Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

Posts

Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

#1

Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

charlie belden

>Virtual Reality Getting Realer � And What That May Do

Preface:

I've been playing with Google's SketchUp trying to make a simplified virtual version of the LEIGH FMT (Frame Mortise and Tenon) JIG in order to compare it with the Festool DOMINO - a hand held mortising machine. That got me thinking about what follows.

========================================

We have binocular vision. Our eyes give our brain TWO simultaneous 2D views of 3D objects. Somehow, our brain knows the distance between the focal points of our eyes and probably using something like triangulation, can work out the distance to what we are looking at � filling in the missing third dimension. The fact that the brain can do that and do it so quickly and virtually continuously is pretty amazing. Since we exist in at least a 3D world (actually 4D if you add the dimension of time), we probably THINK IN 3D.

Until about 15 years ago, if you wanted to convey a representation of a 3D object, you were limited to 2D photos, movies/videos or 2D drawings, the latter typically of a Front, Side and Top View or an Isometric View. The person attempting to see what you intended to convey had only the 2D representation(s) of what you sent them � and only from the vantage point you provided. So there was a bit of mental gymnastics required to convert 2D representations of things into how our brains deal with 3D objects. And those gymnastics have to resolve visual ambiguities the 2D representations may present to our brain.

But NOW, thanks to computers and computer graphic software, we can use Virtual 3D Objects to convey much more information about what we�re attempting to convey. Now we can convey the Virtual 3D Object � and the recipient is no longer limited to the �sender�s� vantage point relative to the Virtual 3D Object. The recipient of the Virtual 3D Object is now free to view it from any vantage point and can even change its lighting, color and perhaps texture. As a result, the recipient�s brain is receiving visual information about the Virtual 3D Object in a format much more like how she/he sees actual 3D objects.

On the immediate horizon are 3D Printers that are affordable. Provide a computer file of the Virtual 3D Object to one of these things and it �prints out� an Actual 3D Object. Also on the immediate horizon are affordable 3D Scanners that will create a Virtual 3D Object computer file of the actual 3D object.

Soon, we will be able to create Virtual 3D Objects either from things we mentally create, virtually create or actually created � in full 3D � and send them in seconds (ok so the file size may require perhaps a minute of two) to anyone connected to the internet who has an e-mail address and access to a computer which has the necessary software to use the Virtual 3D Object file � and maybe the software and 3D printer necessary to create Actual 3D Objects.

But wait, there�s more on the horizon. MRIs, CAT and PET scans are already being done today, which allow you to �see� what�s INSIDE objects. Sometime in the future, the missing link artists are waiting for is coming � not just the OUTSIDE surface of Virtual 3D Objects, but also what�s INSIDE.

As a woodturners, imagine �scanning� a blank and being able to �see� the grain and perhaps even color inside it � either before you decide how to mount it, or while you are virtually turning? Coming up with the User Interface will be tricky � but there are a lot of great and creative software developers out there.

Imagine being able to explore a blank before mounting it on your Virtual Lathe and then virtually turning it � seeing the virtual surface � with grain and color � as you go � AND � have an UNDO option anywhere along the turning process.

Now imagine how ART will change in the next 10 to 20 years. Hell, imagine how teaching and learning will change when what had been only concepts being thought of in 2D can be taught in Virtual 3D � or 4D.

Imagine how much brain power, now being spent converting 2D information into 3D information, can be applied to the 3D thought and not wasted on mental gymnastics of 2D to 3D conversion.

We live in interesting times � and how we think and create things is about to make another major leap foreward.

Got any interesting ideas for using what�s surely coming?

Re: Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

#2

Re: Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

Wayne Fladby

>As always some very thought provoking ideas Charles.

My daughter graduated high-school this past year, (with honors and a few awards in English) and at the commencement the pricipal made much

the same point in his speech. One very interesting thing he said is

that these graduating students will be using machinery in 10 years

which hasn't even been thought of yet!!

Re: Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

#3

Re: Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

Cindy Drozda

>Great point, Charlie! We all need to work hard to keep up or we'll be left behind in the 2D world!

Re: Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

#4

Re: Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

charlie belden

>It'll be interesting to see how the arts and crafts (assuming there's a difference at some point) will deal with what's coming. I suspect it'll be something like it went with photography. Initially it will be met with some resistance for two reasons - a threat to the status quo - and early works will be pretty bad, relatively speaking as artists/craftspersons (a bow to PC) learn to use the new tools and begin refining techniques and making more nuanced virtual pieces. Once there's some degree of acceptance among the A&C community, things will get even more interesting as folks start creating pieces that would be very difficult if not impossible, to do with "conventional", materials, tools and techniques.

Given analogous changes that wood turning has dealt with over the last 10 or 15 years, turners will be some of the early adopters of options the coming technology will provide. Virtual turned pieces, and then actual 3D pieces made from the virtual version, will come to be accepted, first within the turning community and then collectors, galleries and museums and eventually by the public at large.

I'm thinking it may be like the Art Noveau period, where lithography - specifically advertsing posters by the likes of Toulous Latrec and Alphonso Mucha - made owning nice works possible for the average person - for the first time. (Posters were being removed from walls before the glue had time to dry - and taken home to be displayed and appreciated).

