Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Bedan Turning Tool

Posts

Bedan Turning Tool

#1

Bedan Turning Tool

Jerry Nicholson

>Would the Bedan tool on page 278 (Part Number 58B15.12) of the latest Lee Valley catalog be a useful addition to my tiny arsenal of turning tools? If so, might my Hirsch 3/8 inch mortise chisel serve just as well? If I was going to buy the tool from Lee Valley this would be a good time since the shipping is free. I am not a regular on the turning forum - to call me a novice at turning would be giving me too much credit!

Jerry

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

#2

JL

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

JL

>I like the Bedan. I think it is one of the more useful tools. I can turn beads and tapers with it easier that most other tools.

I would say - go for it.

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

#3

JL

While you might use a mortising chisel..

JL

>I would NOT recommend it. The tool design is somewhat different. Would you use a paring chisel to chop mortises? You could - but not very well.

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

#4

Re: While you might use a mortising chisel..

Jerry Nicholson

>Actually the similarities were what got me thinking about it. The Hirsch is 3/8 wide and over 1/2 inch thick. The handle is probably a bit shorter but much thicker and the bevel angle is probably a bit sharper (about 25 degrees), judging by the picture of the Bedan.

Jerry

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: While you might use a mortising chisel..

Keith Tompkins

>Jerry, most paring chisels attach to the handle with a taper fit. Vibration from turning could knock the handle loose with disasterous results. Plus, the handle isn't long enough...you want the ability to tuck the tool in under your arm for support.

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

#6

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

john lucas

>Jerry you could but the bedan is different. The one I used is tpaered on the sides while a mortise chisel is straight. You would also need to sharpen it to 25 to 35 degrees. I thought about using mine but I still chop a mortise occasionally. It's just faster than rigging up the router or changing bits on the mortiser and setting the fence.

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

#7

If you are a pre - novice level........

jake Niedling

>this tool would not make my list of recommendation for you. I would stick with a bowl gouge, spindle/detail gouge, spindle roughing gouge, parting tooling, round nose scraper and a square end scraper. Learning to use these tools well as a novice will take you a long way. Just my thoughts.

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

#8

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

Bill Gasper

>I find the bedan very useful for truing up tenons and would recommend one for any turner.

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

#9

Re:I took a class with Escoulen this fall...

JamieD

>...and what he does with a French bedan is magic! The French tool is a 1/2" square bedan, while the English is trapezoidal like many chisels. But I'm not even attempting to learn what Jeanno demonstrated!

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

#10

A Bedan and a Skew

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Jerry,

If you are a begginner, I highly reccomend to use the bedan and a skew, they are similar to an extent. Put your time to master the skew and you will be way on your way to master the other tools.

Wait to get roughin gouges and bowls gouges etc until you master the skew and the bedan, and by a real bedan, a french one if you can, and have at it, you will be surprise how much one can do with those two. Cylinders, beads, coves ... you name it.

Have fun!

Jorge

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

#11

Re: Jorge- you forgot the "kindling!"

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

#12

Re: A Bedan and a Skew

Jerry Nicholson

>I have made a few bowls from walnut that came out OK - except the one with the two inch hole in the bottom. Little miscalculation on the depth but I call it a feature not a mistake. So far I haven't had any luck at all with a skew but I haven't spent much time with it either.

Jerry

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

#13

Re: A Bedan and a Skew

Barry Turner

>It sounds like you have turned a funnel, not a bowl with hole in the bottom. Many new and experienced turners do these. Most of the time these objects are turned when we least expect it. Usually, it is on the very last finishing cut that we discover we have turned a funnel. But, all is not lost. Actually, funnels can be quite useful for filling canning jars, putting gas in the old lawnmower and other tasks.

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

#14

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

Frank Joseph

>Its A great tool I use MY bedan almost daily. Its a 50/50 to my Raffin curved skew. It has a learning curve to it, There are a lot of other tools I would suggest looking at first. also look at PSI for tools, AS a new Turner save the really good tools till you know what you like. But don't buy junk tools. Try to buy middle of the road quatilly till you know its a tool you want then buy the good stuf

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

#15

Re: Bedan Turning Tool *LINK*

charlie belden

>Assuming you're not planning on using it on anything much over about four inches in diameter - you don't need a long handled beefy tool to remove wood from a spinning object.

I've been using a 1/4" bench chisel much like a bedan - for both small spindle turning as well as for the lip and matching rim cuts for lidded boxes. I can use it like a scraper - or for cuts, including peeling cuts.

LIke any turning tool, getting the bevel rubbing and then raising the handle to begin cutting is the same. And if you use it bevel up - the bevel rubbing on the wood is nice and long.

With a short handle, movement on the handle end isn't "leveraged"/"amplified" as much as when using a long handled tool where raising the handle end 1/16" can move the cutting edge four to ten times that distance.

And with a 1/4" chisel, you don't have a lot of cutting edge available to try and take a big bite out of the spinning wood. If you can use one of those 1/4" "diamond" parting tools, you can probably use a narrow bench chisel much the same way - if you keep the tool rest close to where you're cutting. A beefier chisel, like a mortising chisel might be able to reach an inch or so beyond the tool rest. Passed that, bedan or not, look of another tool.

But for small delicate stuff - try a bench chisel - a narrow one. If that works but you want more overhand without chatter - then look into getting a bedan.


Bench Chisel as Bedan

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

#16

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

john lucas

>With a short handle, movement on the handle end isn't "leveraged"/"amplified" as much as when using a long handled tool where raising the handle end 1/16" can move the cutting edge four to ten times that distance.

Charlie I think it's the other way around. :) A large movement at the handle end equates to a very small movement at the cutting end. That's why my handles are fairly long. When I have a tool with a short handle I anchor my arm against my body and then move my whole body. It gives extremely fine control.

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

#17

Right You Are!

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

#18

Re: Bedan Turning Tool

charlie belden

>You're absolutely right - and I got it exactly back assward.

I started turning using a few mini tools from an inexpensive set. Since I don't do larger turnings, 9" diameter is about the reasonable max on the JET mini, small, short handled tools, mainly a 1/2" skew worked just fine and highly maneuverable - and no need to tuck the handle against my body for control. Of course I don't do hogging off wood fast deeper cuts.

Perhaps if I worked with longer overhangs a longer handle might be a good idea. For that, I've got the MiniMonster and one "real" bowl gouge and "real" spindle gouge (which sit in the case most of the time).

For finials, smaller spindle work and even small lidded boxes, a regular old quarter inch bench chisel is an inexpensive way to find out if a bedan is something worth getting. And because the bevel is so small, it's easy to stop and touch up with a stone or little diamond paddle thing. With a WorkSharp at the end of my lathe bench I sharpen often - quickly and easily.