Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Compressors and moisture

Posts

Compressors and moisture

#1

Compressors and moisture

Paul Zerjay

>I heat my shop only during the day. In the dead of winter, it'll freeze in there overnight. I've been noticing more moisture than normal in my compressor. Do you think that's got something to do with the changes in temperature? My shop is a 24x30 barn that's been insulated. My compressor just sits in the corner with no walls or anything around it. I don't have a moisture filter on my compressor, but I empty it maybe once a month. I guess I need to invest in a filter.

Re: Compressors and moisture

#2

Re: Compressors and moisture

Pete in Holland, MI

>Do you heat with a non-vented gas heater? These guys put a lot of moisture in the air (notice condensation building on the windows while you are out there? Might be part of the problem.

Re: Compressors and moisture

#3

Re: I'm not aware of any possible....

JamieD

>...intake moisture filter, because most moisture accumulation occurs during moist air compression?

Re: Compressors and moisture

#4

Re: I'm not aware of any possible.... *LINK*

Rick_Allen

>The only input moisture filter I have heard of is refrigeration. This is costly, as much or more than the compressor.

The moisture filters are used on the output so moisture doesn't make it to the output. Moisture in a air powered tool can cause rust and shorten the life of an air tool.

Cold air will condensate more moisture out of the air than warm air will. Your shop is likely very dry in the winter because as you warm up the shop the relative humidity will decrease. As your shop cools the relative humidity will increase.

The usual recommendation is to drain water in compressor tanks at the end of the day, not once a month. There is a valve which is often added to compressor tanks to which a small chain or thick string is attached. You pull the string to vent the water in the bottom of the tank at the end of the day or whenever you have used the compressor a lot.


Example of a tank drain

Re: Compressors and moisture

#5

Re: Compressors - slightly long

Don Evans

>Hey Paul:

There really is NOT anyway to remove the moisture prior to it going into the compressor tank. I'll clarify that by saying no practical way or affordable way for the type use we have. It could be done with a dryer made for that but cost prohibitive more than likely.

Remember that moisture in the air is relative to the temperature of the air. Therefore, cold air, because the air molecules are contracted and closer together cannot hold as much water as warmer air which has more room between molecules to hold more water. Thats why the weather man always talks about relative humidity instead of the amount of moisture that is in say one cubic foot of air.

A compressor gets hot when running and the amount of moisture available in the air easily stays suspended. But when it cools down to room temperature some of that moisture is squeeze out, as the shop cools even more during unheated winter nights even more moisture is squeezed out. This is what is visible by your comment of more water now.

It's a good idea to form the habit of draining your tank every time the compressor runs but after it cools down to room temperature. I do this regularly but I have a large tank (80 gallon) and unless I'm running the dental drill for piercing don't run the unit but once a week to fill it up.

Apparently you don't do much with air other than using it to blow out things? Or fill up tires etc. With no filters on the output if you are using air tools they will soon be ruined from moisture and if painting that would be ruined also. With some things like painting you have to go a step further than filters and also have a dessicant dryer on the line used for paint gun or air brush. This would be placed between the paint gun and the small filter.

With moisture in output air you are actually dealing with two types of moisture, the droplets and vapor moisture. The filter removes the droplets and dessicant removes the vapor moisture.

Also understand that a filter works by slinging the water around a bowl in a circular movement, this slings the moisture out just like the spin cycle on your clothes washing machine. How well it does this is based on two things, one is the size of the bowl on the filter and the other is the psi of the air as it goes through the bowl. The smaller the bowl the more moisture it will remove, also the higher the psi the more it will remove. Knowing this, you can see why it will not work on the input air going into the compressor.

I don't really see any damage it would do if it does freeze in the tank. This assumes that you are draining it enough that the quantity of water is small, say cup or less. As long as there is room for the ice to form and the air that it compresses it will not harm anything.

Most all of our experience with water and freezing is with water lines but that is totally different issue as the water lines are not constructed to withstand the pressures that ice can create.

Don't take that to mean you should not try to correct this as rust and tank plus tool failure are are real issues that should be addressed.

