Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Box turning question

Posts

Box turning question

#1

JL

Box turning question

JL

>Okay - do ya'll turn the lids first or the bottoms?

I started doing my bottom first, then I worked on the lid a bit and finished it and then finished my bottom.

As I don't turn many boxes, I was curious.

Re: Box turning question

#2

Re: Box turning question

John Lucas

>I do the same. Mainly because sometimes I will use the bottom as a jam fit for the top so I can do some turning on the top. Then pull the top off and make it fit the way I want.

Re: Box turning question

#3

Box turning question answer

Ed Moore in SW VA

>JL,

ALWAYS make the female part first. It is much easier to adjust the male part for whatever fit you want.

When I teach Ornaments and Boxes in May at JCCFS I will teach only boxes with inset lids. In that case the lid is made last.

When the top/lid fits down over the tenon on the bottom, finish the top before adjusting the tenon on the bottom for fit.

Ed

Re: Box turning question

#4

Re:  Box turning question answer

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryAo1Kz+awUUYH8ShA---

>There are different ways to do it. But, yes, in keeping with the others, a good way is to start with a female lid. Remember to sand and finish the inside of the lid before you take it off because in this approach this is your last chance to finish the inside of the lid. Then do the male bottom part of the box and jam fit the lid on it so you can clean up the top of the lid. Remember to leave enough wood in the chuck when you part off the bottom part so that you can turn a tenon and jam fit the bottom onto the tenon so that you can clean up the bottom of the bottom. Make sense?

Re: Box turning question

#5

karl jr

Re: Box turning question

karl jr

>I turn the body of the box first, then jam chuck it onto the lid to finish the bottom. Then hollow the top. Reverse on a jam chuck and finish the top of the lid.

Fitting the lid has been hit or miss for me. Either loose or tight... can't find the middle ground.

In-fitting lids seem to work better for me. I'm not sure why. I think it's because the shape opens up once it's hollowed, making it tighter.

Re: Box turning question

#6

Re:  Box turning question answer

john lucas

>I don't know about the others but I put the female part on the lid so that things inside the box don't get pinched by the lid. Imagine if you filled the box with sand. You can fill it further with the male part in the bottom. At least that's why I do it.

Re: Box turning question

#7

JL

Thanks for the responses..

JL

>I guess I'm going to have to turn some more boxes and see which way is more comfortable to me. Intuitively, it seems that trimming down the male part is easier.

Re: Box turning question

#8

Dick Hines

Re: Thanks for the responses..

Dick Hines

>I do the bottom first. I true of the wood and then cut off a piece for the top. Then shape the bottom. That way I have enough wood for a jam chuck to finish the bottom of the box.

One thing to remember in fitting the lid is that anything taken off the left side also comes off the right side. In other words it the lid is 1/32" to big don't take 1/32" off the tenon. That will add up to 1/8".

Re: Box turning question

#9

Brad Vietje

Um,... that would be 2/32 = 1/16" Right?

Brad Vietje

Re: Box turning question

#10

Mike Stafford

Dick hasn't been the same since he tripped....

Mike Stafford

>over his woodpile.

I think the shop remodeling incident when he fell has made it worse. LOL!

Love ya, man!

Re: Box turning question

#11

Dick Hines

Re: Dick hasn't been the same since he tripped....

Dick Hines

>What ever! You got the idea.

And you are right about the fall, Mike. The arm is still not back to 100%.

Re: Box turning question

#13

Mike's box is in the traditional ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

>style with a tenon on the bottom and a lid that fits over the tenon. Please note that Mike finishes the inside of the top (female part) before he does the bottom, which has the tenon (male part).

As I mentioned above, turn the female part first and then fit the male part.


These walnut boxes have inset lids, so the bottom part is turned first.

Sequence matters!

Ed