At some point, wood turning will have its Ansel Adams and maybe an Andy Warhol, each with followers and "schools" created for their techniques.

But back to my question: What would YOU like to do with the technology that's coming, in terms of a Virtual Turning?

Re: Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Charlie, Have you ever used a cnc router? The drawing program I use is similar to autocad; I can simulate the operation the router is about to perform then cut the piece apart to examine the inside as well as the outside, then rotate the parts to examine details. All on the computer screen before the first piece is cut. Not too far from what you describe.

Re: Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

#6

Re: Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

charlie belden

>Keith:

Haven't played with a CNC machine yet, though I have access to one. I have watched a fellow turning club member use an Epilog laser on some of his turnings. He refers to it as his Photonic Pyrographic Carving Tool - an early vocabulary word for what's coming?

The Epilog has the ability to "carve" low relief stuff, using a gray scale as the depth of cut cue - white = no cut at all, black = pierce - and shades of gray for different power levels to the laser for different depths of cut. IIRC, this would give you 256 levels of depth of cut, more than enough to produce relatively smooth sculpted surfaces with pretty small "steps".

The Epilog has a very shallow "depth of field"(about 1/8th inch), so getting continuous patterns on curved surfaces requires breaking the pattern down into small areas - and indexing the piece between "burns".

Those limitations can be overcome with software like Auto CAD (or SketchUp) and stepper motors. Laser engravers, with variable focal lengths, combined with "ranging" technology will allow for larger curved surfaces to be "carved" in each "set up" of the device and blank being carved, though software could be developed to break down a virtual 3D object into workable areas and feed the results to the laser and indexing device.

Imagine what J. Paul Fennel, or Ron Fleming, or Graeme Priddle or Andi Wolfe, or Molly Winton would do with an intuitive to use software program - and a Photonic Pyrographic Carver.

The drawback to laser engraving/piercing is the blackened surface it leaves behind. Cleaning that up could be prohibitively time consuming. So maybe micro sand blasting - using a type of CNC driver will be the carving tool. Or maybe, using micro-bots or even nano-bots, "termite droids" may perform the wood removal function.

For those who use color for their pieces, ink jet technology replacing brushes and airbrushes - printing surfaces that would be virtually indestinguishable from conventional mediums and techniques - at least in normal human vision ranges.

For folks who do patination and metal foiling on the surface of their pieces - a high vacuum system with an electron beam gun to vaporize metal onto the surface of a piece. THAT technology has been around since the 70s and the semiconductor industry has been using it for quite a while now. So there's a fair amount of "obsolete" equiptment out there - waiting for artists and craftsmen to get their hands on it. I know of one such person who made amazing "kaliedescopes" from plexiglass, surfaces "mirrored" with subtle different colors using different metals - and different amounts of reflectivity.

What's lacking at the moment is an easy and intuitive CAS (Computer Aided Sculpting) programs and user interface devices. SketchUp has a "sand box" tool which permits some interactive virtual sculpting, but it's still pretty clunky - both in terms of results as well as the user interface. That will no doubt change and get better as demand for such software increases.

The possibilities for uses of what's coming are enormous. Rapid prototyping - and then refining - and/or quickly and easily doing variations once the initial virtual piece is done - PhotoShop for sculptors.

Like photography, sculptors could produce signed limited editions of pieces, distributing the cost of creating the original virtual piece over several final limited edition "prints", while maintaining control over the original "negative" - the computer file of the virtual piece.

All if this will require some crazy early adopters to work out the HOW and to prime the pump. Then, when it gets in the hands of the amateur/hobbyist as the price of software and tooling come down, and techniques explained and demonstrated - things will get REALLY interested - for all the players in this new game.

Demonstrators - imagine being able to do your demonstrator over the internet - for people all over the world - from your living room or kitchen table. No more airports, cabs, hotels. Turning clubs - how about a virtual demonstrator - for a ticket price of $5 rather than $25 to $40.

We live in interesting times - and it's gonna get a lot more interesting - for virtual turners.

I'll ask again - what do YOU see coming - and what ideas do YOU have for using what's out there now, or on the horizon?

Re: Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

#7

BarbS

w-h-o-a

BarbS

>Charlie, you're scaring me a little about producing prototypes in 3-D and signing batches of first runs:

"What's lacking at the moment is an easy and intuitive CAS (Computer Aided Sculpting) programs and user interface devices."

If an accomplished computer-geek artist can format concepts of design and print out virtual 3D copies, wouldn't that lead to something like pre-packaged stereotypes and repetitive design elements? Don't you think it would effect the imaginative process badly, rather than support it? At the very least, it might 'homogenize' future design details in 'hive mentality' virtual sharing mode.

Re: Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

Keith Tompkins

>Charlie, at the initial stage of designing my bowl gauge, my injection molder first drew the frame for my gauge on autocad, then used a prototype process to create an actual 3D prototype directly from the drawing. The prototype equipment added one "pixel" of molten material at a time until the prototype was finished...no machining or mold required. It's already here!

