Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Life is too short to turn crappy wood......

Posts

Life is too short to turn crappy wood......

#1

Life is too short to turn crappy wood......

Barry Irby

>Credit to who ever said it first, but they are right A month or so ago I mentioned I ruined a big walnut bowl blank while discovering my Mcnaughton system had been ruined whiled loaned out. So, I cut the funnel in half and repaired it by gluing in two segments. My next step was to true it up and glue a bottom onto it and turn it into a working bowl. I used Loctite Epoxy and let it cure over night in the house where it was warm. The joints failed. The glue is still gummy as if it did not cure. I was very careful mixing the glue. Have had it for a few months, but it was stored in the house. Should have known better. Should have either bought fresh glue of a better brand or trashed the wood and moved on.

Re: Life is too short to turn crappy wood......

#2

Re: Life is too short to turn crappy wood......

Marc Phillips

>I dunno.... I think it is usually worth the effort to try and salvage something... as a learning experience if nothing else.

I believe "you never know til ya try" :)

Re: Life is too short to turn crappy wood......

#3

Crappy Epoxy . . . ??

Doc Green

>My first thought is that the epoxy was ...crappy. Not all are created equal, in my opinion. I no longer buy epoxy or CA from home centers or hardware stores. Hobby shops and etc have much better stuff.

Just my $0.02. ~Doc

Re: Life is too short to turn crappy wood......

#4

Re: Life is too short to turn crappy wood......

Rick Allen

>Epoxy bad? Could be, but not likely. I use West System and though it is pricy I have always had good success with this brand.

I get the quart of resin and the proper sized hardener (pint). I also get the pumps which meter out the correct amount of resin and hardener.

The other concern with epoxy is to be sure that there is some glue in the joint. To much pressure will squeeze out all the glue.

I will often glue endgrain with epoxy. It is important to make sure both surfaces are "wet". This may mean that epoxy is applied several times before the joint is put together. If the joint is less than perfect I like to use a filler with the last application of epoxy. That filler is often colored for the effect I am looking for.

Good joints

Surfaces look wet before clamping the wood together

Use a filler if the joint is less than perfect

Clamp to position the pieces but don't clamp so hard that all the epoxy is squeezed out

BTW - epoxy is a wonderful glue for turning. The glue is very strong, fills gaps, has an open time based on the temperature and hardener used and takes color well. With the right filler epoxy sands wonderfully. Epoxy cures hard and prevents wood movement creep but also has a little flexibility to absorb shock and allow some seasonal wood movement.

Re: Life is too short to turn crappy wood......

#5

Re: Life is too short to turn crappy wood......

steve worcester

>John Jordan said it, BTW

Re: Life is too short to turn crappy wood......

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Life is too short to turn crappy wood......

Keith Tompkins

>5 minute epoxy never hardens....maybe that's it. After being in the furniture business and having to grade and select lumber, I still can't bring myself to turn a nasty looking piece of wood. Some say that's a problem. Maybe.

Re: Life is too short to turn crappy wood......

#7

Re: Life is too short to turn crappy wood......

Texian

>No doubt John Jordan's "saying" is taken out of context, and it is unfortunate to see it thus repeated so frequently. One turner's "crappy wood" may be another turner's prize wood. Many turners probably cannot afford to purchase wood that meets John's standards, but I am sure he would not wish them to give up turning whatever wood they have available.

That said, nothing wrong with trying to make a good save. Sand the joint surfaces smooth and flat and glue with Titebond II. The wood will usually fail before a properly made joint with PVA glue.

Re: Life is too short to turn crappy wood......

#8

Re: Life is too short to turn crappy wood......

Barry Turner

>If "Crappy Wood" includes burls, spalted wood and wood with obvious knotholes and other defects, I fear that woodturning is about to get extremely boring.............

Re: Life is too short to turn crappy wood......

#9

Re: Life is too short to turn crappy wood......

Lewis Dodd

>Well, I think the intended end desire of the piece and its use determines it's "crappability" Wormy and spalted wood can be turned with care and often a lot of CA glue, result in some spectacular pieces. I most often retain wormy mesquite and have turned some nice looking pieces out of certain fruit wood, like plum, peach and pear. Wormy wood is not suitable for chair rails of course. Turning wood mistakes or "blow ups" are like riding a motorcycle, you never get lost , you just take alternate routes initially unintended!! I have a fellow turner friend that has such a delicate touch, you stand back in amazement as to how he kept the wood together to get a finished piece which I would have considered trash to start with. There is definitely a "crappability scale" IMHO, or is that "in the eyes of the beholder". A lot of wood starts out as firewood anyway, so it may end up as such at the end of the turning process, so what!

Lewis

Lewis

Re: Life is too short to turn crappy wood......

#10

Re: Life is too short to turn crappy wood......

Barry L Elder

>My retort to the "crappy wood" is that anyone can turn perfect wood! The difference is that with perfect wood, it is usually so boring that "form" is very important. I find that by using wood with a little "character", it is likely to cover my faults and inexperience. Kudos to the artists whose form is always excellent while I will continue to experiment with my fallibilities.