Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Punky section in bowl blank - strategy?

Posts

Punky section in bowl blank - strategy?

#1

Punky section in bowl blank - strategy?

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

>Short version: What strategies do you use to turn pieces that have punky/soft wood section? Is this junk wood not worth turning?

Longer version: A friend provided the lowest section of a maple trunk from his yard tree. This is turning fodder for me to turn larger pieces. I am relatively new to turning (max diameter of 6-7" so far) and several of these blanks are 11-14" in diameter.

The first piece I tried to rough out has nice color variation in it, with some mild spalting. There is also a soft/punky section that is 3-4" wide at the rim that continues to the center of the piece. This portion does not cut well with either a bowl gouge or scraper. Sanding this area does nothing at all (as I would guess most of you know)

Can this soft wood be stabilized with CA glue or something like MinWax wood stabilizer? Is this junk wood not worth turning? What strategies do you use?

Thanks

Henry

Re: Punky section in bowl blank - strategy?

#2

Re: Punky section in bowl blank - strategy?

GaryG in MD

>Henry, There a number of commercial wood hardeners on the market that will work just fine. For myself, I would just soak it with thinned shellac and replenish when/if your cut gets deeper than the soak. Any finish will work over shellac. ...Gary

Re: Punky section in bowl blank - strategy?

#3

Brad Vietje

Heave-Ho!

Brad Vietje

>Henry,

I'd heave it, or cut away the rotten parts and make what you can from what's left. Punky stuff is only rarely worth the effort, and even if hardened, it will not take finish the same, and will look a lot worse to you a year from now than it might today.

I'm tempted to suggest using the wood as practice, but then again, punky wood can also come flying apart, so build your skills and confidence with sound wood. You can practice on all sorts of wood, some of which won't make the most stunning bowls, but at least they are not likely to come apart on the lathe.

Most beginners are tempted to turn whatever wood they can find (I did), and many wonder where they can get wood without spending a lot of money, (as I did). If you work on sources of green turning wood, and politely ask about, you will soon have more than you can keep up with (as I do).

Sourcing a variety of better-quality bowl turning blanks can depend on where you live, but there are usually a number of sources. I live in a very rural area, where wood is all over the place. Many people near me burn wood to heat their homes, so there are dozens of people in the fire wood business, as well as loggers, foresters, etc... all can be good sources of cheap -- or free -- wood.

Also, I can't speak highly enough of the benefits to finding and joining a local wood turning club. "Local" may mean within a 2-hour drive, but there are many benefits, including a bunch of turners who have more wood than they can keep up with (like me).

Best of luck, and don't forget to show us what you make from time to time.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Punky section in bowl blank - strategy?

#4

Lots of options

David Walser

>Henry,

Welcome to the wonderful world of turning.

There are lots of options that will allow you to turn punky wood. The two you mentioned will work. CA glue is a little expensive, but it works well if the area is small enough. The problem is CA may "stain" the wood. MinWax Wood Hardener works well, too. If you coat the entire piece, the punky area and the solid wood should accept finish in the same manner.

Another approach is to soak the wood with thinned wood glue (such as Titebond Original). I use a 50/50 mix of glue and water. Soak the blank in the glue and let it dry completely before turning. A combo of glue, water, and shavings can make a mess of your face shield! This glue/water mixture will affect how your bowl will accept stain.

One more approach is to use a thinned mixture of your final finish (such as lacquer or shellac).

None of this is to suggest stabilizing the punky wood is worthwhile. It's just to say there are options.

Good luck!

Re: Punky section in bowl blank - strategy?

#5

Re: Punky section in bowl blank - strategy?

Doc Green

>Henry, I've worked a lot of punky wood and IMO, the best technique is to use lacquer sanding sealer as a stabilizer. You can thin it 50/50 with lacquer thinner for better penetration.

Two points: (1) The sealer will only penetrate about 1/8" max per application, and maybe even less. (2) You must give it "a few hours" to dry after you put it on. It will dry on the surface just a few minutes, but it needs to dry to its depth of penetration for best results.

Yes, this procedure will span a considerable period of time. If you rush it, you are likely to cut deeper than what has been stabilized, and a rough surface will reappear.

I don't like CA because of its obnoxious effects and only use it for small areas, perhaps the size of a quarter or smaller.

After the turning is done, be careful with the sanding. The punky part will sand away much faster then the other wood, and you can get an uneven surface if you aren't careful.

Good Luck, ~Doc

Re: Punky section in bowl blank - strategy?

#6

Re: Thanks all

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

>Thanks for your ideas.

I may just completely turn this piece into shavings - as practice and then move onto the solid pieces I harvested.

Henry