Re: Thoughts on the skew
charlie belden
>Keith:
If how you think a tool is to be used is based on the tool you're most familiar with, which I'm guessing is a spindle gouge or a bowl gouge, you may be starting off in the wrong direction from the get go.
I had the same problem with a spindle gouge, having learned to use the skew first - a curved cutting edge skew specifically - for EVERYTHING - roughing, V grooves, beads, coves, ogees and hollowing - plates, bowls, lidded boxes, finials - everything - except for parting off. Shear cuts or scraping cuts into end grain or side grain cuts - all done with a skew.
Then I tried to use a fingernail grind bowl gouge like I use a skew - and horrible things happened. Same thing with a fingernail grind spindle gouge. Things would go to hell in a handbasket as soon as I rocked the tool on it's rubbing bevel and made contact with the wood with the cutting edge. It was like trying to balance a marble on the tip of a pin. With a skew, you've got a straight line cutting edge. With a fingernail grind you've got TWO - changing direction - cutting edges on either side of the rounded tip. A slight twist of the wrist and the cut can get really aggressive really quickly.
Unlike a skew, which you can begin a groove with any part of the straight line of the cutting edge (looking down on the tool from above), the fingernail grind spindle or bowl gouge CAN cut anywhere along that curved fingernail grind cutting edge - and contact of that long constantly changing radius cutting edge with the far side of the cut you're trying to make - using a skew technique - gets you in trouble INSTANTLY.
The key point to note is the attempt to use a bowl or spindle gouge like a skew - or bedan. Yes, they all rely on bevel rubbing to control the cut. But how the initial cut is made to get the "bevel rubbing" and which part of the cutting edge is cutting is completely different. And with a skew, you can see where the edge is cutting. With a fingernail grind spindle or bowl gouge it's the BOTTOM of flute's edge that's cutting - obscured by the shaving coming off the wood.
Then there's the How To Increase Or Decrease the Aggerssiveness of the Cut thing. If you've driven a few old motorcycles you probably discovered there were TWO ways the throttle worked. With one, as your thumb went down and you knuckles up, you added power. Some called it a Suicide Throttle because in a hairy situation it was easy to add MORE POWER - when that was the last thing you wanted to do in that situation (think Wheelie and you're about to go over - backwards). The other throttle arrangement worked exactly the other way - thumb coming up, knuckles going down and you add power. If a wheelie starts going bad you automatically reduce the power as you begin falling backwards.
For the Suicide Throttle, you rotate the handle, looking in from the end of the handle bar, COUNTER CLOCKWISE to add power, with the other arrangement you rotate the handle CLOCKWISE to add power.
With a skew, rolling to the right, you rotate the straight line of the edge by rotating the tool clockwise, looking in from the end of the handle, to make a more aggressive cut. With a spindle or bowl gouge it's just the opposite. Rotating the gouge counter clockwise looking in from the end of the handle brings more of the bottom of the flute into the wood - increasing the aggressiveness of the cut.
SO - if you've developed Muscle Memory for a bowl or spindle gouge - and then pick up a skew - you've avoided since you've had a bad experience or two with one - any quess as to what's going to happen?
All of my turning experience was with a skew. In retrospect, it's no surprise that my first experience with a bowl gouge was s Shorts Changing Disaster that soured me on bowl gouges - and spindle gouges.
Then a friend gave me three tips for using bowl or spindle gouges.
1. With the bevel square to the surface of the wood, cut a tiny "step" into the wood with just the very tip of the fingernail grind.
2. With the bevel now in contact with the back of that little step,aim the bevel at where you want to go and make the cut, bevel rubbing throughout
3. Control the aggressiveness of the cut like you're using a Suicide Throttle on a bike (rotate counterclockwise, looking in from the end of the handle, to "add power", clockwise to "throttle back").
NOW bowl and spindle gouges are reached for when the best tool for the job - and I consciously reset my Muscle Memory to
Cut Step,
Contact The Bevel And Aim It,
Open Up The Throttle
- and it's off to the races - with wood streaming by instead of the wind!
If you've gotten used to using a spindle gouge and want to get into using a skew - maybe the Sorby Spindle Master might be a transition tool to try. It's sort of like a smushed flat on the top, fingernail grind spindle gouge - no long scary point to worry about.