Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Question on Epoxy? (long)

Posts

Question on Epoxy? (long)

#1

Question on Epoxy? (long)

Barry Irby

>I recently posted on making a funnel out of a 16" walnut bowl blank and trying to recover it. After I cut the bottom out of it, I tried to cut it in half and remove some punky wood from one end and cracks from the other. I cut two three inch wide pieces and glued the two sections back to them with Loctite epoxy from the borg. Two of the four joints pulled up nicely but the other two had gaps maybe as thick as a piece of paper. I counted on the epoxy to fill and hold these gaps. I put the bowl back on the lathe to true up the bottom. The joints failed. I cleaned them up and fitted them better and bought some fresh epoxy and glued them again. Then one of the other joints failed. I cleaned it and glued it. To be sure it did not fail again, I inserted some splines into the bowl through the blocks and glued them in with Titebond. This has been a saga and it reveals that I refused to throw this bowl away when I should have.

So, the question is, does epoxy really fill gaps and if so does it hold well enough to take the stress of turning? (This stuff was a few months old.)

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

#2

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

Chuck Engstrom

>Hi Barry -- I'm not sure I have a real answer to your problem but I'll offer a couple of thoughts to ponder.

First, the age of the epoxy is virtually irrelevant. Shelf life is just about indefinite, and I continue to use stuff given to me over twenty years ago.

Mixing proportion is important, of course, and though none of us can match lab-spec accuracy, good measuring does help, and bad measuring will sometimes leave you with weak results. The first epoxy I ever mixed, in 1967, is probably still as tacky as it stayed all that summer, and I always figured that somehow I went wrong on measurement.

Epoxy does take more time to fully cure than appearances suggest. Overnight cure may be "hard" but not yet ultimate strength.

Epoxy all by itself is great stuff but may benefit, in many applications, from adding different fillers which add to its qualities and may even add strength -- to make an extreme example, you wouldn't build a boat out of pure clear epoxy alone without putting in fiberglass to hold it all together.

Hope this is some food for thought.

Best--

Chuck

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

#3

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

John Lucas

>I can't answer why your joint failed. I've been using System 3 slow set epoxy and it is very strong by itself. I've turned things from just the epoxy. I've used epoxy to bond glue blocks to the bowls. When I use yellow glue I make a really flat gap free joint. When I use epoxy I don't worry about the gap. I haven't had a failure yet.

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

#4

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Barry,

Adding to Chuck comments, epoxy needs heat, although it is exothermic, if it is not at certain temperature it won't set or it will very slowly, the initial heat also acts as a catalist.

The epoxies from the borg, I don't know, get epoxy from a marina or place that caters to boat builders, although I agree that the old epoxies had a very long life, the new ones have less. I like the West System (Gougeon Bros) because it comes with a set of pumps, so there is no guessing, then as soon as I mix it, I warm it up with a light bulb and keep on stirring.

If the wood is cold or moist, that is another avenue for failure, all the wood and the epoxy needs to be warm, ideally at the same temperature, the higher will make it set faster. It really wants to be at 85F.

If you need to fill gaps, warm epoxy goes right into the wood which is good but nothing remains on the gap, so you need to ad a thickener, I like colloidal silica, after coating the matching surfaces with straight epoxy, keep adding small amounts and stirring until it is the consistency of mayonnaise, or until you get thick enough that if you invert the container, it will not even sag.

Hope this helps

Jorge

PS, clean up with white vinegar, it works as well as acetone, but is cheaper and a lot easier to breathe.

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

#5

An execllent resource *LINK*

David Belser

>Barry - This link is to the System Three Epoxy book. It is a great book all about epoxy and it's uses. The book is directed at boat builders but has lots of good info about epoxy.

I would think that most epoxy "glues" are not great at gap filling unless the specifically state so (ie. the manufacture has added a filler). Epoxy is an exothermic reaction and the epoxy gets quite runny (tends to run out of gaps) as it heats up - just before it gels. After it gels, the chemical reaction continues but slows considerably because the molecules aren't moving around as much. Full strength can take more than 24hr. Temperature is very important with gel time and maybe curing.

For small batches, an accurate digital scale is quite useful.

Of course the stuff sold in paired tubes in the box stores is designed to be easy and fool proof. I would mix most of it as one batch to get close to the right amounts.

All in all, sounds like you should have just tossed the bowl at the first breakup :)

- Dave


The Epoxy Book

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

#6

Ric Taylor

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

Ric Taylor

>Barry,

You didn't say, but are you sure that the epoxy flowed into the gap? Sometimes it just lays on top of the surface without actually flowing into the gap. I use a toothpick to make sure the epoxy has flowed down in between the surfaces, and the same applies to gap-filling super glue.

