Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

ATTENTION: Ellis, electrical posts?

Posts

ATTENTION: Ellis, electrical posts?

#1

ATTENTION: Ellis, electrical posts?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>With all the recent electrical posts that have contained very erroneous and DANGEROUS information, I wonder if electrical posts should be banned. Many of these have been posted by caring, but ill-informed people. I would like to know your and others' feelings on this. It is a struggle to provide the info and weed out the mis-info before members have made a potentilly fatal error.

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Retired,w/ 42 years of industrial, commercial, & institutional maintenance experience

Re: ATTENTION: Ellis, electrical posts?

#2

Re: ATTENTION: Ellis, electrical posts?

Marc Phillips

>It is always understood that any information from an online forum is to be used at the users discretion.

If posts start getting banned, then that would be a very slippery slope indeed.

We should ban posts by people recommending tools then because those tools in an amateurs hands are dangerous.

With all due respect, I disagree completely.

Re: ATTENTION: Ellis, electrical posts?

#3

Re: ATTENTION: Ellis, electrical posts?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>Marc: I really do not want them banned either. There has been a large amount of bad electrical posts lately on this and other forums. I started this thread to bring attention to the problem. The problem with these posts happening over several days is that it might be TOO late.

Please people, know your advisors qualifications before you listen to them. The expense of trained, technicians is well worth it. It would be dreadful to know that one of our friends died because of a tip that they got on WC.

Re: ATTENTION: Ellis, electrical posts?

#4

Just Use Caution ! ! !

Barry Turner

>A vast amount of information is available on the web and in on-line forums. Some is very accurate. Much is not. Medical information obtained on-line is no substitute for consulting with a qualified physician. Likewise, info obtained on-line about electrical problems is no substitute for the services of a good (licensed and duly qualified) electrician. Everyone should use caution with all information obtained from on-line sources.

Re: ATTENTION: Ellis, electrical posts?

#5

Re: ATTENTION: Ellis, electrical posts?

Jeff Rich

>My feelings about this are as follows....

We should invite a few licensed electricians to join us for chat.

I am not an electrician but have worked in audio video enough to leave some things to the pros. I will wire a circuit from a breaker box to a switch or an outlet, but that is enough for me.

I agree that we must proceed with caution with any advice concerning potentially fatal results.

Make friends with an electrician, turn him/her a few bowls or pens.

Re: ATTENTION: Ellis, electrical posts?

#6

Bill, I share your concern...thus Addy Protocol

Grant in Iowa

>We have been down this road before. I recall the consensus was that when responding to such posts, we should declare our level of competency on the subject.

I think this is where the term "Addy protocol" came from. We used to see it regularly as an introduction to a disclaimer note, describing the posters level of competency on the subject.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: ATTENTION: Ellis, electrical posts?

#7

as for myself

Jeff Willaford

>Any information I read online.... or hear in person is just that...information. It's up to me to appraise the info and it's suitability to myself. Electrical advise..turning tools, techniques, finishes, etc. Personally I address any electrical questions I have to the licensed electrician of my choice.

I would like to think that Wood Central is a community of information wealth and will remain so. Like others have said ...if we ban posts re: electrical should we also ban posts re: tools and techniques as they may lead to disaster in the wrong hands or if misunderstood or misapplied? As Ed says 'Respect the band saw'...and electricity.

Re: ATTENTION: Ellis, electrical posts?

#8

Re: as for myself

Barbara Gill------WebKitFormBoundarypTwA+e87REJF0d

>There are only a few people whose advice I would take. It varies with the question. Anyone who would do electrical work based on what they are told on a forum should have their head examined.

Re: ATTENTION: Ellis, electrical posts?

#9

Ellis Walentine

Call people's attention to questionable advice

Ellis Walentine

>Bill, I appreciate your concern. As you know, a public forum is a discussion, where we are here to inform each other. WoodCentral doesn't represent that anything said or claimed here is necessarily the best or safest way of doing something. Nor can I (or the other moderators) know whether any given piece of advice is potentially hazardous, so it would be extremely difficult to selectively edit or delete questionable advice. It would be even worse to try to ban it altogether, as we do have a lot of experts among us who usually manage to set the record straight when bad advice is given.

It is worth saying again that every forum visitor is responsible for his/her own safety, and that opinions expressed in our forums are exactly that -- someone's opinion -- and should not be trusted to be the best or safest advice on the subject, merely circumstantial advice. In matters where there is potential for harm, you owe it to yourself to consult with trained or licensed professionals. WoodCentral assumes no responsibility for the veracity of advice or information presented here, although I think our track record is better than average.

Ellis

Re: ATTENTION: Ellis, electrical posts?

#10

Dick Hines

Re: as for myself

Dick Hines

>As with the post about to electrical problem someone was having. It would be like asking on a forum how to fix the transmition in yout truck. If you are not sure what you are doing you had better get the advice from an expert and not someone on a forum.

Re: ATTENTION: Ellis, electrical posts?

#11

Re: Bill- I hope you will accept the ....

Jamie Donaldson

>... challenge to contest any questionable responses when you find them, as your expertise is an asset to those of us who don't know any better. There is a difference between being stupid and being ignorant, and stupid can't be cured, so you have opportunities to help cure ignorance.

Re: ATTENTION: Ellis, electrical posts?

#12

Re: Call people's attention to questionable advice

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>Ellis and I have communicated by e-mail, this is part of what I said to him:

I have almost given up on answering electrical posts because it is so hard to make sure that what I said, is what is read or understood. But the thread below was so glaringly wrong that I posted as soon as I saw it. Like I said in the second post to this thread, too much time can go by before these questionable posts get straightened out. I have accomplished my purpose in my post. "People, please be electrically safe and KNOW the qualifications of your poster." I spent the past 22 years in an industrial plant with seven other multi-skilled maintenance technicians, all of whom had at least ten years of hands-on experience with 12,000 Amp, 480 V/3 phase. A week did not go by without a serious electrical how-to question coming up! A normal woodworker doesn't stand a chance.

I would like to add one more guideline. Let a little time go by before acting on electrical advice....give the qualified a chance to correct the errors. A recent similar post on another forum was answered incorrectly by three different posters before it got straightened out.

Bill in WNC mountains

Re: ATTENTION: Ellis, electrical posts?

#13

I know it's True--I Read it on the INTERNET!!

Dave (PacNW)

>

Re: ATTENTION: Ellis, electrical posts?

#14

Re: Call people's attention to questionable advice

Barbara Gill------WebKitFormBoundarypTwA+e87REJF0d

>Bill that is good advice no matter what the subject. It is beyond my understanding how some people can be so willing to seek and take advice on dangerous, possibly life threatening subjects, from strangers who share a forum with them.

Re: ATTENTION: Ellis, electrical posts?

#15

Re: Call people's attention to questionable advice

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I also have a problem with people who offer advice on a subject that they know very little about.

Wally