Skew question
Joe in a Cleveland suburb
>Hello.
When I am using my skew doing spindles, should the long end be up or down?
Hope that makes sense, I'm not sure of the correct term(s).
Thanks.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Skew question
Joe in a Cleveland suburb
>Hello.
When I am using my skew doing spindles, should the long end be up or down?
Hope that makes sense, I'm not sure of the correct term(s).
Thanks.
Re: Skew question
john lucas
>You can actually do it either way. Most people do it with the long point upl The important thing is to keep the cut below the center line of the cutting edge. You do this by rotating the tool handle. Start by rubbing the bevel of the tool with the handle down. Lift the handle until it starts to cut. At the same time rotate the handle so the cut is about 1/3 of the way up from the bottom. If you get the cut above the half way point it can pull the tool into the cut and you will get a catch. If you lift the handle too much so it's not rubbing the bevel you will also get a catch.
Re: Skew question
Joe in a Cleveland suburb
>Got it. Thanks John.
Re: Skew question
Bob Macgregor
>There are also a number of YouTube videos demonstrating the use of the skew. I'd suggest focusing on ones that are intended to be demos; too many of the others use dubious technique (like the guy turning the little baseball bat!).
BOB
Re: Skew question
karl jr
>John,
are you aware of any terms for these two excellent methods of producing catches? They are, at least initially, caused by different errors.
Awwsheess and Sonnovva!
A. Kapocius
Re: Skews make good negative rake scrapers!
JamieDonaldson
Re: Skew question
John Lucas
>I may not be correct but I call the catch where you come off the bevel " run back" because that's what it does. It makes a nice screw thread. The other one is more of a catch where it tears the wood out in a big chunk and tries to rip the skew from your hand.
Re: Skew question
Russ Fairfield
>Joe, the most important thing about a skew is that it is sharp, the sharpest tool you own. Everything else is personal preference.
Which end is up depends on what you are doing and your personal preference. I use the skew with the toe down to remove a lot of wood fast as in roughing a piece from square to round. I also make end-trim cuts and pommels with the toe down. I make planing cuts and roll beads and larger spherical shapes with the toe up, but I start the beads by making the V-cuts first with the toe down and then roll the edges with the toe up. I cut long sweeping cove shapes with the toe up, but I switch to a shallow spindle gouge (look for German-style spindle gouge in Packard catalog) for smaller cove shapes because it is safer.
Others may do it in different ways.
I agree with Jamie. The skew makes a better negative rake scraper than anything sold for that use. Just plan on sharpening after every 30-seconds of use.
Re: Skew question
John K Jordan
>Somewhere I read cutting above center referred to as an "unsupported edge". I would add that at least for smaller diameter work I often plane near the tip, especially if the lower part of the edge is getting dull and I'm too lazy to stop and sharpen or hone. Can't remember the last time I had a catch from this.
Funny thing, when I started learning the skew I got catches all the time. Then it got so comfortable that I have to actually work at it if I want to demonstrate a catch. I think it's all in the practice. (I remain quite the expert at getting spectacular spiral catches while cutting large beads with the heel, though!)
My biggest problem when planing with the skew is tearout. Some woods in particular tear out for me with the skew when they will cut cleanly with the gouge, especially turning smaller diameters. Osage orange is one I have had problems with. Turning a pen from olive yesterday I kept tearing out chips until I switched away from the skew. Besides the chips, the rest of the surface cut smooth as glass!
JKJ
Re: Skew question
john lucas
>Russ just described exactly the way I use a skew. Jamie did also. If you really need to nail a shape (like when I do copy work) I will often use the skew on it's side to refine the shape and make it perfect.
Re: Skew question
Russ Fairfield
>John, I respectfully submit that you are doing something wrong if you can get a better cut in any species with a gouge than you can with the skew, and that included Osage Orange.
Hollow ground skew
Doc Green
>I have a theory that a skew with hollow ground bevels will produce a rough cut. So, if you are getting a rough cut with a sharp skew, my theory suggests that maybe it's hollow ground instead of having flat bevels.
A skew straight from the grinder will have hollow ground bevels. What you do, of course, is then flatten the bevels with a diamond hone until you get a D-shaped flat surface that surrounds the hollow ground portion in the middle, etc. etc.
Just a thought . . . ~Doc
Re: Skew question
Dick Hines
>Screw the skew, get a good detail gouge.
