Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

What am I missing? Safety issues?

Posts

What am I missing? Safety issues?

#1

What am I missing? Safety issues?

russ fairfield

>It seems to me that there are some serious safety issues being ignored in these conversations about using a glove, loose clothing getting caught in the lathe or spinning wood, underhanded techniques as opposed to proper (?) overhanded tool holding, what kind of a bevel we should grind on a tool, and which tool we should be using to make what kind of a cut.

It seems to me that -

IF we are using the right tool with the right profile and presenting a sharp tool properly to the wood, sliding it along the wood surface on the bevel, using the bevel as the pivot to control the depth of the cut, and we are letting the tool cut and make a natural shaving as opposed to forcing it into the wood; then there is next to no force in any direction at the tool rest. Our hand at the tool rest is only guiding the tool, and there is no need for a death grip on the tool to keep it going where we want it to go, there is no reason to have our fingers wrapped around the tool rest, there is little reason to be prepared to control some irratic tool movement such as a catch, and it doesn't matter whether we are using our hand under or over the tool.

If we are not using the tool as described, we are either using the wrong tool for the cut we are trying to make or we need to go back to the basics and learn how to use a lathe tool.

On the issue of gloves or bare hands, I have to ask the question. Why are your hands or fingers anywhere between the tool rest and the spinning wood. If you keep your hands behind the tool rest where they belong, what difference does it matter whether you wear a glove or not. There should never be any reason to wrap our fingers around the tool rest to control a properly used tool, and there should never be any reason for putting your hands or fingers between the tool rest and the spinning wood.

On getting our cloths wrapped around a chuck or a spinning piece of wood - There should never be any reason to reach across the top of a spinning piece of wood - EVER.

Sanding finishing should be as close as we get to the spinning wood, and that should be done carefully while holding the paper or cloth under the spinning wood so any grabbing will pull it away from our fingers, and not pull our fingers into the wood.

Tool storage is also an important factor. Many woodturners build their tool rack on the wall behind their lathe. This requires them to reach across the lathe for every tool they use. It only takes one time while the wood is spinning to get caught up in your work, and don't count on the fact that the lathe might have only 1-HP to save you from some serious hurting before you stall the motor.

Having to wear heavy clothing in an unheated shop is an accident waiting to happen. Besides getting in the way, heavy clothing is often loose fitting, or restricts movement. It we have to work this way, we should use extreme caution, wear cloths that aren't easilly caught on anything that is moving, wait until spring, or put a heater in the shop.

Tell me where I am wrong.

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#2

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

Texian

>Sounds reasonable to me Russ.

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#3

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

Barry L Elder

>Common sense is a relatively rare commodity until after the "ouch"!

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Russ, A couple of thoughts. I'll bet many catches happen because the turner carelessly allows the tool to come in contact with the wood before the tool is on the toolrest. I hope someone didn't misinterpret my previous post that I put my fingers between the wood and the tool rest. I DO reach across the top of a finial with my palm on the rest, steadying the turning with my fingers while I cut small details. At this point, the diameter is about 1/16". I never thought of this as being dangerous, but then, I probably should never mention such a technique online. You just don't know the skill level or IQ of those visiting the site.

I think many catches result because turners cannot duplicate the same grind. The tool cuts fine one time, then after sharpening, it's uncontrollable. Sharpening is a fundamental of the game. It must be learned.

Teaching new students can be a very dangerous situation. We all have strong or weak points, but some people should NEVER be in a workshop. EVER.

Yes, I am in the process of making a new, at least different, turning tool, where I'm experimenting with several grind combinations. I think that's simply part of a natural chain of events. We take what we know and try to improve on it. For example, somebody ground a skew with a curved edge to improve the way it handles....some find it useful, and it's become commonplace. Frankly, I want to create a tool that makes the skew obsolete; in the words of a middle-eastern oil man "The stone age didn't end because we ran out of stones."

I'm not implying that anyone should grab a tool and begin to modify it....they could get themselves hurt. You are correct...learn the basics.

I think people wear gloves because with the overhand technique, the chips fly back and hit the hand. Gloves are bad. Imagine your watch hitting the jaws of the chuck, or your wedding ring. Take that stuff off. Last, before starting the lathe, ask yourself...am I mentally prepared? Enough sleep? Is this safe?

If you think something my not be same....it probably isn't.

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#5

Steven Antonucci

The flaw is assuming that a new turner knows this

steve antonucci

>If it were just as simple as stepping up to the lathe with a properly honed tool in hand, and magically knowing all of the missteps so you could avoid them, then this would be great advice.

