Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Woods not to use for demonstrations

Posts

Woods not to use for demonstrations

#1

Woods not to use for demonstrations

HeatherAinAK

>Hello, I am doing a demonstration in a couple of weeks and wanted to know if it would be OK to use morado (bolivian rosewood). I know that many people are allergic to cocobolo and our club advised us to not use it, but I did not know about morado. Any other woods to specifically avoid?

Thanks,

Heather

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

#2

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

Don Orr

>Personally I would avoid ANY kind of Rosewood and most other "exotics" in a demo where you cannot predict peoples reactions. Allergic reactions can be sudden and progress rapidly. I woud also avoid Walnut and any of the various "Cedars" around. Stick with known domestic woods like Maple, Birch, Cherry, Sycamore, Beech, Ash which are all pretty innocuous. And go easy on the sanding or use wax to sand.

Good luck with the demo and have fun !

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

#3

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

Dick Coers

>I agree with Don. You don't want to start a sneeze fest, or have someone develope a rash at the demo. They will understand, but you can have some of your exotic wood in the gallery pieces you take to talk about.

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

#4

Concur

Jorge Casta�eda

>Heather,

All the rosewoods cause allergies as well. Maple is a nice turning wood, so is cherry, those would be my first choice.

Have fun!

Jorge

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

#5

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

john lucas

>Heather I agree with the others. I try to turn woods that turn easily, leave clean cuts and throw off curls. The easy to turn woods make the demo move along faster because you don't have to take little tiny cuts over and over to get through the hard stuff. The curls show the newbie's ( and some older turners) what the difference is between cutting and scraping.

I did a demo a few years ago at our local club where I started with a dull tool. I was making cuts and everything was going well. They thought nothing was wrong. Then I showed them how a dull tool slips out of the cut and stopped to sharpen. Then I was able to show them the difference in the shavings and how I was able to remove just a wisper of wood with a sharp tool. Unfortunately they can't feel the difference a sharp tool makes.

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

#6

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Heather, just to add one more voice to the pile, stick with something relatively innocuous. The only reason you would have for using a rosewood would be if you were known for making something out of that type of wood and were demonstrating that thing. My own preference is for wet red maple. When people ask why, my response is, "It makes me look good". But beyond that, there is the allergy potential that some woods pose. If you stick with wood that cuts easily, there is lots less potential for embarrassing moments - not that that every happens, but you never know. ;-)

As John mentioned, you want to keep the demo moving along. The people for whom you are demonstrating should already know you know how to do what it is you are doing, which is why they have you demonstrating. The demo is more about process than it is about how well a person can make something. You may already know this, but it is one of my peeves, sitting in a demo where a person starts fussing over a chunk of wood because it is not gallery quality.

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

#7

Dick Hines

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

Dick Hines

>I agree with you Bill. Something like wet maple or Bradford pear works great in a demo. But wet maple making you "look good" is going to far. :D

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

#8

Steven Antonucci

Yet another vote for wet local hardwood

Steven Antonucci

>As others have mentioned, allergies and ease of use are paramount. Whatever wood you use, make sure it is free of obvious defects to avoid potential spontaneous disintegration. No checks or knots, maybe run it through a metal detector just in case...

Not sure what you are demonstrating, but I would also make my "first demo" something smaller, since my experience is that something I think will take an hour, takes two hours if I have to explain it. By scaling back the size, you can fit your timeslot.

Good luck

steve

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

#9

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

Don at Central Illinois

>Like Bill says, not gallery quality. I was looking at a youtube video (is that redundant?) on a guitar lick. He stated at the outset, this is a teaching video, not my best performance. As with most all demo's, this is a teaching demo, not my best or normal work.

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

#10

Mike Stafford

Makes you look good?

Mike Stafford

>I can think of two ways that a piece of wood can make me look good.

First if during the demonstration I throw enough curls to hide my face....

Or I am able to hide behind the piece of wood.

I have to use dry wood for box making demos. Although a green wood can be used it can dry and distort so rapidly that it affects the completion of the project. I try to use the most innocuous, odorless (or at least free of strong odors) wood I can that is dry but is not too brittle. Sometimes dry cherry can be very brittle and has shattered for me when I dropped a thin lid on the floor.

Not only should you consider the potential allergenic effects of woods you use during demos; they should also be considered when teaching multiple students. You just never know who has been exposed to what and what effect it might have on them.