Re: Skew question
Keith Tompkins
>I agree John...seems to be woodturning's dirty little secret that the skew isn't the best tool for wild grain. Nobody talks about it, we all assume it's operator error. I have found also that a sharp gouge cuts cleaner than a skew on such grain in test after test after test. I believe, however, that grinding the tool to a much steeper angle, which produces a longer bevel, helps. I see lots of skews with a "blunt' cutting edge, which I feel is about useless.
It's just another Skew!
Jorge Casta�eda
>Wonderful tool that behaves just like a skew, and comes with 200 catches that must be all used before mastering it... 
Jorge
Re: Skew question
Lan Brady
>Dick,
You need to let out your feelings.
Stop sugar coating everyting.
How do you really feel about the Skew?
You will live longer. lol
Lan
Re: Skew question
Russ Fairfield
>Keith, you have hit the key to using the skew chisel, sharp and low angle. It makes a difference. The lower angle is harder to control, but it sure makes a difference in how the tool cuts.
The original posting was toe up of toe down, but John's post got us into a discussion about about tearout in a flat planing cut, and the following adresses that issue.
The 1st rule of using a hand plane also applies to the skew chisel. NEVER CUT UPHILL against the grain. That difference may be subtle in a flat planing cut, but there is still a difference. Sometimes the difference between tearout and smooth is changing the direction of the cut, or the the angle we hold the cutting edge to the wood.
Personally I use 3 different skews - a rather standard 30-degree (??) angle between the toe and heel, a greater angle(look at the Ray Key skew in the Craft Supplies catalog), and one that is square across the end. One of them will allow me to present the cutting edge to any wood grain that I run into without having to use awkward tool angles across the tool rest.
Doc Green was also correct. The shape of the bevel is important for making long planing cuts along the grain of the wood. I prefer flat bevels with no more than 30-degrees between them, and I keep it sharp with a sheet of 600 grit sandpaper on a piece of 3/4" particleboard. In time the bevels will take on a slightly convex shape that only improves its ability to leave a smooth cut on squirrley wood.
As Doc mentioned, the honing of the concave (grinding wheel) bevel is important. Besides making a sharper cutting edge, the honing puts a tiny secondary bevel at the cutting edge. That little bevel is enough to make the difference between tearout and a smooth cut. That tiny bevel is needed to hold the wood down while the edge is cutting through the wood fibers ahead of it. Not having it there is like using a paper cutter with only the blade and no table to support the cut.
Some people, like Alan Lacer, can use any skew with any bevel. The rest of us have to find what works for us, and I have described what works for me and why.
small diameter osage orange
John K Jordan
>I respectfully respect your opinion. I get incredible cuts, smooth as glass, in everything except for little chips in osage orange and occasionally other species. I'll try to pay more attention then next time and if I can narrow down the issues I'll send the piece of wood to you or John Lucas or one of the other skew experts for a try.
The work diameters I'm talking about are close to 1/4". I see no problems when the work is larger, say 3/4" or greater. I don't think work flexing is the problem since the thin shafts are well supported. Perhaps I need to try a different sharpening angle or, as someone mentioned, a non-concave grind.
JKJ
Re: Skew question
Joe in a Cleveland suburb
>Thanks Russ, John, and all who replied to my question regarding toe up or toe down. I guess it doesn't really matter.
As far as the skew being sharp, I (recently) ground the skew so that it is slightly rounded instead of straight across. I'm not sure that is the correct description. Anyway, it looks a little less scarey.
On the grinder I tried to keep the same bevel angle. I guess it is now a hollow grind though. After the grinder, I honed it a bit on some 800 then 1200 paper. I didn't really want to use my water stone(s).
I believe it is pretty sharp. Not as sharp as my chisels or plane irons, but close.
It seems to cut well, and without too much effort, but I have noticed the bevel of the skew actually gets pretty warm. Is this normal?
Thanks again.
Joe
Re: small diameter osage orange
Russ Fairfield
>Aha, the rest of the story. You just added something to the discussion that wasn't evident in your earlier message - the diameter. Tearout from vibration is likely whenever the diameter is small relative to the length, and 1/4" is small.
Try less force on the tailstock - a good reason for using a chuck to hold the wood in the lathe.
It's possible that your skew is too large for the size of the work. One of those 1/4" round skews would be recommended for something that small.
Are you using your finger under the spinning wood to give it support. If you aren't, you should. I'm sure the dafety police will arrest me for this photo.
