>Earlier, I brought up coming technologies and guessed at some of the possibilities they will present to turners, carvers/sculptors and other folks with ideas that can't currently be done - or would be very difficult to do. Virtual pieces are already here - but still somewhat basic - simple.
What I thought was lacking, software that'd let you sculpt, turns out to already be here - only an Alpha version - but holds out the promise of some interesting virtual tools for 3D sculpting.
Check out this video to get an idea of what's here - and what's coming.
>Charlie, that's interesting, but in case you are not aware of it this type of software has been available for a long time. In professional circles we had interactive "organic" modeling software with basic function over 15 years ago with similar (but more limited) ability to pick tools and push, pull, smooth, cut, assemble, etc. The speed and fluidity of the interaction were very much limited by the processor speed - today's computers are amazingly more powerful by orders of magnitude. Each year the SIGGRAPH conference on computer graphics (I attended every conference for over 10 years) highlighted new developments in modeling, 3d "printing" and "carving" (machining), and very important - texturing and painting. (Texturing is so important for realism in 3D renderings.)
Many of the character models used in movies, games, and elsewhere were built or refined using this technology. In addition to commercially available technology, individual and panels of researchers from industry and academia gave seminars and demonstrated work in progress. Artists were VERY quick to experiment with and adopt these things and every year displayed real and virtual sculptures.
At SIGGRAPH we saw a variety of input methods - one of the most difficult things to do well for this type of application. Some used position sensing hardware to position a tool in 3D space and some even used "haptic" feedback where the user could feel pressure or texture from the tool or glove. Note that positioning and moving the tool intuitively relative (all the while manipulating lights and viewpoint to monitor the true shape of the model) is a very difficult thing to do with standard computer input such as a mouse, keyboard, or tablet - developers have invented and refined many schemes but none of them are perfect or anything like having a real piece of wood or clay in your hands. Remember you not only have to position the tool in XY&Z, you have to point it in the right direction and be able to push, pull, rotate, twist, etc.
The best I had personally in my studio used a FARO 3D digitizer (www.faro.com if interested) - this tool was intended for manually digitizing a real object but adapting it for interactive modeling was a matter of software. What I had let me control a tool that could be moved through the air to push, pull, and sculpt on a virtual model displayed on the screen. These digitizers looked like a multi-jointed robot arm and had all six degrees of positioning freedom which included rotation and twisting - good clean fun! One small problem with this technology besides the computer speed problem - it cost me over $4000 for the hardware alone (and this was their smallest unit) which didn't include specialized software to interface with my primary modeling package.
What improves every year in both organic and "solid" modeling, e.g. Sketchup, etc, is the user interface (in both workflow and tool positioning relative to the model), a refinement in the type and action of the tools (some of those in the video you provided look great), and the drastic reduction in cost which may finally give the guy on the street access to this type of fun!
JKJ
Re: Looks Like Virtual Sculpting Is Here Now *LINK*
>I looked back through my photos and couldn't find a good example of organic virtual sculpting but the photo below (from 1998) is a 3D "print" of a virtual model, if I remember correctly, that was done by partially by algorithm and guided and edited with a digitizer.
Re: Looks Like Virtual Sculpting Is Here Now *LINK*
>Ah, SIGGRAPH (Special Interest Group: GRAPHics), a stroll down memory lane. My former employer, the City of San Jose, "Heart of Silicon Valley", was an early, non Defense Department adopter of computer graphics - specifically GIS (Graphical Information System). The emphasis was on tying data in various data bases to "flat" maps rather than 3D maps - and being able to either aggregate information by areas or bore down to data for a specific element within the whole.
We're going back to the mid to late '70s - and phosphor refresh displays that required darkened work spaces in order to be able to see the displayed lines. This was InterGraph hardware and software - all proprietary stuff - and VERY expensive. Very powerful stuff - at the time - and prohibitively expensive for a private citizen.
But shortly thereafter, primitive versions of some of the expensive stuff came along with the relatively new, and much more affordable, Personal Computers. ATARI had the ATARI 800 which would run some of the early 3D software, albeit slowly, very slowly. It was used for some of the early computer graphics in films like TRON and the first Alien movie - lo those many years ago.
What's happening is that the creation and manipulation of virtual 3D objects is just now getting in the hands of the average person - with interfaces that are more intuitive, though still with a learning curve to climb. But when I think back to InterGraphs Graphic Stations, with 3'x 4' digitizing tables, with function menus containing icons for hundreds of functions, today's software learning curves look relatively flat - thankfully.
Initially, the user interface has been Analogous - analogous to ways of doing things with early technology. And that's a necessary approach during a transition from an older technology to a new one. But at some point, the new technology will allow for things to be done that couldn't be done with the older technology. These will require new ways of thinking and new interfaces to go with the new Mental Model being used.
Think of a Nittman (sp?) piece - where only a quadrant or perhaps a 30 degree slice of the pie needs detailing - then clone the remaining parts. Think of a Drozda piece - taken to even more delicate extremes - things that couldn't hold up in the "real world". Think of what Greame Priddle, or Terry Scott or Alby Hall could do with their creative - and sometimes Wild Hare - ideas.
At some point tactility will come to virtual pieces - and then things will get REALLY interesting.
We live in interesting times. What's out there now we aren't yet aware of is mind boggling. But what's coming . . .