Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

How many tries does it take?

Posts

How many tries does it take?

#1

How many tries does it take?

Paul Zerjay

>On average, how many tries does it take you to get that "just right" fit on a jam chuck? I turn a lot of lidded vessels, and lately, I've been having a streak of bad luck. I get to where I'm just a little too small, and I'll take the ever so slight cut, and I'm too big. I've done enough to know that the paper towel trick is not a tight enough fit. Sometimes it pays to just go clean the shop for awhile and try again later.

Re: How many tries does it take?

#2

Re: How many tries does it take?

Barry Irby

>Somewhere between one and infinity. One a good day one to three. Some days, it ain't happening.

Do you "burn them in"? Watched a Raffin Demo. He cut a very slight taper on the jamb chuck and held the piece to it lightly while the lathe was spinning. It burned a ring on the chuck and the he careful reduced the taper to a cylinder that size. We are talking a sharp scraper or skew used as a scraper and a few thousandths.

Re: How many tries does it take?

#3

Re: How many tries does it take?

John Lucas

>I find a skew laying on it's side is the best way for me to trim just a wee little bit off to make the jam chuck. Then if you get it just a hair too small wet it and it swells enough to hold. At least sometimes. Yea like you I've used all the tricks including building it up with epoxy.

Re: How many tries does it take?

#4

Dick Hines

Re: How many tries does it take?

Dick Hines

>I have good days, bad days and going half mad days when it comes to jam chucks and box lids. One thing to remember is that you are taking the same amount off the right side as you are the left. So what ever you cut off you are doubleing it. I try to remember that every time. It doesn't always work though.

Re: How many tries does it take?

#5

Mike Stafford

Re: How many tries does it take?

Mike Stafford

>I turn a lot of boxes and therefore I turn a lot of jam chucks. First I have to jam fit the lid on the body of the box so they can be turned as a unit. Then I have to jam chuck the body of the box so I can reverse turn the bottom.

I always turn a tapered tenon and while the piece is turning put the lid or body against the taper to get a rub mark. I don't want to burn the jam chuck because it may burn my finished piece as well.

Once I have that rub mark which is the precise diameter where the lid or body will fit snugly upon the tenon I carefully reduce the remaining part of the taper close to that diameter. Then it is just a matter of sneaking up on the fit by removing dust.

I use a parting tool, a beading/parting tool or a skew depending on my mood and the way the wood is reacting to the cut.

One thing I have learned is that I have a dominant eye and although I can turn with each hand I have to be turning right handed when cutting the tenon or I will remove too much wood and not have a jam fit. I learned this the hard way.

Perhaps the best advice I can give is to remove dust and only dust as you sneak up on the fit and also make sure you are presenting the lid or body squarely as you try to push it on.

And no one consistently gets it right the first time....Some days it ain't gonna happen...

Re: How many tries does it take?

#6

Re: How many tries does it take?

Paul Zerjay

>The use of a cone shaped sacrificial block is fine for turning a tenon type jam chuck. But in my case, the tenon is part of the finished piece. I need to enlarge a hole, and jam the finished tenon into it. Either way, it's frustrating when it doesn't fit time after time.

Re: How many tries does it take?

#7

Re: How many tries does it take?

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Paul, in my opinion you are asking this on the wrong board. I know you know where to go to get the authority on the subject. ;-)

Re: How many tries does it take?

#8

take up thread chasing

John Lucas

>Paul If you thread pieces you only have to take an accurate measurement with some calipers. You can use the power threaders which are admittedly expensive but do pay for themselves if you sell boxes. You can learn thread chasing but that limits your wood choices or requires a hardwood insert. It does make it really easy to do some nice things to the lid or box bottom because the screw threads hold much better than a jam fit.

Re: How many tries does it take?

#9

Re: How many tries does it take?

D. Hansen

>If it is just a tad too loose try rubbing it with beeswax. Sometimes it is sticky enough to hold just long enough.

Re: How many tries does it take?

#10

Different approach . . . ???

Doc Green

>Paul, my first thought is that you should use a different method. Options include a vacuum chuck, doughnut chuck, or mounting the piece on a flat plate with holddowns. Sorry, but I can't be more specific without knowing the details of your pieces.

What is the purpose of the jam chucking? To prepare a seat for a knob or finial on a lid, or to turn a knob or finial on a lid? There are non-frustrating ways to do this ... maybe.

I'll admit that it may take some time to put together a different system, but it may be time well spent in the long run, especially if a more reliable and less frustrating method could be found.

Good Luck, ~Doc

Re: How many tries does it take?

#11

Close - then sand?

charlie belden

>

Re: How many tries does it take?

#12

would not recommend sanding

John Lucas

>It's almost impossible to sand a box lid to make it fit correctly. You always round it off a little and box lid needs really snug for the first fitting. I have a custom made screwdriver scraper and of course my skew that I use to sneak up on the size while still keeping the lip parallel.

Re: How many tries does it take?

#13

Re: Different approach . . . ???

Paul Zerjay

>Frankly, with my limited knowledge, I don't know of a better approach. The jam chuck is probably one of the oldest and best techniques there is. With an entry hole of 1-1/4" there is not enough surface area on a lid of that size for vac chuck to work well. A screw type hold down of some sort, or a doughnut chuck will not allow access to the whole piece. There is always a better way to do something, I just haven't come across it yet.

Re: How many tries does it take?

#14

Hey John

Paul Zerjay

>If a guy were to put threads on a tenon, how close to the shoulder can the threads be? Clear as mud?

Re: How many tries does it take?

#15

Re: would not recommend sanding

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryAo1Kz+awUUYH8ShA

>The best advice, already given, is to turn a slight taper on the male part and make a burn mark using the female part over the male part. Then turn away the fat part of the male taper so it just meets the burn mark. What's even more fun is to try to turn a tiny bead at the burn mark so that the female part snaps onto the male part. That's particularly satisfying! When doing the final, final adjustment, just THINK about removing wood -- as others have said, you only want to remove dust. And don't even cut anything; use a skew on its side as a negative rake scraper for the last tiny bit of scraping.