Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

question on drying with ethanol

Posts

question on drying with ethanol

#1

question on drying with ethanol

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Long story, but I need to have some fundamental understanding of how this process works. Does anyone know, or if not, if I knew the benefits I could figure it out. Compared to simply air drying is it faster, result in less cracking/shrinkage, or what else?

Re: question on drying with ethanol

#2

Ric Taylor

Re: question on drying with ethanol

Ric Taylor

>Bill,

Look in the articles section for the article by Dave Smith. He developed the whole process.

Ric

Re: question on drying with ethanol

#3

JL

Re: question on drying with ethanol

JL

>The basic theory is that the water goes into solution with the ethanol. The ethanol "draws out" the water from within the wood and displaces it to some degree.

When you remove your piece from the ethanol solution, the bound (and free) water has been partial replaced by the ethanol. As the ethanol has a vapor pressure of 40 mm hg at 19 C, it evaporates reasonably quickly. You don't have too much water left behind and it evaporates also. So figure you can get rid of a lot of water a bit faster.

I wonder if a large vacuum chamber would work or if it would be too fast and violent.

Re: question on drying with ethanol

#4

Dick Hines

Re: question on drying with ethanol

Dick Hines

>I don't think ethanol is the sutff David ues. I know I don't use it unless denatured alcohol is the same thing. I have neen useing DNA for a few years and like the results I get. WhenI started useing it the price was $10.95 per gal. I got some last week and it is up to $15.95 per gal.

I think ethanol is poison.

Re: question on drying with ethanol

#5

nope... Re: question on drying with ethanol

GaryG in MD

>Dick, Every liquor store around is full of ethanol (=ethyl alcohol = "grain alcohol"). It's perfectly drinkable, in proper dilution, etc. ;-) It's methanol (methyl alcohol = "wood alcohol") that is poisonous. DNA is a "safe" alcohol that has been "denatured" (poisoned) by adding a percentage of methanol to it, so people won't drink it. ...Gary

Re: question on drying with ethanol

#6

Re: question on drying with ethanol

GaryG in MD

>Bill,

You have been given good info here about looking up Dave Smith's approach and the basics of how the chemical works. OTOH, I believe there's more to it than that. Plunking your roughouts in DNA will make them crack like crazy if you don't follow the instructions! If you read Dave's publications carefully, you will see that he is ADAMANT about covering the outsides of the pieces with newspaper and leaving the insides open to air after the immersion. What this supposedly/apparently does is let the inside dry faster than the outside and create a compression force that holds the piece together (in effect, stops it from cracking). This is a good procedure to follow, whether or not you use alcohol. The alcohol just makes the drying process a little faster.

There may be a difference of opinion about whether the DNA process results in a lower percentage of cracking. I personally do not believe that it does -- assuming you handle the roughouts properly. The goal is to reduce the differential moisture content -- this can be done very quickly with DNA or slowly by maintaining a proper local environment (drying cabinet, brown paper bag, etc.) I will generally spray on a little shellac to slow the drying (also helps to see tool marks) and use brown paper bags. If I'm worried about a piece, I will wrap the outside in brown paper, but not the inside, before I put it into another brown paper bag. I've had excellent results with this procedure.

I tried DNA but didn't care for the logistics or expense. IMO, it's not necessary. I have plenty of roughouts backed up and have no need to rush one thru the pipeline.

If you do it, wear nitrile gloves -- the DNA will do the same thing to your skin that it does to the wood. ...Gary

Re: question on drying with ethanol

#7

Re: OT - sort of - Digital camera recommendation? *LINK*

Fred Holder--MW

>I had posted results on my alcohol drying on

the rec.crafts.woodturning

newsgroup, which triggered off

considerable discussion. I was severely

ridiculed by a few who assured

me that there was no way in

which this could work and that it

was a total farce.

