Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Thoughts on the skew

Posts

Thoughts on the skew

#1

Keith Tompkins

Thoughts on the skew

Keith Tompkins

>If a poll was conducted on which tool is the most difficult to learn, I'm sure the skew chisel would selected by a wide margin. In skilled hands, the skew is almost magical....but the learning curve is so steep that the typical turner is only frustrated by the skew, and seldom reaches for it. In an attempt to make the tool a bit more user friendly, oval profile skews and curved-edge skews have been developed. Both have their drawbacks. In my illustration, I'll attempt to show just two weaknesses of the skew. In "A", imagine you are looking down on the skew being arched into the wood with the long point down....notice that attempting to take a deep cut results in the user trying to push a flat surface into the cut. This can be overcome only by taking small bites alternately from right then left, eventually creating a v- groove. The skew is favored for cleaning up end grain with a similar cut, but a much cleaner cut can be made with a spindle gouge, flute 90 degrees to the cut. (Don't believe it? try it) I feel the skew is a compromise; in order for the tool to cut in either direction, there must be a bevel on both sides of the tool. Illustration "B" shows one result of this. When making a planing cut, the upper bevel wants to pull the tool into the wood, represented by the dotted line. This becomes a real problem in highly figured grain; the edge tends to lift wood fibers when the grain direction changes. Again, spin up a piece of curly maple, and try to plane across the surface cleanly...not easy to do, even in expert hands. Cutting beads? No illustration needed! Cutting filets? You gotta' be good. My point is, if the tool is so hard to learn, and has so many drawbacks, why hasn't someone come up with something better? I've been experimenting for quite some time, and have developed two prototypes that have exceeded my expectations; either one handily outperforms the skew chisel in my own tests. Blasphemy, yes. But I just may be on to something!


img

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#2

I guess we'll just have to wait.

DavidWalser

>

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#3

Re: Thoughts on the skew

Tery Scott

>Thanks Keith

I enjoyed your explanation and approach to the Skew very informative

Me I don't know what all the fuss is about ,just rub the bevel at all times.l.o.l

My skew is second in the rack of favorite tools ,I use it for many differnt tasks from scraping share cutting ,to planing cuts.I even use in a negative rake to finish the outside of bowls and share cut the finishing cut inside

The secret is to practice get a 4 x 4 and turn it down to an egg cup ,by the end of a couple of hours youll be able to use one with eyes closed

Attached a photo of me cutting the wings on one of my Mantaray vessels

Cheers


img

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#4

Re: Thoughts on the skew

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>The skew is a great tool, very versatile, that will perform well when the user has learned how to use it and then practices with it. In my travels I encounter many people who want whatever tool I am using, because if I can use it that way, then they should be able to use it that way too. The answer is yes, but the missing component is practice.

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#5

Steven Antonucci

It's the bevel that kills most people

steve antonucci

>Many turners think they are on bevel and understand how important the bevel is, but truth be told, they're just thrilled that the wood is coming off, no matter what tool is in their hand. I see guys that have been turning for 30+ years who still don't get on bevel.

The skew is a great tool to learn because it provides instant feedback about how good your bevel rubbing skills are. Once you master the skew, I believe that ALL of your tool skills will improve because you will actually rub the bevel with them.

Steve

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#6

Re: Thoughts on the skew

john lucas

>Keith I have to take you to task on the double bevel thing. Every tool has a double bevel. If you grind a spindle gouge to a 35 degree bevel the flute becomes the upper bevel. What we call the included angle is that angle measured from both bevels. If you grind a skew to an included angle of 35 degrees the you have exactly the same thing as far as the wood is concerned. You will have to hold the too slightly differently. The spindle gouge in this description would be no different than a Bedan ground to 35 degrees. You still have to rub the bevel on either tool.

Also I can cut endgrain with my skew as well or better than the spindle gouge. It depends on how you use it. I hope I can make this clear. I've been trying to understand how tools cut and the actual cutting angles as they slice wood. Here's what I've found with the skew.

If you cut end grain the same way we cut a V groove, that is arcing in from the top by lifting the handle, the cutting edge starts at about 90 degrees to the rotation of the wood. As you lift the handle the angle the wood hits the edge is decreased slightly as you proceed into the cut. this is pictured below.


img

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#7

Part 2

john lucas

>Now if you start the cut with the toe but you start it with the handle high and the toe down low the wood passes the tool at a very low skew angle. It could be as low as 0 but usually you lower the handle a little to take a more aggressive cut. This gives an extremely clean cut. I tried it with my normal 35 degree skew, my 25 degree skew, and my convex bevel skew. The 25 left the cleanest cut and the convex bevel was hard to keep in the cut but it did cut clean.

I use this cut when I have punky wood. With the lathe speed up and little forward force of the skew you can get a really clean cut in nasty wood.

This is the same skew as in the first photo I just didn't readjust the lights to get the light to bounce off the edge. Lazy photographer.


img

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#8

Part 3

john lucas

>Here is the spindle gouge making the same cut. As you can see the edge being rounded is a little hard to say what angle is actually cutting the wood but it's safe to say that it's pretty steep which give a cut similar to the high angle skew. Consequently I can see why you would say that it gives the same cut.

