Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

More skew thoughts

Posts

More skew thoughts

#1

Keith Tompkins

More skew thoughts

Keith Tompkins

>I posted some skew thoughts recently, and this is a follow-up to John Lucas's reply about overall angles. The two tools illustrated in A and B both have the exact same nose angle, but with both tools held horizontal, the angle approach is much different. The red dotted line "A" shows the direction the top angle wants to cut, while the single bevel grind in "B" is horizontal. Same overall angle on each tool, yet they behave quite differently. To get the same cut from tool "A" as with tool "B", the handle will have to be lowered to the red line "B". Perhaps this partially explains the difficulties many have in mastering the skew chisel, as the top bevel wants to pull the tool into the wood, resulting in a catch. This effect is not limited to turners: a bench chisel or drawknife behaves quite differently when used bevel up or bevel down. Invert the blade in a plane or spokeshave....uggh.


img

Re: More skew thoughts

#2

maybe I'm missing the point... (pun intended)

GaryG in MD

>Keith,

I have to admit that I don't understand what you're getting at.

As I see it, it's not the tool, it's the user. I have included a modified image of your drawing. For a given total included angle, it doesn't have anything to do with the way the shaft and handle are connected to the cutting tip -- its the angle of presentation of the cutting tip to the wood. This is true for all the tools we use -- there's nothing new there. We don't use skews flat on the rest like that anyway -- we adjust the angle of the shaft and handle so the the cutting tip does what we want it to do. The only difference between the two tools in your drawing is the angle at which the handle is held to get a safe, clean cut. Otherwise, it seems to me that they are the same. Ovals and curved edges, etc., make a real difference, but I can't see any utility here. Please tell me what I'm missing. ...Gary


img

Re: More skew thoughts

#3

Re: maybe I'm missing the point... (pun intended)

John Lucas

>Keith I think I see what you say but I have to agree with Gary. You would not use those two tools the same way. I have a bedan that has the same angle as my skew and I have more trouble using it. I think it's because I don't use it enough to find the proper height of the tool rest to make the most efficient use of the tool. Maybe I should use it more then I would figure it out.

To use your analogy of the draw knife, I use it both ways. It does cut differently in that it's might be more controllable one way than the other. I have 3 drawknives and 2 of them cut better with bevel up and one works better bevel down.

Re: More skew thoughts

#4

Re: More skew thoughts

russ fairfield

>In theory it shouldn't make any difference, but in reality it does. The single bevel will cut different from that with the double bevel, and you might even find it easier to use. Don't believe me? Try it.

It may be a matter of perception, how we hold the tool, or how we see it; but the difference is real.

Re: More skew thoughts

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: maybe I'm missing the point... (pun intended)

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Gary, Your modified pic shows exactly what I was trying to say...Many, if not most, turners try to plane across the top of a cylinder with a high tool rest with a skew...it's the only cut they will even attempt with the tool. Many sharpen their skews with an even blunter cutting edge than I showed, making the problem worse, even if presenting the tool with a lower handle. In actual useage, the tool handle is raised while simultaneously rolled, while the handle is swung, form a bead....the minute the very tip leaves the cut, the tool spirals out of control. The TOP bevel, now with an entirely different geometry, no longer tangent to the surface, pulls the tool aggressively into the cut. The same cut with a spindle gouge doesn't tend to catch and spiral, as the relationship of the flute remains constant throughout the cut.

Re: More skew thoughts

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: maybe I'm missing the point... (pun intended)

Keith Tompkins

>HI John, The skew is the only turning tool I can think of with a double bevel. The only reason I can think of is because the tool can be used either way; to cut to the right, and to cut to the left. But, does the double bevel improve performance, or is it simply a compromise that results in a miserable tool to master? Imagine taking a gouge, and grinding a bevel on the inside as well as the outside...sort of an incannel gouge. It may cut, but not the way it used to...I'll bet you won't like it. If you think about it, how many turners really can use the skew chisel...in a real-life, a catch will ruin the turning, situation? Not many. What would happen if a skew were ground with only ONE bevel? In an attempt to improve upon the skew, I will admit to doing just that, in addition to several other ideas. With impressive results....but, would a turner need TWO skews? ....maybe not; I may have something up my sleeve.

