Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Sandpaper use

Posts

Sandpaper use

#1

Sandpaper use

john lucas

>I know we talk a lot about turning with razor sharp tools and being able to start sanding with 2000 grit sandpaper (yea right). It is fun taking your time and use the tools to their best advantage and it's badge of honor to be able to start sanding with as high a grit as possible.

There are advantages to this. Extremely fine details can be destroyed by even minor sanding. A good example would be my miniatures. If I start below 320 and sometimes even 400 I can ruin the details I try to achieve.

On the other hand you have look at what you are trying to achieve. I learned from a production turner friend who thought nothing of turning 500 or more cedar apples in a week that it was a waste of time to spend an extra 5 minutes cutting with tools. He would rough it out to shape in about a minute leaving tool marks but little tearout, and then start sanding with 120 grit. The wood was soft enough and there weren't any details to worry about. He would make an apple, that really looked like an apple, sanded and a layer of sanding sealer applied in about 3 to 5 minutes.

Nick Cook turns only Cocobolo wine stoppers. These are his production items and he turns them in 3 minutes. He cuts them clean enough that 120 is easily his starting point. You could push the tool a little slower and sharpen more frequently but it would slow him down. He also skips a grit or two and I believe he goes from 120 to 220. He knows exactly what it takes to get a quality product as fast as possible.

When I turn my simple wine stoppers I turn them as quickly as possible and usually start with 120. It is faster doing that than spending the extra time it takes to cut cleaner. On the other hand my detailed wine stoppers are turned to the point that I just barely need to sand them and start with 400 and 600. The exotic ones get sanded and polished to a higher shine.

What I'm saying is we should strive to learn to cut as cleanly as possible. It leaves the wood in better condition and saves sandpaper. It saves fine details and leaves crisp corners. If your doing production items you have to make some decisions on what is most important for that product. Production time is crucial and it may simply be faster to turn them a little less carefully and just start sanding with a lower grit.

Those are my observations. I'm definitely open to different styles of turning and different opinions.

Re: Sandpaper use

#2

Re: Sandpaper use

Barry Irby

>I thought you were going to say we should use sharp sand paper, the same as we use sharp tools. That's a different topic I suppose, but I like many people tend to use sand paper too long. You should use it like you stole it and need to use it up before they catch you with it.

I agree with you about the balance between tool technique and sanding. I spend twenty or thirty minutes trying to get a perfectly clean surface on a player I was working on yesterday. It's crotch grain. If I got the shape they way I wanted it, there was tear out. If I cleaned up the tear out, there were ripples in the surface. I could have power sanded it into submission in about five minutes. And I still will.

At some point, its no longer a point of honor, get on with it.

Re: Sandpaper use

#3

Re: Sandpaper use

Dave Moore

>Agree completely John.

Turning a run of twenty or whatever production items is a whole different dynamic than a one-off piece from a "special" piece of wood. Time has a different quality then.

Production items are forms which become really familiar, and teach which part of the process can be "pushed" a little without adverse effects on the finished piece. Even the design of the production piece is influenced by the desire to not get unduly slowed down by excessive intricacy, at least for me.

Production teaches speed for sure, as will any repetitive activity, but it also helps to "pare down" a form to its important elements, and avoid ornamentation that is actually unnecessary, but looked like a good idea when I thought of it.

Heck, all my ideas seem good to me at the time I have them, and I wish they were. But they're not. Go figure. :)

Re: Sandpaper use

#4

Re: Sandpaper use

robo hippy

>I can't remember who said it, but every cut is a practice cut. With that idea in mind, some times taking a bit extra time to clean things up will pay in the long run. Taking an extra minute with a final shear cut on my bowls may only save me a minute of time sanding, the tool technique will get better and faster with repetition. However, an important part of the learning process is to know when you are as good as you are going to get for this one piece, and start sanding, but the next one will be a bit better. I still think my sanding time on my bowls is slower than my turning time.

robo hippy

Re: Sandpaper use

#5

Mike Stafford

Re: Sandpaper use

Mike Stafford

>I am not a speed demon production turner although I am improving. I am not the best with tool control but I am improving.

Under optimum situations, for me, I can sometimes start with 220 or 240 on most woods. I find it much easier to get clean cuts on the more dense hardwoods particularly exotics and quite often start with 320 or higher. Not always but quite often.

I hope there is a day when my skills have advanced to the point where I can turn what I want to turn very rapidly and not have to do a lot of sanding.

Here are some lessons I have learned:

Sharp tools reduce sanding.

Better tool control reduces sanding.

Using the right grit to start with reduces sanding.

Quality sand paper is the worth the extra money.

If the wood is getting hot you are using too much pressure or sanding at too high spindle speed.

And most importantly use sandpaper as if John Lucas was paying for it.

Too many people try to use a piece of sandpaper until the very last piece of grit is gone. I know sandpaper is expensive or at least it seems expensive but in reality it is not. Our time is much more valuable and trying to sand out 36 grit scratches from poor tool control with 150 grit paper is slow and tedious, possibly damaging to the turning from heat checking, can cause the turning to become out of round and is one of the reasons we hate sanding.

Use the correct grit to start and get out the scrapes, torn end grain, undulations etc. that are left from tool work. And progress from there. Use fresh sandpaper with moderate pressure at lower spindle speeds so the grit can cut and not burnish the wood. And dare I say it again, use sandpaper like John Lucas is paying for it. Make John come off some of that old moldy money he has stashed away....

Re: Sandpaper use

#6

:) :) :)

John Lucas

>Mike If I have to pay for it you would use it until there are 3 grains left, and then you would put that in the drawer and call it 80 grit and use it on the next piece.

Seriously though one of the best things that happened to my turning was when I started thinking of turning tools as disposables, like sandpaper. No longer was I afraid that sharpening would use them up. Consequently I sharpened more, got better at sharpening which used up less metal, and got better at turning because I was using sharp tools. this in turn allowed me to use less sandpaper.

Another thing that happened about then was buying large quantities of good sandpaper instead of the cheap stuff from Lowes. The good sandpaper lasts longer and sands cleaner so just like the turning tools I use less of it.

Re: Sandpaper use

#7

Re: Sandpaper use

Texian

>And the scratches from 80 grit are about as difficult to remove as were the tool marks that the 80 was used to remove.