Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Underhand grip question ???

Posts

Underhand grip question ???

#1

Underhand grip question ???

Ed Moore in SW VA

>I was just turning some very small items and realized that I was using an underhand grip for good control. Steve Antonucci and maybe some others questioned this method of guiding the tool so I spent some time trying to anticipate what could go wrong.

Bang! Assume for the sake of discussion that a catch occurs. This yields a force at the tip of the tool acting downwards. My right hand grips the tool handle normally and prevents the lever action - which is independent of where my left hand is located. I will grant that if the left hand is over the tool then the tip will have a harder time raising than if the underhand grip is used. The tool rest is stationary (we hope) so it may serve as a fulcrum, but it will not apply additional force. The tool should be under control.

Where does the problem occur?

And while you are at it, respect the bandsaw,

Ed

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#2

JL

I'm with you..

JL

>I usually don't do an overhand grip as the flute of the gouges has a tendency to fill up with chips. About the only time I ever use an overhand grip is with the skew.

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#3

Steven Antonucci

It's about mass and arrested momentum

steve antonucci

>If I have an overhand grip, the entire mass of my arm and hand are on top to retard the upward motion of the tool. If I am gripping underhand, I only have the strength of my fingers protecting me.

Typical catches "lift" the tool momentarily and slam it back into the tool rest. It is this "platic collision" that cause the tool to rebound upward. If your right hand retains control, the tool will rotate upward, pointy end back towards the user. The fingertip control doubles the risk, since the tips of your fingers have very little strength (try holding onto somethin when you hit it with a hammer with just your fingertips)

Most of the catches I get are pretty minor. Even when I get a "bad one", the overhand grip minimizes it to look like a minor one. I think my situation is more a result of a happy accident, but I am now convinced that it's just as versatile and many times safer.

Steve

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#4

Re: I'm with you..

John Lucas

>I use an underhand grip for much of my spindle roughing. I like moving my hand along the tool rest. I don't really see the problem with an underhand grip. If the tool gets that big of a catch to pull the tool out of your hand then you have the tool way to far over the tool rest. Of course I could be misunderstanding what steve is calling an underhand rest.

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#5

Steven Antonucci

overhand 

steve antonucci

>


img

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#6

Steven Antonucci

Underhand

steve antonucci

>Notice how little of me is in the way of the tool coming up in the event of the catch. Three fingers in a pinch grip is not my idea of "preventative measure".

steve


img

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#7

Mike Stafford

Re: Underhand grip question ???

Mike Stafford

>Since I have shortened the handles on a lot of my tools I use the underhand grip most of the time.

That said I also turn with the tool in front of me with the handle under my forearm and my forefinger on the flute of the tool or along the side of the tool depending on the direction I am going to be rotating with the flute. Since I turn with both hands and switch back and forth depending on which direction I am cutting along the length of a piece I have had to learn this technique left and right handed.

I am getting better tool control using this method which I learned from Frank Penta and Alan Leland.

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#8

Re: Underhand

john lucas

>Yep that's the grip I use quite often. When you get a catch it pulls the tip of the tool down. The tool rest becomes the fulcrum. As long as you are holding the long end of the handle it shouldn't be a problem. At least that's the way it appears to me and I've a lot of catches over the years because I learned by myself in the early stages.

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#9

Re: Underhand grip question ???

russ fairfield

>Your hands should never be between the tool rest and the spinning wood.

It has nothing to do with whether you use an overhand or underhand gtip, or whether or not you are wearing a glove. Safety has everything to do with not getting your hands where they shouldn't be.

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Underhand grip question ???

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Ed, There may be other factors that I didn't notice in the thread...first, if the tool rest is too far away from the turning, the tool could catch, the fulcrum point gives the wood mechanical advantage, pulling the tip down while raising the handle violently..a short distance at the tip translates to a large movement at the handle. Either grip wouldn't help in that case. Tucking the handle under your arm would.

Turning finials, I reach around the turning, securing it with my hand while only a thumb and one finger guides the skew. That may be a bad thing.

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#11

Steven Antonucci

It all depends upon what the user does in a catch.

steve antonucci

>You are correct that the point of the tool will want to rotate downward, but I've seen new turners try to counteract this, which usually means they push down with their right hand, further worsening the catch and momentarily moving the tool above the tool rest.

It is the corrective action that slams the tool back down on the rest, and rebounds it our of their grip and into flesh. Both guys I saw do this were struck right below their right eye, narrowly escaping a bad situation.

This grip can be used safely, but only on the most delicate cuts on a piece that is small diameter spindle(low rotating mass). I've seen people try this in rouging out a bowl.

I dial 9-1- and wait for the scream...

Steve

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#12

Use the right grip for the type of turning

John Cotten

>Underhand grips are used mostly for spindle turning, not bowl turning. The underhand grip works well for spindle work because you are primarily turning with the rest slightly BELOW center, not above. When you have it above center you are much more likely to get the catches with a upward bounce you are encountering. Something else to consider is spindle work uses a great deal more scraping cuts compared to shearing.