Re: More skew thoughts

#7

Re: maybe I'm missing the point... (pun intended)

GaryG in MD

>Keith,

I think Russ' comment about "perception" is important.

One could argue that if the steel at the cutting edge has the same shape and angle, the same results should be obtained. This isn't quite true because the force will be applied longitudinally along the axis of the shaft, and these are in different directions. It can be noted, however, from looking at my modified figure (B), that this should make the traditional skew safer than the one-sided version because the direction of the force along the axis is more out of the wood.

It seems to me to be a matter of education. Just as with a gouge, one should be taught proper use of the tool based on the position and angle of the cutting tip -- the tool rest and handle are there to make that happen, not as an end unto themselves. If the turner is positioning the handle and tool rest by rote, without regard to the effect on the cutting tip, then there's going to be a big difference -- and problems.

Finally, there are the aspects of vision and comfort. In other words, when the cutting tip is in the correct position and angle, are the tool rest and handle in a logical and comfortable position -- in other words, in a position that looks right and feels right? A lot of this has to do with education and habits, not with the steel and physics.

Vive la diff�rence, Gary

Re: More skew thoughts

#8

Re: maybe I'm missing the point... (pun intended)

russ fairfield

>Keith,

I was using a single bevel skew chisel back in the 1960's when I was working my way through college by turning spindles for ship wheels and porches. I use a single bevel skew to make all all of the cuts from right to left, swap ends in the lathe and cut the other side from the same direction. Sometimes I had to use the LH skew to clean up a mismatch. Worked for me.

Re: More skew thoughts

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: maybe I'm missing the point... (pun intended)

Keith Tompkins

>Gary, when you get a minute, grind an old tool into a single-bevel skew. It behaves completely different than a conventional skew...you will be pleasantly surprised, I think. On very wild grain, the single bevel wins, hands down. I think it's because the upper bevel on a reqular skew is still angling downward into the wood, no matter how it's held, and lifts the grain when it changes direction.

I think the skew is one of those tools we feel we must learn; it's a rite of passage, so to speak. I think it's possible to build a better mousetrap.

Re: More skew thoughts

#10

Re: More skew thoughts

Barry L Elder

>It would seem to me that a single bevel skew has more "meat" or "weight" or "metal" behind the cutting edge making it more stable as compared to a double bevel skew which will probably have more tendency to vibrate or flex than the tool with more metal.

Re: More skew thoughts

#11

Re: More skew thoughts *LINK*

charlie belden

>As someone who started out using a small (1/2"), short handled skew , and thinking it was to be used like a bench chisel or a slanted edge (skewed) pairing chisel, I got myself in a LOT of trouble - trying to do what I now know is a planing cut - using the entire cutting edge, the tool resting on a makeshift tool rest set at centerline (I started turning on a small UniMat metal lathe and got tired of trying to Etch-A-Sketching curved profiles with the X and Y wheels).

Having NO idea of how turning tools were supposed to be used (tool firmly on the tool rest, bevel contacting the wood, handle lifted to bring the cutting edge in contact with the wood, raising the handle to make the cut) - I stabbed and poked, scraped and scratch the spinning wood. I did most of the wood removal - with sandpaper.

Then I ran into a guy at a woodworking show who was an experienced turner and he invited me over to show me how he a)shaped his skews cutting edge to a curve, b) how to sharpen the curved edge skew and c) how he uses one to cut Vs, beads, coves and planing cuts.

Some time on a 3/4" dowel with the improved skew - and having a much better idea of how the tool is used for various types of cuts, I quickly got to where I could confidently cut Vs and beads and coves - and make planing cuts.

That little skew became, and still is, my favorite turning tool and because we're now really good friends, I can get it to practically sing. It cuts AND scrapes - the skew doesn't care.

