Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Lathe Torque and Coring out Bowls

Posts

Lathe Torque and Coring out Bowls

#1

Lathe Torque and Coring out Bowls

Mark Paulley

>I am looking at purchasing either the Robust Sweet 16 or the Oneway 1640 with outboard, both with the 2HP. The Oneway has it where you can move the belts on the pulleys to get more torqoue when for example coring out bowls.

The Robust you do not adjust any pulleys, I was told it is accomplished electronically.

Is that possilbe that the computer knows when to adjust torque?

Has anyone cored out bowls on the Robust sweet 16? I use the Oneway system for coring now on my WoodFast.

If you own a Robust what don't you like about it if anything?

Any help is greatly appreciated

Thanks

Mark in KY (No snow yet!)

Re: Lathe Torque and Coring out Bowls

#2

Re: Lathe Torque and Coring out Bowls

Rick_Allen

>Those are both terrific lathes.

You will have less torque with the Robust 16 at low speed than the Oneway will deliver when the belt on the Oneway is set for the slower speeds.

The robust 16 will let you core bowls using the Oneway coring system. I would not select the Oneway over the Robust based upon the very slight advantage the Oneway has with coring.

Spend a little time on both lathes to help you make up your mind.

Notice how easily each lathe is to adjust

Notice how easily you can access your workpiece using each lathe

See if the controls can be positioned where it is natural for you to use the lathe

Have fun making your decision and know that you will be using the lathe you select for many many many years.

Re: Lathe Torque and Coring out Bowls

#3

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Lathe Torque and Coring out Bowls

Dennis in Southern Oregon

>Mark, I have not used either of these lathes to core bowls. However, as an engineer, I would like to point out that, given the same motor, a lathe with multiple gear/pulley ratios will provide more torque at the lower speed ranges than will a direct-drive lathe, assuming that both lathes have the same maximum speed. This is exactly similar to a stick-shift car where in one case the gearbox works and in the other case, the gearbox is stuck in high gear. If the engine is big enough, you may be able to spin the tires in high gear, but if the engine is not up to it, you have the option of shifting down. There is NO magic in the direct-drive motors.

Dennis

Re: Lathe Torque and Coring out Bowls

#4

Re: Lathe Torque and Coring out Bowls

Don Evans

>The answer is yes it can be done with electronic VECTOR control. This isn't new technology but like all newer things it takes time for the price to come down so it's available for the public.

I would be a little concerned as which type they are using, closed or open loop, if indeed that is what they are doing. I don't know of any other way to do it however.

It would be interesting to know mainly because of cost of the motor if after warranty you have to purchase one. It takes a special motor built for closed loop. A closed loop motor actually sends a signal from an internal sensor back to the controller. The open loop type doesn't have a special motor and the controller is designed to guess what is needed in order to maintain a stable speed. This is done via software programming, I'm sure new advances are still taking place that I don't know about.

I don't have any actual experience with vector motoring to fall back on, so cannot say how well it works as compared to the mechanical belt changing.

One problem that I can foresee is the problem of keeping the motor cool enough during long periods of slow speed. The cooling fan may not produce enough air. Where as the belt moving type requires or allows the motor to turn faster while slowing down the spindle.

Don

Re: Lathe Torque and Coring out Bowls

#5

Re: Lathe Torque and Coring out Bowls

Mark Paulley

>Rick, Dennis and Don,

Thanks for the help!! The Robust is not a direct drive it does have a belt, just not adjustable to different pulleys.

I have used the 1640 several times turning and coring and it is a caddilac for perfromance and such. A local wood turning shop has a Robust and I have seen demos and it is sweet but I have not seen any coring on it. I believe it to is a cadilac too but just have not seen or heard too many people talk about it.

Thanks again and if the above info helps calrify more please give more advice

Mark in KY

Re: Lathe Torque and Coring out Bowls

#6

Re: Lathe Torque and Coring out Bowls

robo hippy

>I am surprised to find out that the Sweet 16 has only one speed range. I have the American Beauty which has 3. It should have no problem with coring with the Oneway system. I would keep the speeds up on your lathe, in the 500 plus range. I often core at 800 plus on my Beauty, and I use the McNaughton system. The only Oneway I have turned on is the smaller one, 12 inch with 2 speed ranges, and found it surprisingly under powered.

As to running at slow speeds and building up heat, that has never been a problem. I had an old PM3520A for 8 years, and the minimum speed on it was almost zero. I had my Beauty minimum speed set down that low as well. I have to have that low speed range for sanding my warped bowls. NEVER any heat problems.Yes, the motor is running slow, but it is drawing very little amperage because sanding takes little force. The motor runs cooler than when I am turning. The PM now shuts off at 50 rpm. It came up on another forum (AAW I think) about adjusting it. I called them (PM) and they said the only way you can do this is to send the motor back to them, and they will reset the converter there, and your motor warranty will be voided because of heat build up problems. After sanding out thousands of bowls at those speeds, I claim that this is a 'Company' policy, and not true at all.

robo hippy

Re: Lathe Torque and Coring out Bowls

#7

Re: Lathe Torque and Coring out Bowls

Brent English

>Hi Everybody, Brent from Robust here.

We use an open loop vector style drive with an auto-tune feature. This means when we set up the drive we run it through a calibration phase that tunes the drive to the exact motor it's running. Works great. You'll start to see the auto-tune feature mentioned in our ads

We deliver very good torque at the low end. We can do this because of the auto-tuned vector drive and because the belt pulley ratio is geared down to begin with. We get the top end by boosting the frequency. Yes the motor is rated for all of this.

We have adapted this feature in our Sweet 16 and our new Liberty lathe. When the market get's more accepting, we may move the American Beauty this way too.

I hope this isn't construed as a commercial post - this is only meant to clarify what we do.