Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Calling Ed Moore.....

Posts

Calling Ed Moore.....

#1

Calling Ed Moore.....

Barry Irby

>Hey Ed,

Over on the Message Forum Brian Newell posted about his new web site.

Go there and look at the pictures of his classes or workshops. there is a picture of him (or someone) using a bandsaw to make what appears to be a completely unsupported cut. Very casual gripe one piece. It would scare me to death and I think I would be lucky if it only cost me the piece of wood and a blade.

Here's the Link www.briannewellfurniture.com

Sam Maloof did stuff like this.

What do you think? Respect the Bandsaw????

Re: Calling Ed Moore.....

#2

Re: Calling Ed Moore.....

Ed Moore

>Barry, I absolutely agree with you. The cut was unsupported and his grip did nothing to help support it. That is an accident waiting to happen - although I hope it doesn't. No respect!

Respect the bandsaw, don't dare it,

Ed

Re: Calling Ed Moore.....

#3

Re: Calling Ed Moore.....

russ fairfield

>That is a staged photo and the saw isn't running. He could not be making that cut with just the light finger pressure that he is using to hold the wood.

Re: Calling Ed Moore.....

#4

Russ, I agree ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

>with your analysis. It is staged. The cut would be safer made upside down.

Why show unsafe cuts on your website if you want to teach how to make furniture?

Respect the bandsaw,

Ed

Re: Calling Ed Moore.....

#5

Staged photo ? ? ?

Doc Green

>Russ, what makes you think it is staged, other than the common-sense conclusion that such a cut could not be done successfully?

I enlarged the photo and no teeth show on the blade, even when the image is sharpened. Also the location of the sawdust next to the bottom of the piece makes it appear that the cut was in progress when the photo was made. Or, someone was very skillful in staging the photo.

Just curious, and it's no big deal. I've been afraid of a bandsaw for a long time, even before it became a popular topic, and the photo scares the crap out of me. I'm a big proponent of using bandsaw sleds, but that is another story. ~Doc

Re: Calling Ed Moore.....

#6

Dick Hines

Re: Russ, I agree ...

Dick Hines

>Staged or not this is a bad idea. Showing someone useing a band saw like just may cause some one that does not know how dangerous a bandsaw can be to loose some body part.

I would hope they take this picture off their web sight.

Re: Calling Ed Moore.....

#7

Re: Not Staged ? ? ?

russ fairfield

>If someone is actually making that cut, they are either totally insane, just plain stupid, or the wood is supported by something we can't see. Keep the 1st aid kit handy

Re: Calling Ed Moore.....

#8

Re: Calling Ed Moore.....

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>This is not just a foolish way to use a bandsaw, it has the endorsement of being in a section of the website labeled classes! In other words, someone reading this could think, well, this guy teaches this technique, so it must be legit. Most of the time in my shop, the only person who uses the bandsaw is me. I show safe techniques, and on occasion have let others use it, but one guy scared me so badly it has been a long time since I let anyone else use it. I can't afford someone lopping off their fingers or part of their arm because of poor technique.

Re: Calling Ed Moore.....

#9

That was my Point.....

Barry Irby

>Actually, it did not occur to me that the picture might be staged. How did they get the piece cut that far?

This appears to be a very bad technique to do, but that makes it even worse to demonstrate in a class. And to stage that shot to post that picture would be worse than that.

I hope nobody sees it and tries to make that cut.

Re: Calling Ed Moore.....

#10

Re: That was my Point.....

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>with our society being so suit prone he really is leaving himself open for trouble even if he is in Japan.

Re: Calling Ed Moore.....

#11

Sent him a note

Ed Moore in SW VA

>Barry, et al,

I went back to Brian's website and looked again, and then wrote him a private email. As a fellow woodworker I wish him well and do not want him or one of his students to have an accident. Hopefully he will think about that cut and reconsider his approach. He has talent, and I hope that he keeps his fingers.

Respect the bandsaw,

Ed

Re: Calling Ed Moore.....

#12

Re: Staged photo ? ? ?

Carole Valentine

>I agree, Doc. The sawdust pattern indicates that the cut is actually being made. I know one can do amazing things with Photoshop, but I don't think this is the case here. This guy is nuts...he's also young. Give him a couple more years of doing crap like this (or even another split second!) and see if he is missing any fingers.

Re: Calling Ed Moore.....

#13

Thanks.....

Barry Irby

>Perhaps I was unkind to use his picture this way. I too think his work looks good and wish him well.

Re: Calling Ed Moore.....

#14

Steven Antonucci

Is it just me?

steve antonucci

>The only picture I see that could potentially qualify as what is described is picture #5 out of the classes section, and that piece is supported on a sled?

Or has the picture been replaced?

Steve

Re: Calling Ed Moore.....

#16

Steven Antonucci

Certainly not the optimal way to do it

steve antonucci

>If I was going to make that type of a cut, I would try to flip the piece over, but more importantly I do it from the other side of the blade. I want my hands to have a clear path of escape that doesn't involve having to cross the path of the blade. If you make this cut from the right side, you can just step back if something goes wrong.

In addition, with the table tilted that way, the tendency is going to be for the wood to be pulled down, which will translate into it rotating. I'm guessing that the biggest danger here is going to be ruining the blade.

If I had no choice but to cut the wood in the manner shown, I would start the cut this way, and pull the wood from behind. There are no teeth on the back of the blade, so you can't get cut.

Now if you ever saw what Sam Maloof did, that would raise some hairs on your neck...

Steve