Then I got a BOWL GOUGE - with a fairly long fingernail grind. Like the skew, I had a total misunderstanding of how it SHOULD be used and tried to use it like I would a skew. So when I presented it to the wood, bevel rubbing - with the flute facing straight up - and rasied the handle to engage the edge - BIG MISTAKE! The tip cut into the wood - and both sides of the fingernail followed. The initial point of contact bite out of the wood instantly became a big honking chomp out of the wood and got worse in an instant.

So I turned the flute 90s - to the left - to use the left cutting edge of the fingernail grind. Also a big mistake.

Then a friend showed me how a bowl gouge, or a spindle gouge for that matter, SHOULD be used - on the outside of a piece. Like the skew, the initiation of the cut is the twitchy part - more so with a bowl or spindle gouge than with a skew - for me. The cut is begun with the very tip of the curve on the fingernail grind and like the skew - if you get it aimed the wrong way - it goes where you don't want it to go.

Now I'm making friends with my bowl and spindle gouge. And when I unintnetionally tried to use either like I work with my old friend the skew - they remind me - sometimes forcefully, that they are NOT a skew. It's very much like calling your NEW girlfriend by your OLD girlfriend's name - or visa versa.

Long story short - and I think I noted this in an earlier thread - using Tool A like Tool B works - if they're a bowl gouge and a spindle gouge works. But if Tool A is a bowl or spindle gouge and Tool B is a skew - expect unpleasant surprises.

The point of this rambling post - familiarity with how to use a bowl or spindle gouge and make learning to use a skew trickier - and visa versa. Going from one to the other, at least initially, requires that you reset your brain and body to the new tool - or muscle memory will bit you in the back of your front.


skew or bedan cuts

Re: More skew thoughts

#12

Re: maybe I'm missing the point... (pun intended)

GaryG in MD

>Keith, OK, I hear you. You've done a lot more skew work than I have. As a physicist though, I'm curious -- have you actually tried using the skew with the handle down so the two sides of the cutting tip are in the same position as for the one-sided tool (as in my modified figure B)? What happens? I would think that, if anything, it would cut less, because the force is angled up, away from the wood. I'm not talking about using it as in your Figure A -- that's clearly a very different case. The relative performance for the two parts of my Figure B is what intrigues me. ...Gary

Re: More skew thoughts

#13

Re: More skew thoughts

john lucas

>How could a single bevel have more metal than a double bevel if they are both ground to the same angle. The only difference is way the angles at the fat side of the bevel intersect the shaft. The tip angle will be the same and the metal thickness the same. At least I think, again I'm not an engineer but I sure don't see how it works the other way. :)

Re: More skew thoughts

#14

Re: maybe I'm missing the point... (pun intended)

john lucas

>Keith If I have time tonight I'm going to spend some time with both the bedan and skew. I still don't see how the angle at the tip will affect how it cuts. The bevel controls the cut and whether or not it pulls into the wood not how it's oriented on the end of the shaft. Perhaps this would be true on a really short shaft and handle where the leverage becomes a problem.

I think there is much more geometry going on here. For example we all angle the skew a little. This changes the cutting angle like angling a hand plane to change it's cutting angle. That and grain direction and the amount of edge actually doing the cutting probably have more affect on whether it lifts grain.

I wish I had tons of time to experiment but this time of the year I run from daylight to dark trying to get everything done. I worked until 11 last night and finished some of the things so I'll have some Me time tonight.

Re: More skew thoughts

#15

Re: More skew thoughts

Barry L Elder

>My interpretation, John, is that when you grind a second bevel, you are removing part of the mass. With one bevel that mass remains in place. I'm not an engineer either, just an observer.

Re: More skew thoughts

#16

Re: More skew thoughts

John Lucas

>Barry I would agree if the total angle wasn't the same. However if you have a 35 degree angle when measured from one side to the other it doesn't matter if you grind both sides or only one side. You still have 35 degrees where the two planes intersect. Now I can agree that if you hollow grind then the one with only one side ground would have more metal. That's why I use an 8" wheel instead of 6". In theory anyway an 8" hollow grind will leave more metal than a 6". Of course we are talking just a few thousandths of an inch here.