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

#11

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

JKJ in East TN

>I agree - I think a demo should not be to make a beautiful finished item or it makes for a long and boring demo. Why waste quality wood, then?

It should probably be something that doesn't tear out easily or require special techniques, unless, of course, the object of the demo is how teach to handle tearout or do special techniques!

JKJ

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

#12

NO Rosewoods (Dalbergia...)

Craig Daymon

>My turning group back east insisted that demo turners never use ANY rosewood when demonstrating. Some in the group were allergic enough to possibly need a very quick injection if exposed to the dust. (Remember the scene in "Pulp Fiction" when Uma Thurman gets the injection in her chest?) Completed pieces were fine to show, as I remember. Better to play it safe.

It's never good for a demo when you have to stop to rush one of your audience to the hospital.

Also, I think one of the lacewoods is from the poison ivy family, but I don't know the botanical name.

-Craig

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

#13

Ken Vaughan

Local woods to use for demonstrations

Ken Vaughan

>Heather - I presume you are in the rail belt of Alaska - As a Juneau Turner, I would love to have some of the birch and aspens that are available to you.

The wood will depend on what you are trying to show and what the learning objectives of the demo is focused on (If you have not yet grabbed ahold of the trick of learning objectives - give it a try -- it adds focus to your demo).

Local woods have value in several directions -- local is the big one, and that means available and commonly low cost or easy access which helps those learning.

I too suggest you stay away from the exotics -- and add that a little color can go a long way to add emphasis to your effort and pop out some drama.

Best wishes and wish I could be there to see it

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

#14

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

HeatherAinAK

>Thanks for all the responses. I am making a hand mirror and the last one I made for practice was of the morado and it turned so easily AND looked so nice that I thought it would be nice for the demo. I will go with the cherry or maple. I have some beautiful spalted birch burl but it tears out badly and I don't want to have to deal with that!

I am really nervous about this demo. The other turners in our symposium are Stewart Batty and Mike Mahoney and another very experienced turner from AK. No pressure! Plus the attendees put their names in a had and we draw names and the winners get to take home any finished demo pieces.

Thanks for all the advice! You are all very encouraging. Plus all our club members are very kind and supportive, I guess most of the pressure is self imposed.

Heather

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

#15

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

charlie belden

>Remember

Home Field Advantage. They've probably been On The Road for a while. YOu probably get to sleep in your own bed. They've been eating in airports an maybe fast food places. You probably will have had Home Cooked. They may know a few of the attendees. You probably know most if not all of your audience. Their audience has high expectations based on the Well Known Turners' reputation. You have the advantage of Shock and Awe - and folks rooting for you.

You'll go fine, so relax and enjoy. The time will go much faster than you think and try not to blush too much when the applause comes.

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

#16

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Heather, in keeping with your OP, forget spalted wood too. It is fairly stuffed with mold spores that are hazardous to everyone's lungs!

But I wanted to make another point too. Don't worry about who else is there or how big their name is. You are there to show what you know, and above all, have fun doing it. That is how I have approached all my demos. I am there to play on the lathe, and everyone else is there to watch me have fun playing on the lathe.

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Dick, Even more fun, grab a piece with the pith in the center...when you turn it, long, continuous ribbons will form, especially if you hold your tool in one spot and just raise the handle...

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

#18

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

Katherine Kowalski

>Hi Heather!

I'll agree with everyone else -- stay away from exotics! Use "easy" wood.

Another consideration is color -- (especially with small stuff like fine spindlework), use a light colored wood, (maple or cherry) if you are wearing dark-colored clothing, and walnut, etc. for a light-colored smock.

I know both Mike and Stuart, and they are the friendliest turners you'd ever want to meet! At symposia, we are all there to learn and share information with each other. Just relax and enjoy everyone's expertise -- you'll do great!

Katherine

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

#19

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

HeatherAinAK

>Thanks Charlie, I just hope the shock and awe is not caused by me launching something and taking out someone on the first row!

Heather

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

#20

Re: Woods not to use for demonstrations

HeatherAinAK

>Thanks Bill, I have already learned a lot just preparing. Your post reminded me of something my husband occasionally says. He fills in preaching occasionally and if I wasn't there and ask him how it went he always says " well, I enjoyed myself".

Heather