Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

Posts

Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

#1

Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

Barry Irby

>Has anyone turned a hollow for with crotch grain? (I know that's a rhetorical question)

I have a walnut branch union (See, I can be PC) and was wondering how to make the wild grain show up on a hollow form. How would you cut the blank?

Re: Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

#2

Re: Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>All pieces of wood like this have two piths to consider. It has been my experience that most walnut is pretty stable so the pith inclusion if necessary might not be an issue. How much pith free figured wood you will have depends upon how large the log is.

I would turn the typical end grain hollow form to maximize the figure. To get the blank I would probably try to saw the crotch through both piths and then cut the blank based on the figure. As you get out toward the bark, the figure will disappear.

The other possibility with a crotch is to saw it 90 degrees to the way mentioned above. This way instead of getting the typical flame figure it will resemble a sunburst.

Because of my sawing experience, I would be more likely to use the crotch figure for plates than hollow forms as it is easier to retain the figure.

Either way, once you decide how to make that initial cut, it will be easier to make a decision as you will be able to see the figure.

I hope I haven't confused you.

Re: Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

#3

Re: Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

Ron in Drums PA

>Hi Barry

I did one just like that this past spring

Walnut hollow form

Re: Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

#4

Re: It doesn't work well because most....

JamieD

>...of the crotch feather will be inside the vessel and turned away. Size will also determine how much of the feather will be visible on the outside, but go for it to see what you can do.

Re: Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

#5

Re: It doesn't work well because most....

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>That is why I make plates/platters from the crotch figure.

Re: Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

#6

Re: It doesn't work well because most....

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

>If it's big enough, cut it so the crotch is offcenter, It will then be on the outside on one side. It can be spectatular.

John

Re: Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

#7

Re: Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Barry,

I make platters and occasionally bowls using the crutch,

Y slice the Y in the plane of all centers, an then, if there is a flame in there, that side becomes the bottom of the bowl or platter.

I never tried a vase

Jorge

Re: Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

#8

Re: Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Hi Barbara,

you said "The other possibility with a crotch is to saw it 90 degrees to the way mentioned above. This way instead of getting the typical flame figure it will resemble a sunburst."

Could you show us the cut and the resulting sunburst?

I always love to learn a new thing

Gracias

Jorge

Re: Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

#9

Re: Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Jorge, I would love to show you but I am not sure how. Are you asking about the positioning of the cut or the appearance of the figure?

Re: Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

#10

Re: Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Barbara,

I guess the positioning of the cut is what I want to know mostly.

Thanks

Jorge

Re: Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

#11

Re: Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Instead of cutting parallel to the piths, you cut directly through the crotch at 90 degrees to the normal pith cut. You end up with two pieces with a pith in each.

Re: Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

#12

Thank you!

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>

Re: Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

#13

Re: It doesn't work well because most.... *LINK*

George Guadiane

>This one was done with the crotch figure off center, I really liked the results:


"Blazing Summer Sun"

Re: Question on Crotch Grain/Hollow forms

#14

Re: It doesn't work well because most.... *LINK*

George Guadiane

>This was the only image of this piece I could find, and the figure was weak here... 90 degree rotation showed what looked like lightning bolts running up and down.

The crotch line was set dead in the center of the piece... My son has it:


Cherry Crotch