Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

hideous grey on box elder

Posts

hideous grey on box elder

#1

hideous grey on box elder

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryAo1Kz+awUUYH8ShA

>If I must say so myself, I turned a really nice, fairly large, hollow form to give as a gift to a niece, It's box elder and has some lovely red streaks running through it. But when I finished it with some Watco Danish oil, it immediately developed a nasty brownish grey patch ( away from the red areas) which I believe ruined the piece. I think I could start over and sand it out or , perhaps, bleach it, but I'm uncertain about how to proceed. Please advise!

Re: hideous grey on box elder

#2

Re: hideous grey on box elder

Texian

>There's a word we don't see frequently (hideous). Could you post some pictures of this alleged unattractive object please. We may like it.

Re: hideous grey on box elder

#3

Re: hideous grey on box elder

Dick Coers

>Oil can cause trouble with soft woods, and once the oil is in there, it's just about in there for good. Bleach sure won't take it out. The only way I can think of for you to work with it, is to add or soak it with lacquer thinner. That will leach out some of the oil. Then you can use a water white lacquer for a brighter finish.

Re: hideous grey on box elder

#4

Re: hideous grey on box elder

russ fairfield

>You can dye it red over the gray area. It will come out a darker red and the color will last longer. It is best to spray the dye and feather the edges, but you can do it with a foam brush if you keep it relatively dry.

If you sand the oil finish off the wood, you can try using the red powdered snap-line chalk to get a similar effect.

Re: hideous grey on box elder

#5

Re: box elder & red powdered snap-line chalk

GalenV in Iowa

>I hear something new in every posting on WoodCentral. Sure a great way to learn more about turning and finishing. I'm still trying to figure out how you bleach box elder and yet the red stays!

Now using red chalk as a pigment "stain"?

Can you explain how you can duplicate the red streaks with chalk? Dust it on then wet it with some agent or finish?

Is this out of a book or experimental learned method?

Thanks if you could expand the use.

Galen

Re: hideous grey on box elder

#6

Re: box elder & red powdered snap-line chalk

john lucas

>Haven't heard the chalk line thing. I'll have to try it. I have some since I use my chalk line when I rip up wood on the bandsaw.

I have tried airbrushing the red. It's difficult and takes a good air brush and lots of practice.

I've bleached a lot of box elder. The red doesn't bleach at all the many times the brown and grays won't bleach. The light wood bleaches really well.

Re: hideous grey on box elder

#7

Book? Who reads books?

russ fairfield

>Rub the chalk into the bare wood. Apply a light coat of the oil finish and work some more of the chalk powder into the finish. Add a little blue chalk if you want a deeper red.

Add some streaks to the bare wood with a black and dark brown Sharpie type marking pen.

You can purchase commercial pigments and stains that will give you similar coloring effects. The only difference is that, with the chalk, you are mixing it yourself.

Re: hideous grey on box elder

#8

Re: hideous grey on box elder

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryAo1Kz+awUUYH8ShA

>Please let me say again that this ugly grey area is AWAY from the nice red streaks.; it's a grey area that would otherwise be a yellow color. So I don't want it to be red -- just not an ugly grey.

Re: hideous grey on box elder

#9

Re: hideous grey on box elder

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryAo1Kz+awUUYH8ShA

>Thanks for responding. Perhaps 'hideous' is too strong. But I know when something doesn't look good.

Re: hideous grey on box elder

#10

Rob Wallace

Re: hideous grey on box elder

Rob Wallace

>Eliot:

In my experience, some of these 'ugly grey' areas might be mineral stains, and I'm not too sure if bleaching will remove them or not (I've never tried). I have had pieces of box elder with both red "flame" caused by the internal fungal infections that Acer negundo is prone to, as well as some contrasting bluish-grey streaks caused by mineral staining (....as far as I could tell). Nearly every piece I have produced with this combination of red streaks and blue-grey staining has sold quickly, so they may not be as 'ugly' to some as you might think.

If you do try to bleach away these grey areas, please let us know if it works - I am very curious about this grey coloration.......

Rob Wallace

Re: hideous grey on box elder

#11

Re: hideous grey on box elder

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>I have run multiple (failed) experiments to bleach the grey out of Maple because I did not believe what others were telling me. Believe it. Nothing will bleach the grey out of the wood.

Re: hideous grey on box elder

#12

Re: hideous grey on box elder

GaryG in MD

>Eliot, Try lemon juice -- can't hurt. ...Gary

Re: hideous grey on box elder

#13

Re: hideous grey on box elder

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryAo1Kz+awUUYH8ShA

>I've taken your advice before about supper fast sanding, so why wouldn't I continue to listen to you? But I just HAVE to try sanding out the grey and then using a two part bleach. I'll get back to you and others after it doesn't work!

Re: hideous grey on box elder

#14

Re: hideous grey on box elder

Barry Turner

>Good luck with that. From my experience,the blue stain in Box Elder does not sand out. From what I have been told, you can't bleach it out either. Learn to accept it for what it is.

Re: hideous grey on box elder

#15

Re: hideous grey on box elder

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryAo1Kz+awUUYH8ShA

>Well. guess what?! Most of the grey sanded out and more disappeared after bleaching with two part wood bleach. It's not all gone, but that's o.k. with me because the piece looks fine now; what's left of the stain seems to blend in fairly well and look like it belongs there. You can still claim that you were correct, in that there still is stain remaining, but the sanding and bleaching definitely helped a good deal. Incidentally, the bleaching did not take much of the nice red stain out.

Re: hideous grey on box elder

#16

Re: hideous grey on box elder

John Leonard

>Steve Russell had an article in Woodturning on bleaching wood. In the article he recommended using household bleach to take out the blue (gray) stain in wood. The commercial strength is better. I have tried it once on box elder and it reduced the stain greatly. The commercial strength might have taken it out completely. However i have been unable to find the commercial strength which is 10% vice 6% for household stuff.