This was a soft piece of glues up wood so it probably wasn't the most accurate test. I could not tell the difference it cut quality between it and the skews except the 25 degree skew required less forward pressure to do the cut.


img

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#9

results with skew

john lucas

>One thing I like about using the skew for this cut. You can take an extremely fine bite that leaves this cool really thin bowl. I haven't been able to do this with the round edge skew and it's more difficult with the 35 degree skew.

I don't claim to be an expert in tool usage and I'm certainly not an engineer and pretty lousy at math. Consequently I just try to understand the tools based on my past years using and sharpening all sorts of hand tools. If someone can explain it better I'm all ears. On a scale of 1 to 10 learning about how tools cut I think I'm up to about a 5.

I'll be heading out of down for a Demo in Ga in a few minutes so I won't be able to check back on this until late tonight.

I'm always interested in what Keith has to say because I know your skills.

By the way the ding in the thumb was from sticking my hand into a rectangular bowl. Bet Terry Scott never did that. :)


img

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#10

Re: Thoughts on the skew

Chuck Engstrom

>Hi Keith -- let us know if you get to the point of looking for beta testers. I do a fair amount of skew work on porch posts and chandelier spindles. Much of the time I use several sizes of square-stock tools usually sold as "parting tools" but as a certified tool-hound I'm open to trying anything that improves efficiency.

Good luck with it--

Chuck

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#11

Mike Stafford

Re: Thoughts on the skew

Mike Stafford

>I have been learning to use the skew. As Bill says it requires lots of practice.

I bought Alan Lacer's videos and have been using them as the basis for my education in the skew. I admit the exercises he advocates practicing have helped me a lot. Now I just need more practice.

Sharpening skill as it relates to a skew is just as important as tool use. A dull skew results in unsatisfactory results. I am getting better at both but it will be a while before I will be doing videos on using a skew.....

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#12

Re: Thoughts on the skew

charlie belden

>Keith:

If how you think a tool is to be used is based on the tool you're most familiar with, which I'm guessing is a spindle gouge or a bowl gouge, you may be starting off in the wrong direction from the get go.

I had the same problem with a spindle gouge, having learned to use the skew first - a curved cutting edge skew specifically - for EVERYTHING - roughing, V grooves, beads, coves, ogees and hollowing - plates, bowls, lidded boxes, finials - everything - except for parting off. Shear cuts or scraping cuts into end grain or side grain cuts - all done with a skew.

Then I tried to use a fingernail grind bowl gouge like I use a skew - and horrible things happened. Same thing with a fingernail grind spindle gouge. Things would go to hell in a handbasket as soon as I rocked the tool on it's rubbing bevel and made contact with the wood with the cutting edge. It was like trying to balance a marble on the tip of a pin. With a skew, you've got a straight line cutting edge. With a fingernail grind you've got TWO - changing direction - cutting edges on either side of the rounded tip. A slight twist of the wrist and the cut can get really aggressive really quickly.

Unlike a skew, which you can begin a groove with any part of the straight line of the cutting edge (looking down on the tool from above), the fingernail grind spindle or bowl gouge CAN cut anywhere along that curved fingernail grind cutting edge - and contact of that long constantly changing radius cutting edge with the far side of the cut you're trying to make - using a skew technique - gets you in trouble INSTANTLY.

The key point to note is the attempt to use a bowl or spindle gouge like a skew - or bedan. Yes, they all rely on bevel rubbing to control the cut. But how the initial cut is made to get the "bevel rubbing" and which part of the cutting edge is cutting is completely different. And with a skew, you can see where the edge is cutting. With a fingernail grind spindle or bowl gouge it's the BOTTOM of flute's edge that's cutting - obscured by the shaving coming off the wood.

Then there's the How To Increase Or Decrease the Aggerssiveness of the Cut thing. If you've driven a few old motorcycles you probably discovered there were TWO ways the throttle worked. With one, as your thumb went down and you knuckles up, you added power. Some called it a Suicide Throttle because in a hairy situation it was easy to add MORE POWER - when that was the last thing you wanted to do in that situation (think Wheelie and you're about to go over - backwards). The other throttle arrangement worked exactly the other way - thumb coming up, knuckles going down and you add power. If a wheelie starts going bad you automatically reduce the power as you begin falling backwards.

For the Suicide Throttle, you rotate the handle, looking in from the end of the handle bar, COUNTER CLOCKWISE to add power, with the other arrangement you rotate the handle CLOCKWISE to add power.

With a skew, rolling to the right, you rotate the straight line of the edge by rotating the tool clockwise, looking in from the end of the handle, to make a more aggressive cut. With a spindle or bowl gouge it's just the opposite. Rotating the gouge counter clockwise looking in from the end of the handle brings more of the bottom of the flute into the wood - increasing the aggressiveness of the cut.

SO - if you've developed Muscle Memory for a bowl or spindle gouge - and then pick up a skew - you've avoided since you've had a bad experience or two with one - any quess as to what's going to happen?

