Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Anyone have problems with tear-out...

Posts

Anyone have problems with tear-out...

#1

Anyone have problems with tear-out...

Paul Zerjay

>In Koa? I sharpened and sharpened. My first piece I ever turned, and I think I got rid of most of the tear-out. This chunk was given to me by a guy named Tony Wheeler. He reads this forum daily, but doesn't contribute much. Thanks Tony!!


img

Re: Anyone have problems with tear-out...

#2

Re: Anyone have problems with tear-out...

Texian

>Can't tell yet if I like it, but beautifully done nonetheless.

Re: Anyone have problems with tear-out...

#3

Re: Anyone have problems with tear-out...

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Paul,

Nice shape, the finial is also very nice, I would like it better with a bigger base, the way it is, looks unbalance to my eye, top heavy.

Jorge

Re: Anyone have problems with tear-out...

#4

Re: Anyone have problems with tear-out...

Gil Jones...GA

>I like it all just as it is!

Sometimes when tear-out does not seem to have a cure, I will turn in reverse and bingo, no more tear-out.

Re: Anyone have problems with tear-out...

#5

Re: Anyone have problems with tear-out...

GaryG in MD

>Very nice piece, Paul. I love the body and finial. I agree with Jorge that the pedestal doesn't fit -- if possible, you might consider replacing it with either none or something a tad more delicate.

Great work. You did the wood justice. When I have tear out problem, I spray on a little thin shellac. Some mist with water to tighten up the fibers. ...Gary

Re: Anyone have problems with tear-out...

#6

Don Pencil

Re: Anyone have problems with tear-out...

Don Pencil

>Go with the suggestions from Gil and Gary.

Also sometimes cutting in the direction. If downhill then try uphill; if uphill then try down hill.

If all of the above fails sand it if possible. Sometimes that is not possible do to other considerations but if will normally do.

Be Well

Don Pencil

Re: Anyone have problems with tear-out...

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Anyone have problems with tear-out...

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Paul, Nice piece as usual. Concerning the base, I would make it match the base of the finial...it would add lift and unify the design. Try a honed spindle gouge presented on its side to make a finish cut..cuts extremely cleanly, even on the worst grain.

Re: Anyone have problems with tear-out...

#8

Re: Anyone have problems with tear-out...

keoni

>I'm in Hawaii and have turned Koa. I'm using Doug Thompson's gouges on the Koa. With it's ability to hold the sharpness I don't get that much tear outs. I sharpen them more than usual,though . You can tell from the shavings if dullness is beginning, also from the heat coming off the shavings. That's my experience with Koa.