Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Finishes and face to end grain transitions

Posts

Finishes and face to end grain transitions

#1

Finishes and face to end grain transitions

wilbur

>Over on the Hand Tools forum there has been a lot of discussion on prepping wood for finishing, and how to minimize the contrast between face grain and endgrain. One of the examples offered was the use of stain on some turned spindles that made up part of a headboard for a bed, and it was noted that the evenness of the finish on the turned parts was impressive given that there was end grain to face grain transitions all over those parts.

Now, I can't claim to be a finishing or turning guru, but I've been reading this forum and I've been at turning long enough to know what sorts of things turners usually gripe about. There are many discussions that complain about tearout, skew chisels, sanding, punky wood, Tormeks, selling at craft fairs, photography, juried contests, the AAW, etc. But I rarely see turners complain about keeping the finish even around their workpiece as the grain shifts from end grain to face grain and back.

Not only that, but this is not an issue I have had to think about or deal with with my turned projects at all, and like I said, I don't think I am particularly talented at turning or finishing. The contrast in finish between end grain and face grain on any of my bowls or spindle projects is much much much less than the contrast in finish on the corners of a dovetailed box that I made.

I have my own theories why this is so, but I thought I'd see what the turners here that actually know what they are doing had to say.

Re: Finishes and face to end grain transitions

#2

Re: Finishes and face to end grain transitions

russ fairfield

>Woodturners have long recognized that there is a difference in pentration of the finish between end-grain and flat-grain. This difference makes the end-grain a darker color. We call that difference "grain enhancement" when it looks good, and "blotch" when it doesn't.

Furniture makers have always recognized that sanding to a finer grit will restrict the penetration of dyes and finishes. To compensate, it is not unusual for them to sand the flat surfaces to no more than 180 grit, while sanding the ends of the table top to 400 or 600 grit. This reduces the penetration of the oil finish into the ends of the table, and it will be a better match to the top surface.

The most visible problem for a woodturner is the lighter band around the top of a bead or the botton of a cove in a spindle turning such as a weed-pot, candle stick, goblet, etc.

We can do the same as the furniture folks with differential sanding of the different grains. Sand the entire piece to 400 or 600 grit, and then go back and sand the flat grain areas with 180 grit. You should notice that this will level out the penetration of the finish and reduce the brightness of that lighter colored band around the piece.

Re: Finishes and face to end grain transitions

#3

Re: Finishes and face to end grain transitions

russ fairfield

>If you miss a spot, you can go back, after the 1st one has dried. and roughen the bright flat-grain area with the 180-grit and give it a 2nd coat

Re: Finishes and face to end grain transitions

#4

Re: Finishes and face to end grain transitions

karl

>Now there's a golden-nugget of a tip!

Thanks Russ

Re: Finishes and face to end grain transitions

#5

Re: Finishes and face to end grain transitions

Ron McKinley

>Excellent Russ, Thanks......Ron

Re: Finishes and face to end grain transitions

#6

Re: Finishes and face to end grain transitions

John Lucas

>I have to step in here because I do a lot of replacement parts for furniture. We don't run into the problem as bad as flat wood people because we don't stain our pieces. Staining shows this problem much worse.

Sanding the end grain areas more sounds good and it works great on flat things but on turned parts it's very difficult to sand just those areas because you have to feather the sanding from the endgrain portion to the flat grain. That's hard to do. A chair spindle for example that has multiple beads and coves is very hard to do. If your careful and have a lot of patience you can do it.

For staining turnings what I do is use an airbrush to add extra stain to the flat areas until it matches the end grain colors. For me it's 3 step process. Sand the endgrain that you can get to with at least 2 finer grits. Then you can try to seal the end grain with a sanding sealer using the air brush. Then apply the stain.

Re: Finishes and face to end grain transitions

#7

Re: Finishes and face to end grain transitions

Greg in Oshkosh

>There is another way we can control the application of stain (or in my case dye) If you apply with a brush or rag you over apply to the endgrain. It takes as much stain as it can hold out of the excess you are applying. The sidegrain doesn't take as much and so looks light in color. If you use a method that limits the amount of starin that the endgrain can absorb and doesn't wipe the excess off the sidegrain you can get them to match without differential sanding. The easiest way to do this is with an airbrush or spray gun. Our turning group has issues dyeing hollow forms that had little figure in that the sidegrain would appear to have a light ring around it from wiping off the excess dye. A spray application of dye fixes things up.