Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

look familiar...

Posts

look familiar...

#1

look familiar...

GaryG in MD

>I've got some road kill here. Seems like I recall that this kind of core staining is typical of Liriodendron Tulipifera (tuliptree nee tulip poplar nee yellow poplar). The bark looks about right, but I can't find a reference for the core staining. Can anyone confirm or deny this ID?

To go a step farther, what causes the color? Is it stable? Does it fade? Does it affect the turnability of the wood? Thanks, Gary


img

Re: look familiar...

#2

Re: look familiar...

Randy Johnson

>Looks more like ash to me - but then I'm not used to looking at endgrain yellow poplar.

Re: look familiar...

#3

Re: look familiar...

Don Orr

>Looks like a lightning strike I saw in a Maple once. Not familiar with Tulip Poplar up here. Real wide growth rings make me think not Ash though.

It's wood, it's free-try it !

Re: look familiar...

#4

Re: look familiar...

Roger

>Gary,

Looks like yellow poplar to me for sure. The staining usually comes from limbs that have been broken off above the stained area allowing water to get into the heart of the tree. Poplar heals quickly so you can get the staining for a while, then after the break heals, the staining will stop. Makes for some interesting pieces. You can get colors anywhere from blues, purples, greens to browns that closely resemble walnut. The colors should stay. Poplar turns easy enough but you will need to go through the sandpaper grits without skipping any to eliminate scratches.Good luck.

Roger

Re: look familiar...

#5

could be ... or could be ... or...

John K Jordan

>How heavy is the wood relative to others? (y.poplar is lighter than many) Does it smell like y.poplar? Does it cut easily with a knife?

So many specific pieces of wood look can like so many others in a photo that if you ask 10 people you might get 10 different answers.

I often see finished pieces passed around at our woodturning club where the type of wood claimed obviously doesn't match the actual wood. One guy said his bowl was cherry when it obviously had a ring porous structure, even without a magnifier. While many people would never know (or care), it could be embarrassing!

If you play with wood often R. Bruce Hoadley has a book well worth getting that will let you positively identify many domestic and exotic species. All you need is a razor blade and a 10x hand magnifier. On a small section (maybe 1/2" square or so) shave across the end grain to reveal the grain structure. You can immediately see if the wood is diffuse porous or ring porous which will eliminate a whole bunch of possibilities. The structure and arrangement of the pores often ids the wood easily, or at least narrows it down. Some species have VERY distinctive pore structure. Hoadley's book has lots of reference pictures plus great instructions. I think anyone who works with wood, except perhaps for those few who really don't care, would benefit from this book.

Any US citizen can also get up to five samples of wood IDed each year by the government labs. A forum member here once sent a little piece of unknown wood to me - I checked with Hoadley's book while she also sent a sample to the government. We both came up with the same answer (elm) but doing it yourself is a lot quicker! BTW, she posted pictures of the log and several forum members did say this wood looked like elm from the photos posted, but there were other guesses too. For the photo below I put the sample under the microscope and shot a picture through the lens with a handheld digital camera. The wavy bands of small latewood pores are typical of the elms.

JKJ


img

Re: look familiar...

#6

Dick Hines

Re: look familiar...

Dick Hines

>I would go with yellow poplar.

Re: look familiar...

#7

Re: look familiar...

Gary Evans--Tallassee TN

>Hi Gary,

Definitely yellow poplar. I have seen dark heartwood like that before, especially on older trees. The color should stick around. It shouldn't affect the way the wood turns. Post some pics when you get done with it.

Gary

Re: look familiar...

#8

Re:From the wide width of the .....

Jamie Donaldson

>.. annual rings this tree is not very old, and grew near a good water source, potentially adding to the heartwood stains. I would expect it to be very unstable during drying, losing much water as it is turned. Get out your diving suit!

Re: look familiar...

#9

I'll agree on poplar..

John Cotten

>as far as the staining, usually most staining in wood is caused by a strong mineral in the soils coming from a root section of the tree, iron being one of the ones that causes black, or in the case of poplar, black, blue, purple. I'll agree with Jamie, it is a young tree, and is not very old.

Re: look familiar...

#10

karl jr

Re: I'll agree on poplar..

karl jr

>Mineral stains caused by nails would corroborate that, I suppose.

Re: look familiar...

#11

to go (way) out on a limb.....

adrien

>Tulip Poplar I've seen here in NJ has a pale greenish heartwood that gradually turns a chocolate (milk chocolate, not bittersweet) brown that is permanent. The dark heartwood on that one looks like walnut.

Re: look familiar...

#12

Thanks all...

GaryG in MD

>I appreciate the good feedback. The group consensus is liriodendron -- I'll do some more research and get back to you with a reality check. It was growing next to a house in Silver Spring, MD in a 45 year old neighborhood -- not sure if the tree was that old.

The pieces are now Anchorsealed and still in the trunk of my junk car. I decided not to cut half rounds as I normally would -- I think I can do some interesting things end grain to show off that staining. Unfortunately, I turn outside, and it doesn't look like it's going to be warm enough for a while -- got 18" of snow on the ground, but the back patio is shoveled off, just in case.

JKJ -- thanks for the book reco -- that sounds like a Christmas present -- I've been meaning to get something like that. Good to have you back.

Happy holidays all, Gary