I once heard bowl turning as dancing with the wood and tool. There is a great deal of truth to this. I have seen full time production spindle turners who sit on a stool and turn for hours who use the underhand method primarily.

For doing face plate or bowl work, overhand is much safer and allows the flexibility of movement required for that type of work. The overhand allows for the tool to be rolled over and moved up and down the face of the cut required for hollowing or making outside face cuts. It is for the most part a power grip. The rest should be slightly above the center for overhand cutting.

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#13

spindle turning is scraping

john lucas

>John you said "Something else to consider is spindle work uses a great deal more scraping cuts compared to shearing" I'm not trying to set up an argument but I never use a scraping action when spindle turning. I do use a scraper on bowl or hollow forms in shear cutting and on platter will occasionally use a scraper flat. I can't imagine why I would use one on a spindle. I think most turners use shear cutting on spindles.

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: It all depends upon what the user does in a ca

Keith Tompkins

>I Got it! A safety tool rest for newbies....it would look kinda' like a captured rig used for hollowing. You're very welcome...next problem! he he.

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#15

Re: Underhand grip question ???

Carole Valentine

>Well, I guess I am stupid, or lucky, or maybe both. I use the underhand grip a LOT...even with a SRG sometimes. I have never had a catch that even remotely threatened to fling the gouge back up at me. Of course, if I get a bad catch on the DVR, it shuts off, but I am not sure that would happen in time to prevent what you folks are discussing. Catches generally tend to push my tool back and down and I ALWAYS maintain firm contact with the tool rest. Maybe this is one of those things I need to see to appreciate.

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#16

Re: It's about mass and arrested momentum

Tery Scott

>Steve I have seen allot of people using an underhand grip as many demonstrators advocate its use.There is no way I will ever turn in this way as I like a bit of metal in between my hand and a piece of wood spinning at 2500 reves or more

Plus I tend to walk the chisel across the tool rest by raising my fingers rather than sliding my hand across which you cannot do if gripping onto the underside .

If you need to press to firmly down on the rest or need additional support for the chisel id suggest you change your style

You should be able to hold the chisel and turn without any support with the other hand on the tool rest at all let the chisel do the work

people often ask me how much grip they should have on a chisel i reply by words of wisdom given to me by Vic Wood ,emagine picking up a bird hold it just enough so it doesnt get away

Just my view

Cheers

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#17

Re: Underhand grip question ???

Barry Irby

>I was not talking about the left hand with the underhanded grip. I don't see that as dangerous as it would be with the right hand. In the case I mentioned they think the chisel handle came up out of his right hand and hit him under the chin so hard it broke his neck. They did not actually know because he was working alone and found dead, but that is what the coroner said. His buddies said he usually kept his right hand under the tool.

Now I have to worry about my left hand too.

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#18

Re: It all depends upon what the user does in a ca

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>I suspect both guys weren't wearing face shields either.

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#19

Steven Antonucci

I know the one had goggles only

steve antonucci

>And that he did it with a skew because ot the underhand grip (happened at a club workshop I was running with 8 lathes and about 15 people, so I only saw the aftermath and secondhand version).

A faceshield is a must for any new turner, but it doesn't sold the root cause- bad technique. If you are standing in such a way that you are even capable of being struck with a tool or the wood you are cutting-well, there's your problem!

Add to it that marginal grip you can get with an underhand, fingertip hold, and well, 9...1.... AAAARRRGHHHHHH!...1

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#20

Steven Antonucci

And we couple it with safety tools (unsharpened)

steve antonucci

>oh, wait, new turners usually already own those :-)

S

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#21

Steven Antonucci

I can sorta see what you describe...

steve antonucci

>Had it happen, to a much lesser extent, once when I was still a NOOB. Sort of like an uppercut to the chin, and just hard enough that I never put the tool that close to my face again (I was hollowing).

New post coming later today

S

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#22

Re: I know the one had goggles only

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Well, I think a face shield is a must for turners of any experience. More experience does not enable people to dodge things coming off the lathe at high speed. I won't teach a workshop with more than six people without assistants, and I am not even wild about that many when I am by myself. I keep my own shop limited to three. And while you are right, a face shield is not a panacea, it is certainly a good start. There are extremely few operations I will do on the lathe without mine in place, and that is usually because I am talking to someone about what I am doing. Anyone who has seen me demo knows that I wear it, and that I take it off to speak. The last thing I need is to be lying on the floor helpless while some stranger decides what to do to try and save my life until the paramedics arrive.

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#23

Production Turning for spindles

John Cotten

>is a bit different. Turners will frequently grind special tools to speed up the process. Look at the beading tools that are pre-ground for making 3/8" beads for instance. Turners who do large ballesters usally have two wide tools preground left and right for making the balls on the top. Makes repeatablity more consistant and easier that pulling out callipers for every new cut. I also use some shearing cuts while doing spindle work, but there are alot of scraping tools out there for specific work and patterns.

Re: Underhand grip question ???

#24

Re: Production Turning for spindles

john lucas

>I wasn't thinking about production work although I am currently testing a duplicator and the cutters used to be scrapers. They aren't anymore, they are cutters.