One way is to dump the air in the tank over night and leave the drain cock open. Once the shop is warmed and if you need air that day THEN fill the tank. To make this task easier I removed the cock and piped with copper pipe, a 90 degree, then another piece of pipe with a ball valve on the end of it. This gets it out to the side of the tank and easy to drain. If you do decide to drain nightly, wear ear and eye protection. The sound of air from the ball valve or cock can do damage.

Don

Re: Compressors and moisture

#6

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re:Automatic Drain

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>I picked up an automatic drain for mine. Got it off Ebay for about fifty bucks, several years ago. It's adjustable for both interval and duration. Mine is set to drain for one second, about once an hour whenever the compressor is turned on. Works great!

Jim D.



img

Re: Compressors and moisture

#7

Re:Automatic Drain

GalenV in Iowa

>Jim has your best solution. We had Quincy put the electronic moisture minders on every compressor pack we bought for resale in water and waste water plants. They end up is a cool damp location in most plants. The electronic work better than the pnuematic type.

You might find a rebuilt Hankison or Wilkensen refrigerated air dryer but then you would have trouble when your shop got to freezing temps. They do make coalescent type filter but sound like you have too much moisture and they are expensive.

Don made a comment the freezing in your tank may not hurt anything but if you have a drain valve or petcock it could burst the body.

Moisture can condense in the head of the compressor and if it freezes it aint going to work.

Galen

Re: Compressors and moisture

#8

Re:Automatic Drain

Don Evans

>I did make that comment, but I hope it is not taken out of context. I don't recommend leaving it that way but I didn't make that part of it very clear. I simply meant to ease his mind in that it probably will not cause a great problem as long as it is corrected soon and he follows my draining advise in the mean time.

As far as the head goes, the bleeder valve should blow the air out of the head as soon as it shuts down, at that point in time the air is still HOT in the head and moisture should not have condensed at that point in time. As the air goes out from above the piston(s) so goes the moisture with it as it is still suspended in the hot air.

I DON'T agree with ice inside busting anything. There is just too much room for it to expand inside the tank. Ice as it expands will take the path of least resistance which is back up into the tank.

I think his biggest problem is too much moisture will result in rust and corrosion over time.

I stated how I do the draining on my system routinely and I will also say that the water coming out is clean as from the tap. It looks that way but I wouldn't drink it!

Don

Re: Compressors and moisture

#9

Re: Compressors - slightly long

Paul Zerjay

>Hey Don

This way seems easiest and cheapest in my view. You are correct in that most of my use is for blowing out shavings. I do use it however for a R.O. sander. That's what is worrying me, in that I don't want to ruin a good tool.

Re: Compressors and moisture

#10

Re:Automatic Drain

GalenV in Iowa

>Don

My Sear "buzz bomb" compressor is setting out in the below zero garage. IF I followed the manual it says to open the drain petcock after every use and LEAVE it open. Not going to depressurize that noisy thing to have to wait for it to pump up each time I use it.

Wonder how many other IOM say to do that? Waiting for it to break anyway to get a better one. Had this so long I forgot when I bought it, darn.

My worst examples where compressor we supplied in State Park water plants that use hydropnuematic charged tanks for operating pressure. Must shut down for winter. Even the loadless starting units then set there all winter and moisture drawn in and the piston could even rust to the cylinder over the winter.

I wish ice took least path of resistance then garden hose left out would not split, drain traps in cabin and RV would not bust like they do. Even the hidden loop in water lines not blown out can rupture the pipe.

Get the idea I just have bad luck and have to fix things. :>(

My compressor is my risk by not following IOM!

Get the idea you've done some service work too!

Galen

Re: Compressors and moisture

#11

Re: Compressors - slightly long

Bill Crommett

>I am currently using an old piston pump compressor that i bought second hand from a Sears store approx. 25 years ago. About ten years ago it began to sound like the piston was about to escape so I bought a new five horse oil-less compressor and relegated the old pump to the barn for as long as it would last. I could not stand the horrible noise of the oil-less pump so I brought the old one back into the shop, and decided not to bother with the recommended draining because I didn't think it would last long enough to make any difference. I have probably drained the tank about every four or five years and I drain the low spot in rhe line about once a month and it is stil pumping up 92# of pressure to blow shavings and spray lacquer ---- after 25+ years of neglect. Go figure.