just put up with what they see -- and miss the details they could be seeing.
SO, how can I tell if my screen is off without tweaking it to and fro?
>...begins to come into play! Do you have any Adobe products that have loaded Adobe Gamma in your Windows Control Panel? There are many free downloads like Calibrize.com that also have tutorials for display calibration and profiles. Each computer has a display card that controls monitor operations, and my Dell laptop has Start>Control Panel> Display> ATI Mobility Radeon > Color- with sliders which adjust the colors with the Color Checker John posted on screen. And BTW,this should be done in a darkened room with no lights falling on the screen! Look for color casts in the white to black scale as I mentioned, and the colors adjusted to the true colors of the CC, then saved as a profile for your monitor.
>It seems to me that if the monitor is not adjusted properly, then the chart displayed on that monitor won't be displaying proper colors. And there is no way to know that without an original chart to compare to.
Therefore, the only way to correctly adjust the monitor is to have a hard copy original of the chart (not printed through your computer) in hand to compare to what is shown on the monitor.
A chart shown on the screen or printed at home cannot be used as the master.
>All you have to do is look at the gray patches on the bottom. If they appear reddish or blueish (technical terms) then you may need to adjust the screen to get them to look gray. Exposure is kind of a guess. The left patch should look white and the right one should look black. If not adjust your brightness levels.
You can pretty much ignore the colors because a tiny shift in color one way or the other will show up in these but only if you have the original to compare. Gray on the other hand should be gray, not blue gray, green gray, red gray etc.
I just posted this because when we look at photos and they appear red, blue, light or dark you really don't know if it's your computer or the the photo was bad. Might also help someone diagnose a problem with posting their photos.
I also thought it would be interesting to see how good WC is at printing colors correctly. They are dead on as near as I can tell.
I like learning new geeky stuff. I didn't have an overall color shift or imbalance, but I did increase the brightness a bit. I could also see the obvious imbalance when any color was a bit off.
>I also see the all the colors and the white and grays are clear/pure colors.
I am viewing this on a Dell 1750 LCD laptop screen. The concerns I have are the different brightness and contrast I can get by moving the screen toward me or away from me. How am I to know what position to set the screen to know where to correct the image? I did not have this issue on my CRT monitor when i had a desktop computer.
>>...different brightness and contrast I can get by moving the screen...
That is one of the biggest problems of using LCD screens for critical graphics and photo work, worse in a laptop than a desktop due to variable tilt - you are stuck with trying to position the screen consistently each time. As one author puts it, "Most laptop LCD screens are poorly suited for critical image editing because gamma is extremely sensitive to viewing angle." (The little-understood gamma value is the cornerstone of device calibration.) To see how bad it can be look at the gamma chart section on this page and watch how the gamma (and black level!) changes when you tilt the screen.
(To get a good idea of some of the issues, read the whole page. All this quickly gets confusing. Digital color management is one of those areas where ignorance really is bliss!)
Note that when using a desktop monitor, you are generally sitting in a chair at nearly the same position each time so you have a better shot at consistency.
Some lcd monitors are much better than others. The specs for falloff at horizontal and vertical viewing angles give a clue. I used dual Planar monitors on my graphics/video workstation and they were excellent. (Of course they were $900 each!)
One way to work with LCD is to find a good gray scale calibration chart or create your own calibration check strip. Display this while working to ensure a consistent viewing angle, at least while adjusting brightness and contrast. When using dual monitors, I made special charts to spread across both monitors to make sure they matched.
BTW, another factor usually ignored but important for critical color work is ambient light. How we perceive color and contrast on a monitor varies with the brightness and color of the ambient light so the monitor needs to be calibrated for specific lighting. This is especially a problem when working on a laptop since it might be moved from tungsten to daylight to fluorescent environments. What's a graphic artist to do? (answer: don't work from a laptop or if necessary, plug in a desktop monitor for critical work!)
>Thanks John! This is quite a page. I will read it all tonight when I have time. I am still busy building my "Boiler Barn". Turning time in the shop would feel like a vacation.
>...to the subject. Many viewers would benefit from this info when shopping for a new "HDTV" these days, as the viewing angles of an LCD screen are much more narrow than a plasma, and there is a big difference when standing in a darkened sales area and installation in a lighted living room. Although LCD technology is improving rapidly, the range of contrast and color saturation can be significantly affected by ambient light levels and viewing angles. The ideal viewing environment of theatre seating in a dark room painted 18% gray wouldn't appeal to many for living room decor!
>One thing I didn't mention in my terse description of my monitor is that Samsung provides a utility with the monitor that all allows the user to setup the monitor to suit themselves. It has three main sections that include:
Initial setup that allows the user to adjust the overall screen intensity balance using gray leaf images all over the screen.
Gamma adjustment,
And individual red, blue green intensity levels.
Finally, when you are done with the monitor, you can move on to your printer and tune it up.
Foot note: About 15 years ago I bought a Sony XBR 52" rear projection TV. After a month of "burn in" I had it professionally calibrated using a Phillips Color meter. After the calibration, I opened up the box and unplugged the Scan Velocity Modulation(SVM) function.
This TV has never had a service call and still produces a reasonable picture. Why, because the set has been adjusted to work correctly. The color temp was set to 6500 degrees Kelvin, the color guns are working withing proper intensity, and their is no phony white/black intensity enhancements introduced by SVM. Sure a calibration will cost you two or three hundred dollars, but it will make a difference in your viewing.
>The right way is to calibrate your own monitor, like with a Datacolor Spyder, but there are charts on the net, or this one, that can get you close for free.