Honing
Jeff Rich
>Just a tip.....
I bought some diamond hones last week and sharpened my skews.
What a difference it makes!
The skew really cuts as it should cut.
The surface was silky and the cutting was effortless.
Thanks Alan Lacer!
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Honing
Jeff Rich
>Just a tip.....
I bought some diamond hones last week and sharpened my skews.
What a difference it makes!
The skew really cuts as it should cut.
The surface was silky and the cutting was effortless.
Thanks Alan Lacer!
Re: Honing
john lucas
>Just as Russ says. The skew should be the sharpest tool in your collection.
Re: Honing
Jeff Rich
>It cuts like a dream now!
No more spiral pattern.
Re: Honing
Jim Sebring
>I gotta get me one of them thar 'no spiral' hones. The ones i have still let thet thar skue do spirals an' such. Some times the's real pretty 
Re: Honing
Jeff Rich
>I purchased a 4 sided CHEAP hone from everyones favorite cheap tool store just on a whim. It really made a difference on the 600 grit, which I suppose you could do with other sharpening systems. Your skew must be super sharp and just enough pressure to keep the bevel rubbing. I hope it doesnt take everyone 15 years to figure it out like it did me, LOL.
I plan to buy another set that includes the cone shaped stones that diamond impregnated. I have found only one place that has this 4 piece set, does anyone know if its available elsewhere?
I would like to find a local store, just trying to help the local economy, but will mail order if needed.
Re: Honing
Bill Neddow
>Try honing your bowl gouge -- especially if you have one of Doug Thompson's gems. The steel is strong enough that the "scary edge" does not break off as with M2 steel. It cuts smoother and faster.
Also, sharpen and hone just before the fina cut. If you have a long fingernail shape on your gouge, you can then sheer scrape or better still, sheer cut to get a finish that will allow you to start sanding with 220 grit. I did this again last night on a piece of Walnut. By sheer cutting, I mean opening the fluted, while in sheer scraping mode, so that instead of scraping, you are cutting. You should get extremely fine ribbons of wood coming off. You can not only easily remove any tearout but also easily get rid of all the ridges this way. Just make sure you keep the end of the handle way down, or you will get a catch. You want the tool edge coming across the bowl at a 45 degree angle.
I think part of the reason I never honed anything but a skew before is that I was using cheap hones and they did not work that well. I finally broke down and bought one of Alan Lacer's hones last fall. It makes a huge difference.
Bill, could you Explain that better?
Barry Irby
>Are you speaking of the outside of the bowl? I was trying to visualize the handle down on the Inside? Doesn't seem right.
And, I have not been honing tools. Do you hone the inside of the flute or the same face you grind, or both on a bowl gouge?
It's not just the skew. It works for all tools.
Russ Fairfield
>Sharp tools cut better than dull tools, and the sharper they are the better they cut. It's amazing how that works.
There used to be a rather common belief among woodturners that a bowl gouge can be too sharp and that a gouge straight off the 46 grit grinding wheel cuts better because it has "tooth", and that honing was a total waste of time.
Re: Bill, could you Explain that better?
Bill Neddow
>Thanks, Barry. I do need to clarify. I was talking about the outsider of the bowl. Inside, I use one of Bin Pho's scrapers. It is a tear-shaped cutter mounted on a round bar. Instead of scraping, I turn it on edge so it is almost vertical. That way the edge of the tear-shaped cutter is almost vertical to the wood down near the fat (cutting) end and you can sheer-cut. You do not need the handle down with this tool. Sorby also makes a similar tool with a tear-shaped cutter mounted on the end of is half-round bar, so you can roll it up into the best cutting position. The idea on both the outside and inside of the bowl is that you have your cutting edge slicing across the wood fibers at more than 45 degrees It is like taking a razor blade and slashing a pice of cloth. It really minimizes tear-out.
Do keep the handle down with the bowl gouge. That way you will get the 45 degree or greater slice across the bowl. If you keep the handle horizontal, the cutting edge will be horizontal. That will allow it to dig in rather than slice.
On the bowl gouge, I use the diamond hone on the inside of the flute when I have sharpened it on a blue or white grit grinding wheel. This takes off the very tough burr that forms on the A10 steel. This burr is the reason some people claim you cannot get a really sharp edge with the new steels. Then, when the gouge starts to lose its edge, I keep it sharp by honing the actual bevel.
Just remember, when you sharpen with a 46 grit wheel, you transfer that pattern of scratches to your wood. That means you have to start sanding at 46 grit -- or 80 grit if you have done a really good job. If you sharpen with a 120 grit wheel -- that's the scratches you transfer. So you should be able to start with a 120 grit piece of sandpaper -- or a 180, if you do a really good job. Because the Thompson tools are so good, and the "scary edge" is possible, I sharpen with a 180 grit diamond wheel, then hone with the 600 grit hone. Even on a bad day, you should be able to start sanding at 180 grit. My goal is to do away with sanding entirely as I find it boring and dusty. But, I don't think I will ever achieve it.
