Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Interesting thought about art and craft

Posts

Interesting thought about art and craft

#1

Interesting thought about art and craft

Dick Coers

>I've been doing some reading lately on the creative process. I've been working with wood so long (both furniture and turning) that I am struggling with the fire needed to create. In the book I just finished, Art and Fear: Observations on the peril(and rewards)of artmaking, the authors have a discussion about the famous art versus craft debate. I would like to share a thought and get your opinions. I'll paraphrase from memory; "all art becomes craft at some point". So it warms me a bit to know that when the great artists find their voice, it then becomes a craft to perfect and perform for each object they create. This reinforces my thoughts about seeing the same basic work from the turners over the last two years at SOFA Chicago. Yeah, it's art, but after that aha moment, it may just be craft again. Any thoughts?

Re: Interesting thought about art and craft

#2

Re: Interesting thought about art and craft

Dan Oliphant

>Dick, as I'm sure you know well, this is a very touchy/feely topic. The use of the term "art", relating to wood work (flat or round) is, I believe, more of a marketing tool rather than a descriptive tool. An example, look at Robyn Horns' and John Jordans' work. They are both very good at what they do. Does pricing a piece at $60,000 make a piece more "art" than the piece priced at $5,000? My response is no. Now compare those pieces to someone without name recognition, is the "no name" piece less art (or craft)? Maybe not, but because Mr. no name does not have name recognition, his work is most likely called "craft". In my opinion, all these pieces are very creative, so assuming the persons that create the pieces are at the same skill levels, the terminology becomes a marketing tool, not a valid descriptive.

Just my thoughts on the matter.

Re: Interesting thought about art and craft

#3

Re: Interesting thought about art and craft

Barry L Elder

>The "Whackjob" (non-specific entity) was raised by Mama Wierd and Papa Wierd and lived with all the other Wierds. When Whackjob Wierd grew up he realized that he wasn't weird at all, he was rather common. So, just as spousal abuse becomes commonplace for those who grew up in an abusive household, maybe "art" becomes "craft" after it becomes "common". After all, didn't all start from the same place!? ;-)

Re: Interesting thought about art and craft

#4

Steven Antonucci

Art is the vision, craft is the execution

steve antonucci

>If we cannot see, what we make will not matter. If we cannot make, what we see is irrelevant.

In my mind, I have created enormous, perfectly proportioned turnings that are 1/1000" thick with elegant decoration. In my shop, I've make some pretty firewood...

Steve

Re: Interesting thought about art and craft

#5

Re: Interesting thought about art and craft

John Cotten

>Several years ago I was working on a magazine article with my friend Abe Harper, a professional turner who was a student of a very well known wood turner, Rude Osolnik. While sitting at lunch one day with Abe and Rude, this same subject came up when does craft become art. Rude's comment was simple. The biggest difference between what is art and what is craft; Self promotion, being able to sell your work, what the market well except, and being the first on the block to do it. Rude was definately an individual who understood the business end of art and craft.

I have seen some truly exceptional turnings over the years, some that truly required masterfull skill, nerve, an exceptional piece of wood or finish, and technique to execute, did that make it art? To the person who created it, maybe. Depends on whether it was an exercise in a personal challenge or a true vision to create art. To the person who appreciated the work, maybe, depends on whether they are a contempory or just someone who appreciates the work. To the person who bought it, yes. That person bought it because it was unique, it appealed to some inner need or appreciation of that persons creativity and vision.

Maybe my opinion is a bit commericalized, but I make a full time occupation of woodworking (I'm not brave enough to say I make a good living at it). Do I produce art? When the customer is willing to pay for that level of quality of material, perfection, and execution. Do I produce craft? Everyday. You simply cannot have art without craft. True quality art must be born of the vision, quality materials, skill, ability, and nerve to execute the work and the risk of failure. Craft on the other hand is frequently safe and easily repeatable.

The bottom line though, if you cannot sustain yourself and your daily obligations, then neither will survive for long.

Re: Interesting thought about art and craft

#6

Re: Art is the vision, craft is the execution

Barry Irby

>I see things that may be truly art, but they lack some sort of depth that holds my attention for more than a moment or two. Sometimes I am trying to figure out how I could make such a thing. Sometimes I think it would be easy. Often I wonder why anyone made it or why anyone would pay anything for it and wouldn't make it, even if I could. In my mind, the art holds my attention and draws me back to look again. The ones that appear easy for me to make are probably closer to craft.