Re: Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

#9

Re: w-h-o-a

charlie belden

>>"If an accomplished computer-geek artist can

> format concepts of design and print out

> virtual 3D copies, wouldn't that lead to

> something like pre-packaged stereotypes

> and repetitive design elements?"

Well if you look at photography and what was around before it - and what was around before that - yes, there will probably be some pretty cookie cutter stuff, much of it pretty so-so to downright bad. But in the hands of creative folks some really nice things can result.

If the maxim "Ultimately, it's the shape and form that is the most important, colors fading or turning ultimately brown over time". So for newbies - and probably most of the rest of us - being able to experiment and develop a feel for good shapes and forms can come first, THEN the tools and techniques to actually turn them in wood - on a lathe - can follow.

Or, if you are satisfied with a piece that doesn't have all those random things found in actual wood, a virtual piece may be enough, or a 3D "printed" version may do quite nicely.

> Don't you think it would effect the

> imaginative process badly, rather than

> support it?

On the contrary - it may reduce the grunt work of hogging off 90% of the wood to get close to what you're after. I see it more like a word processor which allows you to try variations - without losing anything you've done so far. And like a word processor, or many of the graphics programs out there, it can allow you to explore several possible avenues - without having to start all over if one of those avenues turns out to be a dead end.

I don't know about you, but I've got a long list of Wild Hare Ideas I'd like to try. But many of them are likely to be very time consuming to actually make. And many of those ideas are beyond my current, or foreseeable turning abilities and just too high risk to try.

> At the very least, it might 'homogenize' future design details in 'hive mentality' virtual sharing mode.

If you look around, we've already got a bit of that now. How many Ellsworthesque, or Drozdaesque or . . . have you seen in the last 6 months?

Virtual turnings will require climbing another learning curve. Those that start climbing early will probably remain ahead of those that follow, just as some actual turners are today.

But you're also going to get the people who get Wild Hare Ideas - and pursue them - to very interesting places - that don't exist today - that a "traditional" (and that word's meaning will no doubt change) turner or a traditional turning working in virtual turning wouldn't even think to try. There's an inertia involved in getting really good at something. And that inertia tends to be difficult to redirect.

But rather than the "new" displacing the "old" there will be co-existence - like all the other branches of "turning". That seems to be the beauty of turning - and why I think what's coming will be adopted by some turners - and taken in interesting directions we may not be able to imagine now.

Re: Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

#10

Re: Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

charlie belden

>Keith:

I understand that much of the technology is already here. But CAD doesn't lend itself to free flowing, done on the fly, "brush strokes" or free hand pencil line work.

Which is not to say that there aren't drawing programs that do permit, and encourage drawing - as opposed to "mechanical drawing". Kai Kraus did a program called Painter - which Corel bought and dropped the ball on. It had virtual versions of artist tools - a "sable" brush that worked like a sable brush actually works, a "fan brush" that worked like an actual fan brush, an "oils brush" that . . . AND the virtual mediums worked very much like real world mediums - water colors "bleed" and are translucent like real water colors, oil paints could be worked as if with a spatula - and the results had the shallow relief 3D look that technique produces. BUT - you could combine mediums in the virtual world - that can't be done in the real world - a combination of oils and water colors for example - or airbrush and thick oils for a pointalistic, stippled look.

Imagine being able to brand portions of a piece - without the smoke and fire - and with a virtual branding iron - that has a copy whole areas and paste them somewhere else - at a different scale - WITH - and Undo option.

We're now playing with mechanical drawing based CAD and paper and printing as the medium for which it's intended. It's when the crazies get their hands on this stuff that things will open up - a LOT.

It's going to require a paradigm shift in how creative folks approach their next piece - being able to think in different terms, being able to visualize ideas in a different way.

Take the laser engraver. It can use a gray scale for depth of cut. But visualizing a low relief "carving" in a gray scale - white meaning highest, black being lowest - will take some work.

Again, Kai Kraus and his collaborators already have done some of this with a program called KPT Bryce. The USGS took 2D countour maps of mountains and converted them into the required "gray scale" version. KPT Bryce could then take that gray scale data and build a virtual 3D mountain - which you could then add trees and lakes and rocks etc. to - often using fractals.

Google "KPT Bryce" to get an idea of what's already out there for doing some of what's coming.

Re: Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

#11

Sculpting Modeling Tool example *LINK*

charlie belden

>Apparently Bryce is now being done by DAZ. If you can do a spiral shell you can probably do turned type objects as well.


Spiral Shell Example

Re: Virtual Reality - Changes Coming For "Makers"

#12

BarbS

A good, thoughtful answer

BarbS

>Thanks, Charlie. You make the future look full of unconsidered possibilities.

"I see it (virtual turning) more like a word processor which allows you to try variations - without losing anything you've done so far."

And perhaps this new technology will reveal itself as only another 'tool' in the artists' arsenal. Perhaps with something like this, Edison could have invented the battery much sooner than he did.

Much will change in the next ten to twenty years. If we all survive that asteroid headed our way in 2029, virtual design may be a common theme in every craftsman's hands. We'll see!

Thanks for a thought-provoking topic.