Sharpening at 46 grit was a good idea when we were using lesser quality steels like high-carbon. They were less resilient, and the "scary edge" of a fine grit would break off easily, leaving you with a really dull tool very quickly. My theory is that the coarse grit left very sharp teeth on the edge -- and these teeth acted like butresses to a wall. They kept the edge from breaking off completely. You would loose some teeth -- but there would still be some sharp edge in the gaps between the broken teeth.
Now that we have better steel, we can keep the 46 grit wheel for shaping, and sharpen on a finer wheel. But, it take a bit of time for people to adapt and to realize that there is no "law" out there that requires you to use the coarser grits. The commonly accepted practice has to adapt as the tools improve.
Re: Honing
Carole Valentine
>Bill, which grit of Alan's hones do you use? Don't know if I can swing that amount of $$ for a hone, but I do need to get a decent one one of these days.
Re: Honing
Bill Neddow
>Carole, I use the 600 grit, which is the one he recommended for wood turners. He said his finer stone was aimed more at wood carvers, who want to create a "super scary edge".
If you want to sharpen an edge, I find the diamond hone works best. If you want to raise a burr on an edge, I find the ceramic hone John Jordan sells works best.
Re: Honing
Carole Valentine
>Thanks, Bill. 600 was what I was thinking. I have been using a a steel burnishing rod to bring up a fine burr on scrapers - maybe I will try John's.
Re: Honing
Russ Fairfield
>Carole, I have been using one of those little diamond paddles that sells for about $8. Mine is the red one (600-grit I think) and I got it free with a sawblade about 20 years ago. It still works, so don't worry about making the investment. Alan's hone has the advantage of having rounded edges for getting inside the flute. I had to spend $10 for a round diamond stone to do that.
Re: Honing
Jorge Casta�eda
>Carole,
I got Alan Lacer's hone before that gathering at TD's, so it was 4 years ago, at the time I though I was crazy for sinking $75.00 on the hone, but it has 2 2x6" surfaces ans then 2 round edges, one goes very nicely inside the small gouges and the other on the bigger ones, so if you add up the price of 4 separate tools, it comes to more. I have been using it ever since and although you can see some wear here and there, it still works perfectly well after some 500 bowls and platters, so it really pays for itself and will improve the quality of your work.
When we were in the Higher Ground, last fall I did mentioned to Alan that the hone was still in great shape, he told me that cleaning it now and then with soapy water will add to it's life.
Highly reccomended.
Jorge
Standard disclaimer...
Re: Honing
Carole Valentine
>Russ, I have a couple of those little credit card diamond hones and a couple of the paddles, but the coating seems to wear off of them. Of course I have used them a LOT. I guess they made everything better 20 years ago, though! I also have some of those DMT stones with the little holes all over them but I had them for flatwork tools...don't think they would work on turning tools.
Re: Honing
Bill Neddow
>Carole, the steel burnishing rod is the traditional tool, and works very well. I find the diamond hone too effective to make a good burr -- it cuts too much of the metal off too quickly.
Paddle hones
John K Jordan
>I love the paddle diamond hones. I like the control I get by placing my forefinger on the back of the paddle. I can control this hone far better than I can the credit card or other configurations I've tried, al least for turning tools like small gouges and skews. I do use the others for other purposes. I primarily use the very fine (blue) but sometimes the red and occasionally the purple.
I found out the manufacturer would sell them at considerably less than I could find anywhere if I bought a quantity so I now have a lifetime supply, depending on how long my life turns out to be.
JKJ
Thanks, I need a video....
Barry Irby
>I use a Sorby scraper on the inside of the bowls and I use my Ellsworth gouge on the outside and have done the cut you describe with the handle way down.
Part of my problem is that I really don't know what I am looking for. I fumble around with different cuts but lack the know how to recognise what is causing the improvements or NOT.
I think the same thing applies to honing. I'm not sure the improvement is blindingly obvious and I probably need it to be just about blinding to recognise it.
Re: Honing
Barry Irby
>I have two little hones I bought at Walmart that were intended for fishermen. They are a handle about the size of a fat pen with a ferrule you can tighten. the rod retracts into the handle. They have a flat side and a round side with a groove in it for sharpening fish hooks. They were less than ten bucks. I think the last on was about seven bucks. That one is reversible and has a tapered rod on the other end. I have no idea what grit they are, one is marked M, but they are way finer than 46. I will try them on my gouge. I sharpen my kitchen knives with them and carry one in my job site construction tool bucket. Sharpen everything with it, drill bits, chisels, razor knives, on and on. Very good investment.
Re: Paddle hones
John Lucas
>I use the E-Z brand diamond paddles. I use the purple to raise burrs on scrapers, I hone with the extra fine. I use the purple(medium) through extra fine for the skew.
I bought one of the round diamond fish hook sharpeners to do the flutes. I find most of the time all I need is the round fish hook sharpener and I get a much cleaner cut without using the outside flat cards.
I've used both the DMT and E-Z lapp and the both wear out. I like the way the E-Z lap ones cut so keep buying them.
EZE-LAP
John K Jordan
>EZE-LAP was the brand I bought in quantity. Might be worth buying direct if you use them a lot. I think I had to ask for a discount.
I think the EZE-LAP are far better than the Dia-sharp junk from DMT that WoodCraft carried. The steel substrate is thicker and flatter and the abrasive surface lasts longer.
JKJ