Re: More skew thoughts

#17

Re: More skew thoughts

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>I'll tell you all what I think. If people spent as much time practicing with their tool (after some competent instruction) as they did posting on internet boards, we would all be masters of the skew. When I started out with my skew, I got bone jarring, hair raising catches. I ruined wood, I walked out the door of the shop frustrated, and I became highly skilled at throwing the skew and sticking it in the wood door like a circus act knife thrower. But I went back and tried again. I examined what I was doing and how I was doing it. And what do you know, but my tool control started to improve!

Now people watch me use a skew, and they say things like, "Oh, you're so good with that", and, "You make that look so easy. I wish I could turn like that." The answer is, you can turn like that, with instruction, and practice. But many people want a new tool. Many people think that the skill is in the tool, not in the hands wielding the tool. This malady is not peculiar to turning. I see it in photography and target shooting, and I hear it is endemic in golf too. ;-) As I say when I teach, it is not the tool, it is the loose nut on the handle that makes all the difference. A person who practices can cut with just about any tool placed in his or her hands. A person who does not practice is not going to fare so well.

Re: More skew thoughts

#18

Re: More skew thoughts

John Lucas

>Bill Couldn't agree more except I can't turn while at work. I can sometimes respond to questions while I'm downloading photos at work because there is a considerable time delay when you have to download 250 or more photos.

Now if you could work out a way for me to bring my lathe to work so I could turn while downloading I would definitely improve my skill.

Re: More skew thoughts

#19

Bedan has two bevels, but one is really long

jerhall------WebKitFormBoundaryS55vZAaXJsx+Qg1Q

>Great discussion. I turned tops with a sharp roofers hatchet a few times and was surprised and delighted at what I learned about the basics of a cutting tool.

In using the bedan I don't think of it having 1 bevel, but 2 bevels, with one much longer than the other. A long bevel is nice. I use the bedan up or down (depending,) but most times it is sweet to have the longer bevel down.

So with a bench chisel. Long bevel down it pares beautifully with the grain, or across the grain for tenons. Because you index easily on a long bevel. the wood doesn't care which bevel is down. At the instant of cut it looks the same. It is about ease of tool control.

It seems to me most of this discussion is about tool presentation, indexing the tool, control, and what is a comfortable body position. A long bevel (eg with a "single" bevel) is handy. As John says, it all comes down to the bevel guiding the cut.

With a skew grind and going left or right it feels symmetric and familiar each way with 2 equally ground bevels. But it doesn't mean you can't grind a Bedan style at an angle, and use it successfully in many situations.

I thinks that in all of this, as in carving, included angle, grain direction and wood nature rules, more than bevel style. We just have to be willing to adapt our body and use our muscle memory.

Re: More skew thoughts

#20

Re: More skew thoughts

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>John, this isn't aimed at you, or anyone in particular. It is a general observation. I spend my recreational time on gun boards, and do a lot of shooting. When I started with a pistol, I could barely hit the broad side of a barn while standing inside of it! Now, if I get groups larger than my fist at 15 yds, I know I need more practice. But I see guys arguing about the type of gun, what sights are on it, etc - everything but range time!

And you know photographers. How in the world can someone buy an auto everything camera and still get out of focus, poorly exposed shots!?! I don't even address composition and lighting. It is lack of familiarity with the tool at hand. A new gun or a new camera can help, but it is not a panacea, just like a new lathe tool is not.

Re: More skew thoughts

#21

Re:So Keith, are you now inventing .....

JamieD

>... a skewbedan, or is it a bedanskew? After taking a class with Jean Francois Escoulen and his French bedans this summer, I am still amazed how a skilled turner can make a single tool do so many cutting operations, and as Bill stated, it's the hand that guides the tool that matters most.

Re: More skew thoughts

#22

Keith Tompkins

Re:So Keith, are you now inventing .....

Keith Tompkins

>You're close, Jamie. real close :)