Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Eureka!

Posts

Eureka!

#1

Keith Tompkins

Eureka!

Keith Tompkins

>I did a bit of turning, comparing the two skew grinds in question in my previous post. I believe I've discovered WHY the two grinds behave quite differently. First, illustration "A" shows a conventional ground skew chisel. The dotted red line shows the relationship of the grind to the turning stock. I have concluded, since the double bevel is at an angle to the axis of the tool, raising or lowering the handle has NO EFFECT on the edge's approach angle of the tool. The top bevel will always be angling downward, no matter the tool handle height. Only when the handle is swung to an extreme angle, as in the image on the far left, will raising or lowering the handle have any effect on how the bevel approaches the cut. In this position the tool is useful only for a peeling cut, in small increments. The advantage of the skewed edge is lost. Illustration "B" shows a skew with only one bevel, notice the different top edge approach from "A".

The main factor here is the skewed edge....if both tools were ground straight across, they would behave exactly the same, as one would expect. The only difference would be tool handle position.

I think this shows a clear, distinct difference in the two grinds. What do you think?


img

Re: Eureka!

#2

If tool B is supposed to be a ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

>one-sided skew, then why not use it like a bedan and put the flat side down? Of course you would need two tools, each ground on one side, and I am talking about the "other" tool.

Respect the bandsaw,

Ed

Re: Eureka!

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: If tool B is supposed to be a ...

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Ed, I think the tool is more controllable with the bevel down, although I have tried it both ways. Don't necessarily need a matching tool...don't want to let the cat out of the bag!

Re: Eureka!

#4

Somehow I see a Henry Taylor ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

>spear point scraper turned over and used like a slanted two-edged bedan. I remembered an old Greenlee scraper like that in my old tools bucket, so I got it out this morning and sharpened it. Then I honed it on the edges and the top. I put some scrap between centers and made a cylinder about 1 1/4" in diameter. Then I took the pointed tool, rolled it onto its back (top)so that the two bevels were up, and made real sure that the point was way above where the tool touched the stock. Using the equivalent of the short point on a skew, I rolled some beads. Normally I use a detail gouge for this, but I found that using the tool "upside down" from its normal position made turning beads real easy to do, and it seemed easier than using a skew.

I shouldn't be surprised by the performance of this old tool, after all, Alan Batty uses a pyramid point tool with three faces to roll beads. Effectively, this pointed scraper is a point tool with one side more prominent than the other two. It was a 1/2" tool that I was using and I would have been more comfortable with a 3/4" or 1" tool of the same shape. Keeping the long point away from the cut is extremely important or a MAJOR catch will occur. Fortunately a catch didn't happen this time.

Respect the bandsaw,

Ed

Re: Eureka!

#5

ebd

Re: Eureka!

ebd

>Keith,

You said "I have concluded, since the double bevel is at an angle to the axis of the tool, raising or lowering the handle has NO EFFECT on the edge's approach angle of the tool."

IMO that can't possibly be right. 1st common sense - If you grind off the top of the A skew down to the axis you have The B skew, though thinner.

2nd - Geometry is precisely the same with respect to the bevel rubbing and the skews attack angle.

The only difference is if the A skew is ground at say 15 degrees on both sides and the B skew ground on a single side at the same 15 degrees the total angle of A will be twice that of B.

Re: Eureka!

#6

Spear point tool cutting a bead

Ed Moore in SW VA

>This picture is definitely staged because I was by myself and the tool is taped to the tool rest. My wife is a weaver and her towels are in real demand - so she is weaving and I must take my own pictures.

That said, the spear point tool did make the cuts to make all those beads, and in approximately that position. The handle was slightly higher than shown. I like the Sorby bedan, so this was a natural extension of using that tool.

I almost forgot to insert the picture ...

Respect the bandsaw,

Ed


img

Re: Eureka!

#7

Does this look like your cat?

charlie belden

>This is a Steve Knight Double bevel marking knife (he also did Left and Right Single Bevel Marking Knives). Behaving as many edged tools do, this one leaped off my workbench, managed to avoid the rubber mat in front of the bench and managed to find a bare patch of concrete to land - on its point. Then, obeying the edged tool code - it then bounced UNDER the bench - and came to rest next to something that stings, bites AND smells.

Theoretically, you could put two bevels on a bedan like this and end up with something that works sort of like a skew and sort of like a bedan.

Guesss right?


img

Re: Eureka!

#8

Ed beat me to it!

charlie belden

>

Re: Eureka!

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Eureka!

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Ed. I don't think so. If you grind the top off tool A, then you just ground away the top bevel as well. The included angle is no longer 35(or whatever it was), to achieve that, the remaining lower bevel must be reground much steeper to compensate for the removed top bevel. Then, the two tools would be the same. Tools A and B have the same included angles, one is ground only on the bottom, the other on both top and bottom. Study the image again, better yet, grind a single bevel skew and compare it to a regular skew.you will find they look different, and behave very differently in the way they remove material.

Re: Eureka!

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Spear point tool cutting a bead

Keith Tompkins

>Man, You guys are GOOD! Yes, that's one of the tool grinds I've been using. Ed Moore, try the same tool with the flat side up...you'll notice you can cut with the point. Also, try it straight into end grain, riding the spot between the two bevels. That's one clean cut.

The tool pictured will cut right or left, yet has to be ground only on one side. Cuts as cleanly (or cleaner) than a skew without the tendency to catch.

Re: Eureka!

#11

Re: Spear point tool cutting a bead

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>I've been using a spear point scraper like Ed's for years, flat side up. I use it on bowls and on spindles. I have it ground way back, so that it has a 30 deg bevel or something close. And yeah, going into the wood with just the tip gives a very good cut. But I haven't hung up my skews yet. ;-)

Re: Eureka!

#12

ebd

Re: Eureka!

ebd

>First, not Ed - it's ebd.

Second, I couldn't tell that the total angle is the same in both from your illustration. I made an incorrect assumption. Sorry. Perhaps a longitudinal section would have made the equality clear.

However, I'll stand by geometry - since both total angles are the same the geometry is the same with respect to the cutting edge. However the bevels dictate a different tool angle. The difference lies in the way you hold the tool to get the bevel to rub. The angle of the tool for A is shallower than for B with the bevel rubbing and with B used with the bevel up it would be held shallower than A.

It's the same as if you ground the bevel on a bowl gouge on the inside instead of the outside. Same geometry of bevel - much different tool angle.

Re: Eureka!

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Eureka!

Keith Tompkins

>Hey ebd, I must be dyslexic...looked like "edb". Sorry. Anyway,I was going to email you but your post didn't include an email address. Yes, the angles are the same as far as included angles go, but you can't approach the wood the same way with both tools. To answer (I think) your response, go to your lathe, and try to change the angle the skew approaches the wood by riding the bevel with a low handle, then a high handle.. you can't. The top bevel will always be angling down towards the stock. If the bevel rubs, the relationship stays the same...now, swing the handle to the side while raising and lowering the handle. NOW the bevels are square with the stock, and the relationship will change with the slightest up or down movement. I'd do that test with the lathe off, as it is extremely aggressive.