All of my turning experience was with a skew. In retrospect, it's no surprise that my first experience with a bowl gouge was s Shorts Changing Disaster that soured me on bowl gouges - and spindle gouges.

Then a friend gave me three tips for using bowl or spindle gouges.

1. With the bevel square to the surface of the wood, cut a tiny "step" into the wood with just the very tip of the fingernail grind.

2. With the bevel now in contact with the back of that little step,aim the bevel at where you want to go and make the cut, bevel rubbing throughout

3. Control the aggressiveness of the cut like you're using a Suicide Throttle on a bike (rotate counterclockwise, looking in from the end of the handle, to "add power", clockwise to "throttle back").

NOW bowl and spindle gouges are reached for when the best tool for the job - and I consciously reset my Muscle Memory to

Cut Step,

Contact The Bevel And Aim It,

Open Up The Throttle

- and it's off to the races - with wood streaming by instead of the wind!

If you've gotten used to using a spindle gouge and want to get into using a skew - maybe the Sorby Spindle Master might be a transition tool to try. It's sort of like a smushed flat on the top, fingernail grind spindle gouge - no long scary point to worry about.

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#13

Re: Thoughts on the skew

russ fairfield

>My observation is that most new, and many experienced, woodturners have to see the bevel before they can know where it is relative to the wood surface. The spindle gouge is easier to use because they can see the bevel, where thay cannot see the bevel on a skew chisel as they go around the corner.

I have always wondered if a new woodturner might find it easier to use a skew chisel with only one ground bevel. I learned to turn with such a tool, and I still find it easier to use a Skew with a single bevel because it just seems more natural to use than one with 2 ground bevels.

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: Thoughts on the skew

Keith Tompkins

>Russ, You must be reading my mind! That's a scary thought. When cutting beads in the traditional manner, the skew conceals the bead being cut. Many times you can't see the bead's profile until the bead is finished...by then, too late. My concept begins with a single bevel for both tools I'm working on (two different concepts, not a right and left)....I believe the only reason for the double bevel is so the tool can cut either right or left without switching tools.

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#15

What is old is new

Ron in Drums PA

>From 1927


img

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Thoughts on the skew

Keith Tompkins

>Hi John, I KNEW someone would take me to task on that one! The solution, as you know, is to rotate the tool and lower the handle so the upper bevel is parallel, or nearly so, to the surface being cut.

Judging by your photos, the first end grain cut is the traditional cut, while the second photo shows the side of the bevel rubbing, giving a cleaner cut. I agree the cut is cleaner but the likelyhood of a catch goes up; the second cut takes much more skill.

Now, try the end grain cut with the continental gouge, which is what I should have stated...cuts cleaner than the round gouge. I gotta' say...a turning session with you would be a blast!!

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: What is old is new

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Ron, Yep, same old tool, same old technique! Actually, the planing cut is quite easy to master, and the reason for the double bevel is obvious...the ability to cut from either direction without switching tools. What I'm considering is a tool to (gasp) replace the skew, being easier for the typical turner to master. After all, look at all the progress we've made in other areas, yet we rely on the same tool with very little development.

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: It's the bevel that kills most people

Keith Tompkins

>Steve, you've seen my unorthodox skew technique, which I developed over time to compensate for the skew's (in my opinion) shortcomings. My new tools will roll a bead far easier than the traditional skew, and make cutting pommels, tapers, and filets a simple task. Yes, leaving the bevel for a split second will ruin a turning in an instant.

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#19

Keith Tompkins

Re: Thoughts on the skew

Keith Tompkins

>Alan's videos are good, but I don't like the rounded edge he advocates...it makes using the points far more difficult to use, thereby reducing the effectiveness of the tool. I told him that... he was not amused.

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#20

Keith Tompkins

Re: Thoughts on the skew

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Charle, some good thoughts. My aim is to develop a tool whichs cuts like the gouge cut you describe...can't do it easily with a skew, although I've spent enough time working at it that it's become my regular technique. One of my grinds is so simple that I'm amazed it's not a commonplace tool...perhaps we just assume the skew is the ultimate design so don't bother to attempt an improvement?

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#21

Mike Stafford

Re: Thoughts on the skew

Mike Stafford

>I use skews ground both straight and curved and see almost no difference. Of course that could be because I am not proficient enough to know.

I will say for certain operations I do find the straight skew long point easier to place where I want it. I also find it easier to sharpen the straight skew.

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#22

Keith Tompkins

Re: Thoughts on the skew

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Mike, in order to form a curved cutting edge, the long and short point must be ground away. Then, when attempting to use either end, the curved edge above the cutting point hits the wood, creating a disaster. just my observations.

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#23

Would you come and demo?

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>I think many of us would be delighted to attend...

Cheers

Jorge

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#24

Re: Thoughts on the skew

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Mike,

I like my skew edges straight and the bevels flat, so I use an oil stone to sharpen. I grind only occasionally when the edge gets a nick.

my $0.02

Jorge

Re: Thoughts on the skew

#25

Nice tool rest!

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>