Walnut NE
karl jr
>About 10 inches on the major axis 
Another walnut NE, this one about 11 inches or so
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Walnut NE
karl jr
>About 10 inches on the major axis 
Another walnut NE, this one about 11 inches or so
Great shape, Karl. Very nice reverse curve
Brad Vietje
"great shape" took the words right out of my mouth
GaryG in MD
Re: "great shape" took the words right out of my m
karl jr
>Thanks guys.
I think they turned out pretty good. The gallery that has my stuff seems to like NE's a lot. Hopefully these will sell.
Selling Natural Edge Stuff
Brad Vietje
>I have had a few mixed experiences selling natural-edge work, and I've concluded that the need some sort of "owner's manual". There's no problem when another woodturner or a turned wood collector buy them, but the average person looking to buy a finely made gift, or display piece for the mantle needs to be told in clear language just how fragile that bark edge is. I think a little signed note card telling about the piece or where the tree grew helps sales anyway, but be sure to add a caution about the fragile bark edge.
For more enclosed forms that curve inward, or have relatively vertical walls where the bark is attached, the chances of busting off a chunk of bark are lessened, as the bulk of the object tends to protect the fragile bark. When the shape curves outward, and a lot of bark is exposed, especially when it's found at the widest part of the piece, it can be mighty easy to break it.
I think the dangers are:
* Thin bark edges -- that is, bark turned to a thin wall
* Thick bark -- depends on the species. Beech is great, young Red Oak not bad, Walnut or Black Locust = rather thick bark layer.
* Deeply furrowed or scaly bark -- Black Cherry, for example, has all sorts of infoldings and complex shapes that create a very fragile bark "live" edge.
* Bark orientation -- see above. Surfaces perpendicular to bark layer expose less bark than those at oblique angles.
* Bark turned from spring wood (wood cut in spring with a lot of moisture in it)
* Tiny foot or base -- natural edges and tipsy forms are a tough mix
I've had better luck with:
* Thicker live edges
* Thin, smooth bark species
* Bark away from widest part of the piece
* Heavier pieces -- thin and light hollow forms seem to surprise people who pick them up, and the tend to develop "gravity issues"
* Winter cut wood -- bark has less moisture, shrinks kess, and tends to adhere to the sapwood better.
* Slightly larger feet
Since I've gone on so long, I'll throw in a firm rule from the woodturning design section of The World According to Brad
: Bark edges should be all or none. In other words, if some of the bark comes off, and can't be attractively repaired, take it all off, and highlight the natural form of the piece and the sapwood. My view is that patches of bark here and there tell a story of failure, and look so much worse than all on or all off.
There may be other guidelines, but I've had some real nice pieces experience the momentary thrill of gravitational attraction, which means the handler either has to buy a broken piece, or I have to find a way to fix it, or both.
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Great post re NE's
karl jr
>Thanks Brad. THat's a nice bit of expeience wrapped up in a nut shell.