Ric

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

#7

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

Barry L Elder

>I use some two-part slow curing epoxy I bought from Sewell Hardware about 25 or 30 years ago after a recommendation from an engineer at NASA. It is used on spacecraft and by aircraft manufacturers. I have used it on golf clubs, custom fishing rods, and woodturning for repair and assembly. It does not reach full strength for 7 days in our region. It is a paste and I measure it out with cheap measuring spoons and mix it for 3 or 4 minutes. It will fill any gap and if mixed with the dust of the wood you are repairing, it will tend to assume that color (within reason). Normally dries to a dull yellow-tan color. No since in giving the name since it is so old, but like Jorge said, you can get good epoxy from most any boatyard. If at any time you need quality products, stay away from the BORG.

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

#8

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

Jesper, Denmark

>The epoxy only fills gaps if you put som filler into the epoxy. If you really want a strong epoxy joint, that needs to fill gaps, add fibreglass or some other fibre. The strength is from glueing fibre to fibre and fibre to wood. Not the unthickened epoxy itself. Epoxy is a glue - not a structural member. It is strong in shear, not tension.

Please check to see if the failure was in the glue - or in the punky wood next to the glue.

My guess is the latter, so it was maybe not really a glue question?

I did answer �our other epoxy questions on the main board too.

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

#9

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

russ fairfield

>I have to ask the question. Is this a 2-part epoxy? I associate Loctite with the 1-part red or blue anerobic epoxies used for locking threads and seating bearings. To my knowledge the only 2-part epoxy they make is the quick mix that is labeled as a 1-minute adhesive. Is this what you used? If it is, I sincerely doubt that you can work fast enough to spread the adhesive and get the pieces together to make a good joint with a 1-minute adhesive. These faster glues are also poor gap fillers.

Any of the 30-minmute epoxies from the same big box store would be better than the ocktite product.

System-3 makes a 30 minute epoxy that would be good for your application. Their 5-minute is also an encellent adhesive with good gap filling abilities if you can work fast enough to use it. Woodcraft stores carry both of them.

For those who are having problems with the epoxy aging and getting lumpy in the tubes, you are just coming off from a long hot summer, and epoxies don't store well in the heat. They will keep much better if stored in the house where the AC keeps the temperature below 75F.

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

#10

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

Barry Irby

>Ric, I coated both surfaces making sure they were wet and liberally coated. I had squeeze out on both sides. I am beginning to to think it may have been too cold. It was room temp, but probably about 65 degrees.

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

#11

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

Barry Irby

>The glue failed. Both sides were still coated. Only one tiny piece of wood separated, and that probably had a crack in it to start with. I am suspicious the joint drained out.

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

#12

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

Barry Irby

>Russ this was two part epoxy labeled Loctite. Who knows who actually made it. Came from Lowes. They also sell the same or similar stuff in the little double syringes. In the syringes they have 5 minute and one hour. In the larger containers they have the One Hour only. At least I have not seen the 5 minute stuff in the larger size. I tried to be accurate measuring them out but leaned a little toward excess hardener. Maybe I'll go fetch the rest of it back out of the trash.

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

#13

Epoxy as filler

Ray

>Here is some West systems with filler, colored yellow about 1/8+" wide. Notice that the center pieces are cross grained to the background.

Ray


img

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

#14

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

Jesper, Denmark

>Then you definitely needed fillers like colloidal silica to control viscosity and some fibre to add strength.

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

#15

Re: Question on Epoxy? (long)

Fog Tanner

>Barry.

I am using epoxy that is several years old with no problems. I use it for both filling gaps and joining surfaces. When filling gaps, it is stronger if you add a filler. The filler helps by reducing the span that the epoxy must make. You effectively glue the filler together and glue it to the mating surfaces. I normally use coffee, but have used wood chips and/or sawdust in wood turning. I have used carbon fiber, chopped glass, ground glass, phenolic, glass bubbles, and other materials for higher stress applications (i.e. nonturning). If you are looking for strength then about 70/30 epoxy to filler. If cosmetic 50/50, 40/60, 30/70 epoxy to filler.

You also didn't say how long you are letting the epoxy cure, but it sounds like hours or overnight. The pot life or working time may be 30 to 60 minutes, with the set time normally being 4-12 hours. But the cure time is still seven days. The joint will still move after sitting overnight. You can handle it, but placing a stress on it is asking a lot. If I am working on something that is subject to a lot of stress, then I glue up the joint and come back in a week. If cosmetic, 24-36 hours depending on the joint, glue, temp, and rush I am in. If its really cosmetic and I am using 5 minute epoxy w/filler, then over night.

When working with deep cracks that I am trying to fill, I will place epoxy in and on the crack and use a heat gun to thin it out - repeating until it is filled. This affects the working time, but not the cure time. These are normally more the cosmetic types. For stress bearing joints, the best is still a tight fitting joint or a high strength filler to fill the gap.

Fog