Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Finish for hard maple bowls?

Posts

Finish for hard maple bowls?

#1

Finish for hard maple bowls?

Dave Mount

>Because it is readily available to me, I've been turning a lot of hard maple bowls. I rotary sand to 800 grit on the lathe and this brings hard maple to a nice polish even without finish. However, when I put Danish oil on it, it seems like the wood is so polished that it takes up very little finish. After the oil dries (what little is absorbed), I've been using buffs with tripoli, w diamond, and carnuba.

All this makes a pretty bowl, but the problem seems to be that there's so little protection that any moisture at all creates pronounced water spots and rough spots like raised grain. I've also tried Shellawax cream, but it seems to suffer from similar problems -- a pretty finish when it's fresh, but easily damaged even from just casual moisture on peoples hands.

I'm about to start experimenting with film finishes, but before I do, I thought I'd ask for any pointers. I'm looking for something appropriate for a bowl that lies between a purely display piece and a salad bowl -- a bowl that can hold something like chips or nuts, then be wiped out with a damp rag without suffering too much, but nothing so severe as sitting with something wet in it.

Should I be pre-raising the grain with water somewhere in the sanding sequence? Should I stop sanding at a lower grit to leave more "texture" and enourage more oil to stick? Or should I just go to film finishes (and if so, which)?

Suggestions appreciated,

Dave

Re: Finish for hard maple bowls?

#2

Re: Any time you buff a surface ...

Jamie Donaldson

>...finished with wax there are going to be water spots, so for a bowl that will be wiped after use skip the wax process. A wiping poly finish will be more durable than a Danish oil, and most wiping poly finishes are somewhat less likely to yellow the maple color. Sanding to 800 is excessive and probably hardening the surface, and 400 should be sufficient and a better surface for absorbing more finish for a more durable product.

Re: Finish for hard maple bowls?

#3

Re: Finish for hard maple bowls?

Mike Brazeau

>I have done a number of hard maple and norway maple salad bowls that I have finished with walnut oil followed by beeswax/mineral oil salad bowl finish. Oil pops the grain. It is a low lustre finish. Whoever ends up owning the bowl can easily renew the finish with Claphams Beeswax Salad Bowl finish.


img

Re: Finish for hard maple bowls?

#4

Re: Finish for hard maple bowls?

Bill Howatt

>Another vote for leaving out the carnuba wax in the buffing process. It does make the bowls feel nice and they do look nice - at first. In time with even light handling the wax becomes imperfect in places and generally makes the piece look duller. I therefore stop at the white diamond stage.

Several wipe-on, wait a few minutes, wipe-off coats of a finish like polymerized tung oil will offer plenty of protection for the use you describe. You can also go the non-drying oil finish route as suggested and let the owner maintain the finish.

I wouldn't bother going beyond 400 grit for a bowl that is going to be put into real use.

There are lots of different finishes around and it can be a bit of a try this, try that until you have a comfortable arsenal of products at your disposal.

IMO, there is no benefit to raising the grain when using a non-water-based finish.

Bill

Re: Finish for hard maple bowls?

#5

Re: Finish for hard maple bowls?

Tery Scott

>High Mike I lacquer all my work even salad bowls as the oil drys out in galliers and at least I can just give alight sand and re spray at any time

The lacquer I use has been tested for nasties and is food safe once dry

Re: Finish for hard maple bowls?

#6

Re: Finish for hard maple bowls?

Matt Overton

>Mike, I can't quite tell, is the treatment carved or pyrography? I really like the look.

Re: Finish for hard maple bowls?

#7

Re: Finish for hard maple bowls?

Bernie Weishapl

>I started using Minwax Antique Oil. I saw Ernie Conover and asked him. He says he uses it on all of his turnings that are for utility use. I also use Mahoney's walnut oil which I like a lot. I have several salad bowl sets out in use and all have held up well.

Bernie

Re: Finish for hard maple bowls?

#8

Re: Finish for hard maple bowls? *LINK*

Mike Brazeau

>That was done with the Sorby spiralling wheel, I believe the coarsest one. Whole exercise takes about five minutes with somewhat unpredictable results. Just have to keep practising with it. Some additional pieces using the Sorby Texturing system at the link in Bowls Gallery. The beads were done with a homemade triple point tool and how to make it is in my Tools section.


The Joy of Wood

Re: Finish for hard maple bowls?

#9

Re: Finish for hard maple bowls?

John Leonard

>I use General Salad Bowl Finish applied with an old nylon stocking (best to wait till the lady if through with the stocking)for all bowls that will be used except walnut. For some reason it doesn't look good on walnut. I use three coats cut back with 0000 steel wool between coats. I have used it for the last 8 years or so and never had a problem (except the walnut) or one returned and I do buff with the Beall system. John leonard