The issue is that new turners don't know ANY of this. How do you make someone safe on a lathe? You dumb the rules down for them into a few basic elements:

Grip- keep you hand over to arrest a catch

Body- don't stand in the wrong place

Prep- only short sleeves, no gloves

Faceshield- Always

You don't want a new turner to get a mixed message about when it's OK to start sliding around the beginner rules, because they don't know when they are no longer beginners!

I know guys who have been turning for 30 years and are still beginner, but they'd be insulted to hear it! I can see it in their work (tear out, dull tools), and people sometimes ask them for advice because "they've been turning for 30 years".

My simple rule is that I assume nothing and I start from the beginning. Do I turn in long sleeves? Sometimes (small work). Do I rough out a bowl with a glove? Sometimes (hand behind the rest, and shaving pounding it at 300 degrees). Do I use an underhand grip? Occasionally (finials like Keith, and a good 6" from the chuck).

It's all about i before e, except after c... learn the basics before you move on to the exceptions. Basics work 90% of the time, and with the lowest risk of injury.

It only takes one time...

S

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#6

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

Marc Phillips

>There is so much information in this post that I REALLY wish I would have known when I started turning!

I went for a couple of years holding on for dear life to a bowl gouge... I just thought that was part of the deal... that turning was sort of a physical hobby concerning the hands.

I didn't know... that simple.

I like the idea of having a basic set of "rules"... things that a new turner should know before getting very deep into turning at all.

Of course, you can lead a horse to water....

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#7

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

russ fairfield

>Keith,

There are some things we do in the privacy of our own shop, but should never admit in public that we do them. I got soundly hammered by a long list of experts and beginners alike when I posted a photo of using my hand as a steady rest, just as you described, a few years ago.

I didn't think it could be done, but after a lot of practice and broken finials, I discovered that I could turn long and thin without using my hand to hold it. It isn't wasy, but it can be done.

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#8

Steve Kubien

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

Steve Kubien

>Russ, you are correct on so many levels. My concern about the gloves is, what if I screw up? That is the thing that always stops me from buying them (and weraing them). For me, it is a matter of removing one more thing to worry about or worse, forget about.

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#9

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

Scott Crumpton

>Russ, you make some good points regarding technique.

I work in computer security; we use a concept called �security in depth� which basically states that no one security mechanism or protocol can be expected to be 100 percent effective 100 percent of the time, it�s therefore necessary to layer defenses. To depend on only one defense is asking for an eventual failure. I think safety is similar. The first layer is proper technique, but to depend on that alone is insufficient considering the consequences. Safety equipment/procedures are your backup � just in case the unexpected happens. They form one of the protective layers between us and the bad stuff. Safety and security always involve a compromise to allow for usability or just plain getting the job done at all.

Usability can be a major problem in both safety and security. My lawn tractor (like every other one I�ve ever seen) has had the seat and reverse gear kill switches disabled because they affect usability in a way which is unacceptable to most people. Requirements for long complex passwords that must be changed regularly cause people to write them down. These are examples that actually affect usability to the point that people will do unsafe things that they would normally not do. On the other hand, the chain brake on a chain saw can prevent major injury, generally doesn�t get in the way of usage, and is therefore rarely removed.

Institutions like to make rules. It�s easier to enforce rules than to teach good technique and safety/security awareness. Rules will work for the otherwise clueless among us. Some of us will find the rules insulting. At least in our own shops we are free to make the judgment calls and balance the risk/reward equation to our own satisfaction.

---Scott.

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#10

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

D. Hansen

>I'm still trying to figure out how to turn thin without using my hands OVER the wood. How about when you are parting off and want to catch the piece. Is that still and over the top no no?

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#11

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

Carole Valentine

>I always bring my my fingers under the toolrest and under and around the BACK of the spindle/finial that I am working on to steady it, but I have a round rest that easily lets me do this. If you can't picture this, watch Cindy Drozda.

BTW, one the EASIEST ways in the world to mutilate your hand is to use your fingers to clear shaving that might pile up on top of the toolrest while the lathe is spinning! And it is something you ight be tempted to do without even thinking..just brush them away. NOT!

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#12

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

Alan T

>Carole, I am guilty of doing just that and I thank you for this warning. I'm always careful to keep my finger behind the rest but now that you mention this I will stop. THANK YOU THANK YOU. Alan

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#13

BarbS

Tell me about shop heaters

BarbS

>Satety issues: I'm needing another heater and Lee Valley is sold out of its overhead radiant heater. Tell me about what Ace Hardware heaters to avoid in a shop with sawdust and finishes and thinner present.

