Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Drying Wood

Posts

Drying Wood

#1

Drying Wood

David Fen

>Years ago, a woodturner shared a green wood technique w/ me and I wanted to confirm it w/ anyone else w/ experience. The technique had to do w/ turning a rough shape wet, placing it in a garbage bag for 30 days , turning the bag inside out daily allowing the accumulated moisture to evaporate from the outside of the bag, repeating the process daily, and at the end of 30 days the bowl has (supposedly) given up the moisture that causes endchecking.

I am being offered some wet wood in desirable thicknesses (4")for bowl turning. If they ship it to me w/ the ends waxed/ sealed in a garbage bag, will that minimize end and face checking during transit(4 days)? Once I receive blanks, my intention is to start the my drying process . I realize that this may hinge on current moisture content+/- 30%. They sent a batch to me that was raw, ends untreated and the results were a disaster!

Thanks for your help,

David Fen

Re: Drying Wood

#2

Re: Drying Wood

John Lucas

>I've used the plastic bag trick on a smaller scale with some cut offs of limbs that had the heart in it. It did work however you will get some mold. In my case it was spalted wood so the color the mold added was a good thing.

What I do on bowls is rough them out and then coat all of the endgrain areas and the foot with Anchorseal. If I'm nervous about that piece or feel it's particularly special I put a paper sack over it. Then I store them on the floor of my shop. I've lost some by putting them up on shelves. Apparently my shop is quite a bit warmer up high and speeds the drying which in the early stages is not a good thing. after about 30 days I move them from the floor to the shelves. I used to weight them and when they quit losing weight they were ready. In Tennessee it takes about 3 to 6 months depending on the size of the bowl. Now I have a backlog so I just put them on the shelf with the newest to the right and pull them off the left to turn and don't worry about the time.

Re: Drying Wood

#3

Re: Drying Wood

John K Jordan

>I do basically what Sir Lucas does, coat with anchorseal. If I'm not going to turn right away (usually), I paint the ends with a double coat of anchor seal. If I have time, I cut bowl blanks round and coat the sides all the way around. Since I love spindle and box turning I cut much into turning squares and coat the ends.

When I turn wet, I usually coat the rough turning inside and out with anchorseal. This slows the drying enough to keep most from checking.

Any time I put things in a plastic bag for too long I got mold, especially in the summer. I like to store blanks in plastic tubs with the lids off. This seems to let the air circulate but not dry too quickly. Nice for organizing by species.

JKJ

Re: Drying Wood

#4

Brad Vietje

Re: Drying Wood

Brad Vietje

>Hey David,

There are two basic philosophies to drying green wood: slow methods and faster methods. I occasionally push the drying cycle with microwaves and such when I'm in a hurry, but generally, I subscribe to the slow and steady school of thought. If you try to dry wood too fast, you invite problems of many sorts, and the usual outcome is checking (cracking) of the wood.

The alternative is to rough out many pieces and have them air-drying so you will always have dry stock whenever you need to produce a piece in a hurry. It takes a few months to get ahead of the curve, but a few months of turning down opportunities to have a piece ready for tomorrow night's B-day party, and you'll be there. I must have a few hundred air-dried pieces hanging around, so if I need something rather sudden, I'm all set -- all I need is an outside temp warm enough for me to turn something in an un-heated "shop" -- see Jorge's photos of snow and turning in the cold, and you'll get the idea... I'm just as far North, but it's generally colder inland, where I am, away from the ocean.

I also advise NEVER turning half-dry wood if you can avoid it. In other words, if you are going to make 12" x 4" bowls, I'd say wack 'em out green as grass, and dry them as roughed-out bowls, and not as a solid chunk of wood. I would never air-dry a bowl blank before turning it -- there is simply no good reason to do this, and the results are often compromised. Green wood turns great, and once its air-dried, you can finish turn it with great success, but half-dry wood is a genuine PITA to turn, with the advantages of neither, and the disadvantages of both.

I've used the plastic bag method, but only on rough-turned items. After 30 days a 4" thick blank will still have a lot of moisture in it, and will need other attention to avoid checking. Again, I would not advise drying it at all before rough turning it.

To avoid discoloration, you are best to rough turn the piece when wet, and then bag it. Don't skip a day inverting the plastic bag, and do this where its relatively cool, or you will get spalting or mold, as John reports. After 30 days, you might place the item in a paper shopping bag, which helps slow down the dying a lot like Anchorseal.

I use Anchorseal for rare or high-value wood, or all cut ends when processing fresh wood in log form to buy a little time. It will only delay -- and not stop -- the inevitable degradation of the wood if a solid block.

Cardboard Box Method: Another method I use for processing larger numbers of bowls or box blanks in batches, is to toss them into a cardboard box, probably 6 - 8 small bowls or 10 - 12 box rough-outs (depending on sizes), and then close up the box, and place in a cool spot like the garage floor. I check on them every few weeks and move 'em around, which allows air in there, so you don't get a big ball of green furry stuff. After about 2 months they just sit on a shelf in my barn waiting for their big day on the lathe for finish turning. Many have been waiting 5 years or more. I never tape the box closed, just fold in the flaps, and that has worked real well for me. I have gotten a little fungal growth on some Elm bowls, and occasionally a little mold on fresh, wet Maple rough-outs, but I can't recall ever getting excessive checking that ruins the piece.

For high-value wood like a nice burl or highly-figured piece, I smear the outside with Butcher's Paste Wax, melting it on while the work spins on the lathe, a la Wally -- if it works in Arizona, it will work about anywhere!

