walnut finish
karl jr
>I have gotten some less than desirable results with oil finishes, i.e. danish oil on walnut. The white oh-so-nice sapwood yellows. What finish can I use to maintain that nice bright whiteness?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
walnut finish
karl jr
>I have gotten some less than desirable results with oil finishes, i.e. danish oil on walnut. The white oh-so-nice sapwood yellows. What finish can I use to maintain that nice bright whiteness?
Re: walnut finish
Texian
>You might try lacquer on a piece of scrap.
Re: walnut finish
Carole Valentine
>Walnut with sap wood is a problem for me. I have several choices:
I can use oil and get the beautiful dark deep finish on the heart wood and have the sap wood turn amber.
I can use a water clear poly like Velvit Oil Aqua-Shield which keeps the sap wood white but then I sacrifice some of the dark oiled look on the heart wood.
I can use a sealer (I like a 50% thinned lacquer wash) which usually is a pretty good compromise.
I have not experimented with different treatments on the sap wood and heart wood on the same piece (i.e. seal the SW only then oil everything.)but that may be worth trying on a piece of scrap.
Re: walnut finish
russ fairfield
>You are going to have a problem keeping the white color, and you will have to accept a compromise. Anything you put on the white sap-wood will change its color to some degree, immediately or later as both the wood and the finish age.
The bare wood will tend towards a gray coloring, and maybe some yellowing, with age and exposure to air and light. Plain water, which will impart the least color to the wood, can give it a gray coloring. Wet the surface and see what it does.
Avoid any oil finishes, and everything that has polyurethane in it. They will look good on the dark wood, but you have already seen their yellowing effect on the white sap wood, and it will get darker with age.
Wax will have the least effect of anything you can put on it, and will be almost the same as the surface that was wetted with plain water. I would suggest using the Bealle buffing so you get a good coating of pure Carnauba on the surface. Stay away form paste waxes because they have softer beeswax and paraffin mix in them to make them more user-friendly, but seriously compromise the durability of a pure Carnauba.
If you want a durable finish, lacquer (already suggested) will impart the least color of any finish, but a nitrocellulose lacquer such as Deft will itself turn amber with age.
A waterborne acrylic won't change the color of the white sap-wood much more than water or wax, but you may not like what it does to the darker Walnut because some of them can ghive the dark wood a muddy appearance.
I would suggest experimenting with some of the finishing options before the wood is turned down to finished size. That way you can turn away the rejects while deciding which compromise you like the best.
Others may suggest other options that they have used and liked. Personally, I would go for the wax applied with the buffing wheel, and accept that it might have to be renewed every year or so.
Thank you all for the finishing tips
karl jr
>
General Finishes "High Performance" will...
JamieD
>..do an excellent job of retaining the original colors, especially the white. It is a H20 based polyurethane that is durable and easily buffed to a nice gloss if desired.
Can a brush on finish be wiped on?
karl jr
>
Re: Can a brush on finish be wiped on?
Russ Fairfield
>Yes, no, and maybe. It depends on how fast it dries and soon the surface film starts to form.
Oils and varnishes are slow drying and they can be wiped on with the addition of some thinner.
Shellac and lacquer generally dry too fast, but we can get around that by using a little oil between the pad and the finish and keeping the pad in constant motion.
The waterborns are a case of some dry too fast, while others can be wiped on if you work fast. It will depend on the humidity because that will influence how fast it dries. The "High Performance" that Jamie mentioned says it can be applied by padding (wipe-on), but I have never tried it.
Re: Can a brush on finish be wiped on?
karl jr
>I think I'll give it a try. No risk, no gain, right? The wax treatment you suggested should work well for more decorative, less handled pieces, but this stuff sounds better for the NE walnut bowls I'm planning.
Thanks
Re:I wipe on the High Performance....
Jamie Donaldson
>...quickly with a piece of foam carpet padding, then leave it alone till dry. As Russ mentioned, it dries according to humitity levels, among other influences, but don't go back over the surface while drying and break the surface film or it will rough up the final surface smoothness.