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#14

Re: Tell me about shop heaters

john lucas

>I just use a standard Kerosene and propane heater. I make sure I nothing flammable within 3 feet of the front of the thing and at least 2 feet from the back. I wish I had more wattage but these will have to do for now. I've run these heaters for the last 10 years with no problems. If I'm roughing out bowls I sweep up often around the heater and never leave the shop with shavings closer than 3 feet.

Unfortunately I do have top wear gloves this time of year. It's just simply too cold no to. I know the dangers and consequently there are certain things I do not do while wearing the gloves. If I need to work near the wood I remove them.

There are so many dangers in the workshop. We try our best to recognize them and limit the danger so it's good to discuss them but each person must make their own decisions.

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#15

BarbS

I do it, too

BarbS

>and every time my hand ever-so-gently dusts off that tool rest, the little voice behind me is saying "bad, bad, bad idea." I have to quit.

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#16

agree

GaryG in MD

>If elephants had wings, they could fly.

If all turners were as expert as Russ, maybe we wouldn't have injuries or need safety rules.

The point is we DO have injuries because not everyone is perfect.

Safety rules and reminders are there for a good reason -- to educate those of us who haven't been turning for 30 years so we don't start decorating our pieces in natural red. I applaud Ed Moore for his "respect the bandsaw" closing.

One never knows how many injuries are averted because of a steady stream of safety reminders, but you can bet the number is significant. The first job of any turner is to be safe.

The second job should be to help make sure everyone else stays safe.

Most people aren't perfect. Accidents happen. Proper education and constant reminders WILL reduce injuries, but we'll never know it for sure. It's a faith thing.

...Gary

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

Keith Tompkins

>Russ, You will remember a few years ago I used to talk about design concepts here on WC. Bad mistake. I really got hammered too!

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#18

JL

Do turner's smocks count as long sleeved?

JL

>I typically put mine on whenever I turn. The rib knit at the end of the sleeves is reasonably safe. I don't turn in T-shirts - too many chips a-flying down the front.

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#19

Re: Do turner's smocks count as long sleeved?

Jeff Brockett

>I went to a discount uniform store and found a short sleeve barbers smock that had a zipper front, velcro closure neck and velcro tabs on the sleeves to hold them as snug as I wanted. No more shaving down my neck or sleeves. And what a bargain $12.00!

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#20

The "Common Knowledge -Not Worth Mentioning" Thing

charlie belden

>There's a tremendous amount of information one needs to work wood safely, being it case work, carving, turning, etc. that is seldom if ever mentioned let alone explained as to WHY.

In the apprentice system days you'd be made AWARE when you did something unsafe - either before you did it - or after, though the method of making you aware in the latter case would probably involve some yelling and maybe a slap up the back of the head. With woodworking tools and machines affordable for most folks, and TV shows that give the impression that you can make your own Blurfle (desk, table, chain, plates and bowls, family room, etc.) - in under half an hour - an hour max it's - it's surprising that more newbie woodworkers aren't on the news each night as victims of some horrible shop accident.

Then there are those who know better - and do dangerous things anyway. Some make it to the annual Darwin Awards List.

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#21

Re: quartz radiant shop heaters

gtwilkins

>This is the heater I use:

http://www.finehomebuilding.com/toolguide/product-finder/w-b-marvin-manufacturing-7060-overhead-quartz-radiant-heater.aspx

I got mine from Home Hardware in Canada a couple of years ago, the only difference I can see is no light.

Trevor

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#22

BarbS

Re: quartz radiant shop heaters

BarbS

>Thanks John and Trevor.. that radiant heater is the one I wanted; maybe have to go look for it locally. Thanks for replying.

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#23

Re: Oops

gtwilkins

>Looks like the manufacturer Marvin is no longer in business, just went looking for another one for the shop and can't find any.

There is a similar one at Home Depot called the Workforce but it is only 1500 w.

Trevor

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#24

Re:Found It!

gtwilkins

>Finally:

http://www.northerntool.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/product_6970_200395479_200395479

Better price looks the same.

Trevor

Re: What am I missing? Safety issues?

#25

Re: quartz radiant shop heaters

john lucas

>I tried the radiant heaters and maybe I'm just cold natured but they only warmed me up if I stayed in one place. If I move 5 feet to one side then I was cold. I have a 2 car garage for a shop and I tend to move all over when working on different tools. I know a lot of big shops use them. Maybe those are larger units than what I tried.

I went out yesterday and looked at what's available in my town and the double Propane heaters seem to be the deal. I would have to buy an 80lb tank because it's much less expensive to operate than the 20lb tanks. The downside is that I would have to haul it in to fill it.

The industrial propane heaters all put out too much heat at the source and I don't have enough room to keep it away from things that would burn. They are also twice as expensive.