As a result, I took another section

of Walnut Tree Root and

cut it in half. I turned two bowls

out of the two halves. Each had a

wall thickness of 1/2� and diameters

of less than 5�. I soaked one

in fresh denatured alcohol for two

hours and wrapped both in brown

grocery sack leaving the hollowed

part of the bowl open to the air.I was very surprised

at how similar the weight loss

ran. I�m presenting the results here

for your information:

Date Alcohol Soaked Unsoaked

5-17 225 grams 215 grams

5-18 200 grams 205 grams

5-19 165 grams 170 grams

5-20 150 grams 154 grams

5-21 125 grams 140 grams

5-22 115 grams 125 grams

5-23 105 grams 115 grams

5-24 100 grams 105 grams

5-25 100 grams 100 grams

5-26 95 grams 95 grams

In nine days the alcohol soaked

bowl lost 58 percent of its original

weight and the unsoaked bowl had

lost only 56 percent of its original

weight. The percentage of weight loss

each day was higher for the alcohol

soaked bowl than for the unsoaked

bowl. However, it was not as great

as I had expected.

In most of our previous tests

using alcohol, virtually all of them

had quit losing weight after seven

days, there was minimal warpage,

and no cracking in any of the pieces,

even madrone.

Dave Smith reports similar results,

but I don�t recall if he did any

side by side tests of the same wood

as I did in this second test. Dave said

with fresh alcohol, the wood was almost

always dry within seven days.

This has been our experience also.

In the first test presented here,

we used alcohol that had been used

several times in the past and was

likely fairly deluted with water from

the wood that had been soaked in it.

This last test used fresh alcohol and

the soak period was only two hours.

I hope this information will be

of use to some of our readers. I recommend

you give it a try on your

next wet turned piece. We used Denatured

Alcohol, so don�t drink the

stuff!!

This material was extracted from my article in the July 2006 issue of More Woodturning magazine. If any of you wish to see the entire article e-mail me and I'll send you a PDF of the story.


More Woodturning web site

Re: question on drying with ethanol

#8

Drying wood with alcohol *LINK*

Fred Holder--MW

>Hello all,

For some reason my post on this subject got posted under a title on Digital Cameras.


More Woodturning web site

Re: question on drying with ethanol

#9

Think EtOH/water azeotrope

BOB HAINES

>

Re: question on drying with ethanol

#10

Re: question on drying with ethanol

russ fairfield

>It has always been my experience that, if we were to take the same care in wrapping, inspecting, and weighing on a daily basis with every piece of wood, that we wouldn't need the alcohol. Given the same care and treatment, the only difference should be that the one soaked in the alcohol may dry at a faster rate.

Re: question on drying with ethanol

#11

Re: question on drying with ethanol

Barry L Elder

>I quit using denatured alcohol because too many of our tropical woods cracked like crazy while soaking. Also, I didn't see any meaningful difference in drying time or warping in many woods that I use. Still have 2 or 3 gallons in a 5 gallon can waiting for someone to take.

Re: question on drying with ethanol

#12

The trick...

GaryG in MD

>with those tropical woods to reduce warpage and cracking is to BOIL them. Our friends Jim King and Steve Russell have discussed this procedure in great detail.

See, for example,

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/archives_turning.pl?read=110857&v1=e2vrt43&v2=pneumatic+nailer&v4=belt+sander&v5=e2vrt43

and

http://www.woodturningvideosplus.com/boiling-green-wood.html

...Gary

Re: question on drying with ethanol

#13

Re: The trick...

Barry L Elder

>Yup! Boiling is probably the answer as soon as I can find a retired turkey fryer.

Re: question on drying with ethanol

#14

Ric Taylor

Re: question on drying with ethanol

Ric Taylor

>All I can say is that I follow Dave Smith's instructions to the letter, except that I soak the rough-turned pieces for at least two weeks instead of the short time that Dave recommends. The only reason I do that is because it is usually at least two weeks between my turning sessions. I just can't get out to the garage any more frequently.

The results of my experience are that cracking and warping in various types of wood are reduced by about 80 percent.

Recently my friend and I cut book-matched platter blanks out of a large pecan crotch. They were identical, split apart face to face. I used the alcohol method on my rough-turned 16" blank and it only warped 1/8". The twin blank that my friend air-dried warped like a potato chip and was unusable.

Ric

Re: question on drying with ethanol

#15

good to know...

GaryG in MD

>I'm very glad to hear it. Boiling is easy in concept but logistically unappealing, unless you have a spare turkey roaster around. ...Gary