These methods work well in my climate (Northeastern Vermont) where its warm and muggy in summer, and often downright frigid and dry in winter. My barn has a dirt floor and is unheated (or cooled), with poured concrete only in one horse stall (that's the "shop"), so there's always some moisture in the air down low -- in the summer it can get real hot up higher in the building. Be really careful to dry wood away from heat registers, drafts, or direct sunlight, and generally, forced hot air heat will cause a lot more checks than just about anything.

If you work in a heated space, consider drying your rough-turned pieces in an unheated space, like a garage or car-port, or a minimally-heated space, like an entryway, breezeway, or 3-season porch.

I also recommend Turning Green Wood, by Michael O'Donnell highly.

Good luck, and show us what you create!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Drying Wood

#5

Re: Check the Benefit Auction Board for the book

Stuart Johnson

Re: Drying Wood

#6

Re: Drying Wood

Dave Moore

>As for the question of whether wax and bagging will protect the blanks while in transit, I would think yes, it should be fine. I've transported wet wood log sections in bags whenever I luck into them when on a trip or vacation and they've held like that for a couple of weeks .

Once you get them home though it's time to rough turn them ASAP; I would not try to dry a solid block, there's nothing to gain even if it worked, which it mostly doesn't.

Here in the mountains it's dry as all get out most of the time, so I usually hustle to get things roughed out. It's so dry here that I'll bag a piece in progress on the lathe if I get interrupted for more that a minute or so.

After that it depends on the species what happens next.

Some woods dry without a fight with the rough bowl just set off to one side without any treatment. Some others dry OK but need a little help with anchorseal or starting them out in a paper grocery bag for a month or so. Others, like apple for example, are just real difficult to manage no matter what, and they go in the cool and humid crawl space next to the water cistern, with anchorseal and in a bag sometimes. Even then it's uncertain, and there are some that will crack come hell or high water.

Slow the process down whenever in any doubt, and be real sure that the thickness of any rough turned stuff is as uniform as you can get it, whatever the thickness may be. Even friendly wood will crack if there's much variation.

Re: Drying Wood

#7

Re: Drying Wood *LINK*

Fred Holder

>I believe that I've used about every method of drying wood that has been invented. Some methods result in nice dry wood without cracks. However, if you leave the wood as a turning blank, you must seal the ends with Anchor Seal and hope that it doesn't crack. If you rought turn the blank to 10 percent of diameter for the wall thickness and use one of the many methods, you are likely to get a useable dry bowl blank withing 6 to 12 months. Some of the methods for doing this are:

1. The plastic bag process that you describe. Actually, it will seldom be dry at the end of 30 days, but it will be ready to place on the shelf to finish drying. Weigh it often and when it stops losing weight it is ready to final turn.

2. The paper bag with shavings method. This works pretty good, but may spalt or mold your wood.

3. Soaking in Turner's Choice works pretty well if there is no pith in the piece. One thing that it does is make the wood turn better when final turning. I choose this process to treat all of the ball blanks I use to make the Chinese Balls.

4. There is also the alcohol drying process that Dave Smith came up with a few years ago. I found that this works pretty well.

5. Some people have good luck using the microwave oven to dry their rough turned bowls. I've never had very much luck with this process.

I hope this helps a little bit.


More Woodturning magazine

Re: Drying Wood

#8

Re: Drying Wood

Bill Neddow

>I would both wax and garbage bag the pieces for transit. Then, I would follow the advice you have received here to rough turn the pieces as soon as possible.

I turn a lot of bowls and have an inventory of well over 3,000 rough turned ones. Simply air drying the bowls will result in losing about 25 per cent of them to cracking. Drying them in plastic bags works, but invites lots of mould and spalting. I use this technique to deliberately spalt wood. If you are dealing with only a few, Anchorseal the ends of the rough turned bowls and put them in brown paper bags to dry. If you want to speed up the drying, try boiling them. There is a protocol for this. You can find it at

http://www.woodturningvideosplus.com/boiling-green-wood.html

It works for all sizes of bowls. I have tried using the alcohol soak method and and found, to my dismay, that it only works reliably on smaller bowls (under 12 inches).

I have made one change in Steve's protocol for boiling. He stores the boiled bowls in brown paper bags. But, with the size of my inventory, this is not practical. I have to be able to see the shape of different bowls to find what I want. Also, the fire marshall would probablly close me down if he found so many paper bags stored somewhere. I simply was the pieces all over, inside and out, with Anchorseal. I throw them onto shelves in the garage and forget them. They are ready to turn (moisture content under 12 per cent) in 3 to 6 months for the smaller ones (under a foot) and in a year for the larger ones (about 18 to 24 inches). Failure rate: 1/2 of 1 per cent.

I live in Ottawa Canada. the summer are very hot and muggy. The garage gets stinking hot. Winters are now variable but usually we get a couple of weeks of minus 40 weather -- and lots of other cold, dry days.

Re: Drying Wood

#9

Re: Drying Wood

John K Jordan

>>but usually we get a couple of weeks of minus 40 weather

Yikes, where do you live? It must be in the land of engine block heaters.

JKJ

Re: Drying Wood

#10

Re: Drying Wood

David Fen

>Thanks to all for your input. I have lots of good info to work with here and my sense is that I'll be gleaning value from your sharing for years. Please know that your advice gets one of my vendors off the hook. He sent me a bad batch of Alaskan Yellow Cedar. and with int'l postage so high- this seemed like a tough place for him. I wanted the wood more than I wanted my money back- and now I can make some suggestions to him that will get me new wood that I can dry myself.

Thanks to all,

David

Re: Drying Wood

#11

Re: Drying Wood

fgvanatta

>About the only drying method Fred didn't mention is pressure cooking. I have used this method a lot and have been quite satisfied with the results. The only drawbacks are that it darkens the wood slightly and seems to make it harder (to turn, at least).