Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Electricity, Arthritis, and Gout (agreed-long)

Posts

Electricity, Arthritis, and Gout (agreed-long)

#1

Electricity, Arthritis, and Gout (agreed-long)

Jim Rutten

>You know, this is an interesting forum. You exchange information about woodturning, but something else happens. In sharing the joy and mishaps about woodturning you come to think of the people on this site as part of your family. I never had that close of a family growing up for various reasons, never cried at my father's funeral, but have sat here weeping while reading about someones mother passing away from cancer or someone's dog passing on. So, I guess, a lot of the inhibitions in talking to strangers have also been removed. Like I said, I think of a lot of people on this forum more as family.

So, onto my note. I am not a doctor and I made the mistake of not saying that up front. I have had a lot of experience with doctors, though, having been through three brain tumor operations, the last a full craniotomy, that have left me partially blinded and taking a cacaphony of medicine. My first brain tumor operation was when I was 29 and I am now 50. I will "get" to take these drugs for the rest of my life. I don't say this for pity because I think of my life as a very good one, but more to explain why I look for alternatives rather than having a doctor say take this pill for the rest of your life to combat gout.

My goal in leaving that message was merely to share something that had worked for me, not to have someone forego going to the doctor in lieu of taking parsley or anything else. I totally agree with Mr. Manley that any sort of dispensing of medical advise like what drug to take for this or that malady should be left to those who have a medical license!

So what can be done about this. Well, Mr. Manley's suggestion was, if I had been talking about cancer alternatives, that we ban all "medical topics". This is just my opinion, but I think this kind of censorship is a slippery slope and who is to say what topics are taboo and what are OK. But since I was the person who made this error I feel responsible for the solution. My proposed solution is to implement a self-imposed moritorium on my message-writing in this forum until a time when I feel I can contribute without endangering the life's, or in this case, the pain management of others. So, congratulations Mr. Manley, you have achieved in one message what my wife has not in 25 years of marriage. Getting me to shut up.

Re: Electricity, Arthritis, and Gout (agreed-long)

#2

Whoa! We need controversy. Keep posting.

adrien

>

Re: Electricity, Arthritis, and Gout (agreed-long)

#3

I've always enjoyed your posts, don't stop now :)

John Lucas

>

Re: Electricity, Arthritis, and Gout (agreed-long)

#4

Hey Jim...

Don Orr

>You don't need to stop posting until we tell you to ;-))

You did nothing wrong by trying to provide information about something that helped you. We're all grown-ups here (I think) and can figure out for ourselves what to do with things like you posted. I found it interesting myself. I'm not a doctor either but I do work in health care and hear all kinds of interesting stories from patients.

Re: Electricity, Arthritis, and Gout (agreed-long)

#5

Re: Electricity, Arthritis, and Gout (agreed-long)

Carol Reed - Strawberry, AZ

>Your self-imposition does not serve you or us very well. I too, spent some time researching the information you offered. And I learned some things. Had you not offered it, I would not have learned anything.

You are right about friends and 'family'. Here is a family we can choose to be a part of, as opposed to the one into which we were born. Good family members care about one another. Your information was offered with good intentions, and was taken as such by at least this family member. Proud to know ya, Jim. Don't run off. Wives aren't always right!

Likely on the very top of my list of personal peeves are the rantings of one who advocates that I do not know what is best for me and I don't have the right to make those decisions, therefore I am to capitulate mindlessly to someone who presumably knows better that I. No one knows better than I until I have discovered they do!

Whew! I feel better now!

Re: Electricity, Arthritis, and Gout (agreed-long)

#6

Brad Vietje

Hope you stay around, Jim!

Brad Vietje

>Hey Jim,

Please don't take offense at these posts. First, e-mail is easy to miss-interpret, since the tone of voice and body language are not sent with the message. It's hard to send a message that will be interpreted just the way you meant it, and vice-versa.

Second, Some people get all worked up, and really -- we ought to be careful about non-professional advice we read on-line, and take responsibility for double-checking anything questionable.

Third, I appreciate learning about alternative therapies, and want to at least hear about them. I have a sister with a very rare auto-immune disorder who might well be dead now if she blindly followed what every doctor told her to do. Fortunately, she had learned so much about her rare medical condition over the years that she knew enough to doubt one piece of advice from one doctor, and call her regular doctor who was on vacation. Her doctor called her right back from another country, and confirmed that she was right -- and probably saved her life.

Since I didn't see your post about an alternative therapy, I'll go back and look for it now -- I want to read more about it.

Thanks for participating, Jim -- I hope you'll continue.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Electricity, Arthritis, and Gout (agreed-long)

#7

Brad Vietje

And Then There's The Darwin Awards...

Brad Vietje

>Look kids,

Grow up. Electricity is dangerous -- it can even kill you. Don't blindly follow what someone spouts on-line without checking with a professional (very good advice, Bill T !). If you take chances with something potentially deadly, and you don't know enough to check with a knowing professional (or don't know when you are out of your depth), you could get killed by being stupid.

Here's an example: say I tell you that the best way to check for gas leaks is with a candle or a match. If you get killed in the explosion, there really wasn't much we could do to save you from yourself, now was there? Wait till I tell you about peeing on electrical fires to put them out... Don't you think you'd have bought the farm sooner or later anyway? Given that the risk of danger is so high (death, e.g.), if you failed to check to see if my candle advice was any good, maybe you were just too stupid for this planet, anyway!

Now, if you tried something innocuous, like using cotton candy as a furniture polish, and it works about as well as I expect it will, then no real harm done -- just a sticky mess to clean up. But when your safety and possibly your very life is at stake, I have to believe you are human enough to at least try to protect yourself by checking with someone who knows more than you or I do.

Otherwise, they have awards for that sorta thing ;-))

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Electricity, Arthritis, and Gout (agreed-long)

#8

Re: Electricity, Arthritis, and Gout (agreed-long)

Cyril Griesbach

>Stay with us, Jim, your contributions have always been welcome.

Re: Electricity, Arthritis, and Gout (agreed-long)

#9

If it makes you feel better, Jim.

Gary Evans--Tallassee TN

>Hey Jim,

I have been married to a nurse for more than 30 years, so I have met a lot of doctors. I only know one or two whose advice I would take regarding my own health.

Right after I read your post I ran across a line in a novel that I'm reading which pretty much sums up my opinion about the medical profession. Supposedly it is an old Yiddish saying. The English translation is: "If it's not your time, even a doctor can't kill you."

Gary

Re: Electricity, Arthritis, and Gout (agreed-long)

#10

Love it, Gary!

Carol Reed - Strawberry, AZ

>